I have to share my story of this restaurant. It was my first vacation alone to Disney and I booked WCC because I was on the dining plan and I wanted to see the Lodge.
I had to wait to be seated, and, while waiting, I realized what the restaurant did as far as entertainment. However, the waitstaff, thinking I wanted a quiet dinner, put me in the back next to a romantic fireplace (not so romantic by myself). I quickly asked to be moved up front with all the families. After being moved, I orded and received the prime rib, which was very good. Somewhere near dessert, I called my cousin to fill her in on what I had done for the day. Well, this was a mistake, because my waitress started yelling to the whole restaurant, hey, keep it down, can't you see she's on the phone. So, she then asks whom I am speaking with, to which I answered, "Amy." So she then has the entire restaurant say, "Hello Amy." My cousin was hysterical on the phone and has made me promise the next time she goes to Disney with me that I will take her there.
So there you have it, I think you should go. And, if you, by chance go during Christmas, you get a chance to see the Lodge decorated beautifully.
Enjoy!