Woman, 92, dies in shootout with police...

If they had the wrong house, she was totally justified. If strange men started breaking my door down, I'd shoot them, too.

Either way, this War on Drugs is just ticking me off. The drugs haven't stopped, but 92 year old ladies are being shot and killed. I wish they'd just give up and legalize the drugs.
 
Cool-Beans said:
If they had the wrong house, she was totally justified. If strange men started breaking my door down, I'd shoot them, too.

Either way, this War on Drugs is just ticking me off. The drugs haven't stopped, but 92 year old ladies are being shot and killed. I wish they'd just give up and legalize the drugs.[/QUOTE]


Seriously...like heroin, cocaine, meth :confused3...it puzzles me that someone would think this way.
 
Cool-Beans said:
If they had the wrong house, she was totally justified. If strange men started breaking my door down, I'd shoot them, too.
It was the correct house!

Also they identified themselves with warrant in hand.

So if the police ever show up at your house and announce their presence, your first reaction would be to shoot at them? :confused3
 
Cool-Beans said:
If they had the wrong house, she was totally justified. If strange men started breaking my door down, I'd shoot them, too.

If they identified themselves as the police, even if they had the wrong house, there is no way in heck her shooting them was justified.
 
The Mystery Machine said:
Why are plainclothes police kicking down her door....sorry sounds over the top to me.

There was a better way to handle it, imo.

I agree with police brutality.


ITA, as a previous poster mentioned, she culd have had poor hearing or perhaps didn't believe that the officeers were actually cops. if they are working undercover, they often dress like the guys they are trying to catch. it seems to me that stand offs have been handled before without shooting. they didn't do enough.
 
The Mayor said:
Cool-Beans said:
If they had the wrong house, she was totally justified. If strange men started breaking my door down, I'd shoot them, too.

Either way, this War on Drugs is just ticking me off. The drugs haven't stopped, but 92 year old ladies are being shot and killed. I wish they'd just give up and legalize the drugs.[/QUOTE]


Seriously...like heroin, cocaine, meth :confused3...it puzzles me that someone would think this way.

Yes, just like those things. I have yet to meet a person who says, "the only reason I don't shoot heroine, smoke crack, etc. is because it's illegal. If drugs were legalized I'd be the first one in line for the crack pipe!!!" The war on drugs is a loosing proposition - but that's a topic for a whole other thread...
 
Miss Jasmine said:
It was the correct house!

Also they identified themselves with warrant in hand.

So if the police ever show up at your house and announce their presence, your first reaction would be to shoot at them? :confused3
No, if they knocked and I heard it, I'd go see what was up. But if I didn't know who the men breaking my door in were, I'd shoot them. For me, that's a shoot first, ask questions later kind of situation.
 
DawnCt1 said:
ITA, as a previous poster mentioned, she culd have had poor hearing or perhaps didn't believe that the officeers were actually cops. if they are working undercover, they often dress like the guys they are trying to catch. it seems to me that stand offs have been handled before without shooting. they didn't do enough.


There was no stand-off. She shot them. Repeatedly. How were they supposed to handle it?
 
Cool-Beans said:
No, if they knocked and I heard it, I'd go see what was up. But if I didn't know who the men breaking my door in were, I'd shoot them. For me, that's a shoot first, ask questions later kind of situation.

They announce and have to wait a certain number of seconds before entering. She had enough time to grab the gun and start shooting... They also come in with guns pulled and scan the room looking for people while yelling "Police!" You can, of course, start shooting but it won't end well.
 
DawnCt1 said:
ITA, as a previous poster mentioned, she culd have had poor hearing or perhaps didn't believe that the officeers were actually cops. if they are working undercover, they often dress like the guys they are trying to catch. it seems to me that stand offs have been handled before without shooting. they didn't do enough.

This wasn't a "standoff". This was a woman firing (and hitting) police who seemingly followed proper procedures.
 
The Mayor said:
Seriously...like heroin, cocaine, meth :confused3...it puzzles me that someone would think this way.
Since the war on drugs didn't work, but people keep dying, and innocent people are killed in the crossfire, I think this War should end.

Kind of like the War on Booze. Let the holier-than-thou people get all worked up about the travesty, and the evil to society about it being legal...and let the killing end.
 
mrsltg said:
My husband worked vice. They are almost always in plainclothes. They announce in the moments before knocking down the door as the element of surprise is generally needed.

How were they supposed to handle it? They had a warrant. They announced themselves and entered. What were they supposed to do?

Exactly what they did .............. and they killed a 92-year old woman. End of story.
 
mrsltg said:
They announce and have to wait a certain number of seconds before entering. She had enough time to grab the gun and start shooting... They also come in with guns pulled and scan the room looking for people while yelling "Police!" You can, of course, start shooting but it won't end well.
Criminals could bust in and yell "Police!", too. And I'm not familiar enough with badges to know a fake one from a real one. If I were running a drug house and had a good idea why the cops showed up, no I wouldn't start shooting.

But as it stands, I'll assume anyone breaking into the house has no good reason for it, and they will be shot.

We had a story on the news last night in Cleveland about an old man who shot a couple teenagers who forced their way into his house. They arrested the guy. Wish I could be on that Grand Jury.
 
I think we need to wait for more info because everyone is reporting the event with 2 different scenarios-probably to confuse us---They are reporting that she opened fire as they entered the yard AND saying they broke down the door then she started firing.

It'd be nice to know exactly what happened but I doubt we ever will.
 
juligrl said:
Sometimes you'd think police go around shooting people just for the heck of it! I mean seriously why would an officer just randomly want to shoot someone? They hate doing paperwork as much as the next person and as my sister says that'd require waaaay too much paperwork.
Don't you hate it when you shoot and kill somebody. All that tiresome paperwork.
 
Bob Slydell said:
This wasn't a "standoff". This was a woman firing (and hitting) police who seemingly followed proper procedures.


while they may have followed procedure, they could have called for back up, evacuated the injured and made an attempt to communicate with the occupant of the house. it seems to me that there was an alternative that they could have attempted. perhaps she sat with a gun because she lived in a high crime area.
 
I don't know why anyone would want to be a police officer in this day and age...look at the opinions here on the DIS, as a cross-section of the ocuntry.

"The police shouldn't have shot a 92 year old woan who was shooting at them". I'd be interested to know what the cut-off age is in people's minds when it is OK for the police to shoot back if you are shooting at them.

"This is police brutality" No, this is the police doing their job.

"A 92 year old can'rt hear well, see well, may be confused". Yet, she was able to "lock and load" a gun and shoot 2 or 3 police officers in what one would assume was a fairly short period of time. Kind of sounds to me like the gun may have been loaded and some folks were waiting for the cops to come.

Look, I know it's unfathomable to many people to think that every 92 year old isn't like your sweet little Grandma or Great-Grandma, baking apple pies and giving you squishy hugs, but there are older people who have lived a life or crime and degradation and wouldn't hesitate to kill you where you stood if it suited their purposes.

And you know...a couple of weeks ago, the DISers were ready to fry the 90-something year old guy that ran over and killed a bunch of people, but the lady who shot the cops...she's a poor old thing and it's the cops' fault.

We live in an amazing world. :sad2:
 
Cool-Beans said:
Since the war on drugs didn't work, but people keep dying, and innocent people are killed in the crossfire, I think this War should end.

.
thats tantamount to saying lets legalize crime and then there would be no criminals.
 
Im not saying the police were wrong in what they did at all, however you need look at it from both perspectives.
T
hey came to the door, knocked and announced...

no answer...the 92 year old woman maybe didn't hear what they were saying clearly, may see strange men on her door step and become frightened, grabs a gun, waits, hopes they just go away.

The plain clothes police follow procedure and breakdown the door, the women thinks several men are breaking in, fires, it doesn't say how many times, could have been once with buck shot spraying or several times with a low caliber weapon, (assuming since the officers wounds were not very serious for being shot). The officers upon hearing gunfire, shoot back.

There are always two perspectives, the cops are fearing the worst, as she must have been.

What I see as strange is the fact that they say the warrant was legal. But that doesn't mean that the legal warrant did not have a mistakenly wrong address. If she was the only resident as reported I find it hard to believe a 92 year old grandmother was a narcotics dealer. This house/woman would have had to be watched for a while to know that and they were not expecting a 92 year old woman. Something is not right.
 
DawnCt1 said:
while they may have followed procedure, they could have called for back up, evacuated the injured and made an attempt to communicate with the occupant of the house. it seems to me that there was an alternative that they could have attempted. perhaps she sat with a gun because she lived in a high crime area.
I am sure there was plenty of back-up on scene. When a search warrant is executed, there are more than three officers there. I'm sorry but when officers are being shot at they are allowed to use lethal force. You want them to yell time out?
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom