The rooms are definitely smaller. We decided to do Wilderness Lodge once just to try other resorts though didn't have high expectations as we usually stayed at Beach Club, Grand Floridian, Animal Kingdom or Boardwalk. Only stayed there once but I want to go back for our next trip, whenever that will be. Although the rooms are smaller, they are very nice and I think they may have been renovated since. The resort itself is so lovely with decent food options. We were considering a DVC purchase (put on hold for the near term) and this is where we would have bought points. It's just so nice to walk around the grounds - you really feel like you're in the pacific northwest walking through pathways between the trees. Two really nice pools. Geyser Point is really nice to get a drink or a snack and sit there in the open area or go sit by the water and watch the electric water parade while you eat or drink. Get a quick breakfast from Roaring Forks and eat it outside. And for the price compared to BC/YC, it's really good value IMO.