Will there ever be A La Carte cable or Why do I need 9 channels of ESPN?

sdarwkcabemanmy

<font color=blue>Not only do I not know what's goi
Joined
Oct 23, 2007
Messages
2,572
I really, really, REALLY wish we had the ability to pick/choose which cable channels we got or didn't get.

I would LOVE to trade the nine channels of ESPN we get (which we never watch) for Sprout, The Science Channel, Discovery Investigation and Boomerang.

Because honestly, who needs 9 channels of ESPN/FSN anyway?:confused3
 
True a la carte is not actually what anyone really wants, if they think it all the way through. The reason is that people won't be happy with the a la carte price. Figure each a la carte choice would cost roughly 1/3 to 1/4 the price of the tier that channel is on, and having a la carte choices would require an unbundling of the basic extended tier's service access from the cost of the channels for that tier. So instead of paying $50 for extended basic, you'd pay $35 for extended basic access, and then $3-$4 per channel on that tier you'd want. Instead of paying $10.95 for the upgrade from Preferred to Silver, you'd pay $3-$4 for each channel on that tier you'd want. For the vast majority of subscribers, there would be only a small difference in the price you'd pay, and for many, a la carte would simply be more expensive than paying for the currently available tiers.
 
I really, really, REALLY wish we had the ability to pick/choose which cable channels we got or didn't get.

I would LOVE to trade the nine channels of ESPN we get (which we never watch) for Sprout, The Science Channel, Discovery Investigation and Boomerang.

Because honestly, who needs 9 channels of ESPN/FSN anyway?:confused3

I work for FSN....:lmao: Get rid of the ESPN...:smokin:

The packages are beneficial for the sale of advertising, also. Sales staffs can offer several different channels to play a client's commercial instead of just one. Also, it costs the cable channel very little to air the other channels, so for SALES it's a win win situation.

I have a zillion channels, too... LOTS of which my son watch, I hardly watch 6 of them. You can do like I did, eliminate the channels from your TV so you don't have to sale thru them.
 
I have TiVo, so how do I elminate channels from the lineup?

Because honestly, there are quite a few channels I would love to never see again--HSN, QVC, the umptyump number of ESPN/FSN...

In order to get Sprout and Boomerang, we'd have to go up another tier which would only add more channels I don't care for (Oxygen, WE, etc).

I JUST WANT SPROUT FOR GOSHDARNSAKES!:lmao:
 
Do you have the stand-alone TiVo, or do you have the Comcast TiVo.

If you have the stand-alone TiVo, go into the program guide and hit Enter. Then switch to "Favorite Channels". Then go into Settings and set up your favorite channels, including only those you want to see in the guide.
 
True a la carte is not actually what anyone really wants, if they think it all the way through.
Is there any part of you that qustions the cable company logic before passing it along? Anything that says, "hmm, would the cable companies really *have* to charge me about the same price for fewer channels?" But, let's assume the cable companies are 100% correct.
For the vast majority of subscribers, there would be only a small difference in the price you'd pay,
Having the vast majority of subscibers pay less - even if it's only a small difference - is a GOOD thing.
 
and i dont think 9 channels of espn is enough. go figure.
 
certain towns allow you to choose what channels you want.

with comcast I had to get the super trybinium sphere package just to get speed channel to watch the formula one races. It was like $130 a month!!!

so obviously we do not have comcast anymore.

Mikeeee
 
Is there any part of you that qustions the cable company logic before passing it along?
I question everything. My comments are my informed opinion, based on a substantial understanding of both the industry and business, in general. I will grant you that there isn't happy news, here, for consumers. That's life.

Beyond that, since it seems that you are expressing frustration, I'll forgive your scurrilous implication.

Having the vast majority of subscibers pay less - even if it's only a small difference - is a GOOD thing.
And to think that that will happen is unreasonable. Suppliers set pricing based on perceived value. Letting folks get rid of channels they don't value in the first place won't reduce their perception of the value of the service as a whole, and so will not reduce the price they pay.
 
We have the standalone TiVo because we live in an area where we can ONLY get one cable company, which really sucks. We only recently got DSL out here because nobody else would come out this far and the cable company (which also does the gas, electricity and phone) finally got enough complaints about not having it.
 
This was probably 15 years ago but my grandfather had somehow conned his local cable company into providing just the local tier (local networks and community access) and TBS. He was a big Braves fan and he didn't want to give up the ability to see his team. I think they got 9 channels total for about $9 per month.

