I'd go with WL CL myself, but I've never stayed at CR, it's just not our style while at wdw. We like having a constant theme at the disney resorts, that's part of the fun for us. For me the benefits of staying CL are worth it too.
You've stayed at both? So you already know the pros and cons. Personally, we'd choose CR because of the ease of getting to MK (we love to walk to parks!), Chef Mickeys, and the ability to watch Wishes in full without being at MK. We also love WL, don't get me wrong, but we'd go with what works best for our particular family and that would be CR.