All I really want is my local "big 4" channels, TWC, CNN, Bravo, ESPN, ESPN2, MASN, Food Network, the Travel Channel, PBS, Noggin, Sprout, and Disney Channel.
 
That's actually not that uncommon, HamTown. Here, it is $8.50 per month for the local broadcast channels, community access, plus two cable channels (Style and Speed). In some places, they include WGN in the lifeline tier; in other places, TBS; in other places, I think it is WPIX from New York.
 
I took the idea that the vast majority of subscibers would pay less directly from your post.
Then you're reading too much into it. The most important part of my message was the part about, for the vast majority, the difference would be small.

Suppliers set pricing based on what they can get away with.
Apparently, we agree. I don't understand your earlier message, then. :confused3
 
I checked and Charter does provide WGN with its basic package, along with QVC, TBN (which I guess for me could be considered local) and a few other random things. I had no idea that was considered basic, but then again, I never watch WGN unless I find America's Funniest Videos on while channel surfing.
 
Yes: I've heard Charter is the double-whammy -- among the worst for its consumers and not good for its investors.
 
and i dont think 9 channels of espn is enough. go figure.

You can have our ESPN channels. :lmao: In fact, I'll trade you all of them and throw in the GOLF channel for the Travel Channel. I honestly cannot fathom having an entire channel devoted to golf but...hey, I guess it takes all kinds.

I agree with the OP--I really wish we were able to pick a certain number of channels that we would actually watch instead of a zillion stupid channels.
 
Then you're reading too much into it. The most important part of my message was the part about, for the vast majority, the difference would be small.
A small difference is better than no difference. If this will save most people money, it's a good thing.

The cable company argument is that (1) offering choices will be bad for consumers and (2) the cable companies don't want to offer choice because it will be bad of consumers.

First, I believe that when you offer people more choices, it's almost better for them. I don't see anything extraordinary about the cable business that would negate that.

And the second part is almost laughable. The cable companies aren't in business for the good of consumers. They are in business for the good of cable companies. If they won't offer ala cart pricing, it's because it's good for the cable company profits. Profits which come from consumers. The fact that the companies won't offer ala cart pricing is almost prima facie evidence that ala cart pricing would save folks money.
 
A lot of channels, from the providers standpoint are....if you want to offer A you need to take B, C and D along with it.

For example...the cost of carrying ESPN is covered in the main channels of ESPN & ESPN2. The actual cost to add ESNPU, ESPN Classics and ESPNews (if anyone really has 9 ESPNs let me know what I'm missing!) is virtually nill for the Cable / Sat companies.

So if a la carte were available and you wanted to drop all 5 ESPN's it may save you $1.20. If you wanted to keep ESPN and drop the other 4 channels it may save you all of $0.20.
 
A small difference is better than no difference. If this will save most people money, it's a good thing.
Not necessarily. If it saves you a dollar or so per month, but then one of your special interests is no longer served, because too few people subscribed to that channel, then that's a big loss, in my book. Critics love to poo-poo the idea but it is real: If a la carte becomes commonplace, you can say goodbye to a bunch of niche interest channels. For folks with strictly mainstream tastes, no big deal. I personally don't think any of my channels would be decommissioned. However, I think beyond my own needs, and recognize how bad this would be for others.

First, I believe that when you offer people more choices, it's almost better for them.
Which is why switching to a pricing structure where niche interest channels will be more likely to fail isn't a GOOD thing.

And the second part is almost laughable. The cable companies aren't in business for the good of consumers.
No one ever said they were. I wonder what you're actually responding to. :confused3

They are in business for the good of cable companies.
And if they weren't, I'd be the first one to find them guilty of fiscal irresponsibility. It isn't their money to mess with. They're supposed to make all their decisions in their owners' best financial interests. We don't need a cable company ENRON-type situation. The owners' interests should always be paramount.

Profits which come from consumers. The fact that the companies won't offer ala cart pricing is almost prima facie evidence that ala cart pricing would save folks money.
Uh, no. Your logic is faulty. The fact that the cable companies won't offer ala cart pricing is evidence that the cable companies would make more money the way things are. BIG difference.

As it is, to be clear, I think that consumers would save a small amount, and lose niche interest channels, and that's not a "GOOD" trade.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom