why the lack of love for larger families?

I would not want to rent Disney Vacation Club points from a private party.

I want to deal with the resort and not with some unrelated person who may be difficult to reach by phone.

I want the flexibility of adjusting dates if a flight gets cancelled or a hurricane strikes.
 
Were they not allowing you to upgrade anymore? I know last year I upgraded and I think it was only $10 a night per adult.

I booked online and had no idea I could even do that!!! I am still outside my window so I may call and check on that. I could handle that much :). Thanks!
 
I booked online and had no idea I could even do that!!! I am still outside my window so I may call and check on that. I could handle that much :). Thanks!

Here are the prices for 2012:

QSDP
■Adults (Ages 10+) : $34.99 per day
■Children: (Ages 3-9): $11.99 per day


DDP
■Adults (Ages 10+) : $51.54 per day (regular season) / $53.54 per day (peak season)
■Children: (Ages 3-9): $15.02 per day (regular season) / $16.02 per day (peak season)


So the increase is a little like $16-$18 per person per night. For our upcoming trip the prices are more like $21 per person(x4) per night(x6), and at that price we can throw a table service meal in when ever we want and still have the two counter services meals per day.
 
The issue isn't escaping from the room, it's escaping from the burning building. The number of people trying to escape using stairs is limited by the number of stairs, width of the stairs, etc.

You are focussing on the room and that is only one part of the equation. After getting out of the room you have to get out of the building within the code specified time. Getting out of the room is as simple as opening the door. But you've got to get from there to the outside before smoke overwhelms you and, as explained to me, that can happen very fast. That's the biggest worry, not the flames. And it's why even if you don't see flames or smoke you should exit as soon as you hear the alarm. You've got even less time when you actually see the smoke.

The hotel stairwells, corridors etc must accommodate sufficient people per minute to get everyone out before the toxic effects occur. When a child is carried, it and the parent take up 1 person space. That's why infants, often under 3 by definition, are often not counted in the fire code person count. Note some jurisdictions still might count them.

Architects, engineers and firemen know this stuff in better detail than I as a hotelier do but that is how it's explained to us in seminars. Take alarms and room restrictions seriously, they are for your safety.

While I am totally aware that it isn't just escaping from the room that causes the issues, I still stand by my statement. There is no age limit on the person sleeping on the trundle bed at POR and the walkways for those rooms are no wider than for the rooms without trundle beds. What would be their reason for limiting the number of people staying in the Cabins? There are no walkways because you go directly to the outside. If the issue was just the number of people on the walkways and stairs then they would not allow visitors on property to visit guests.

While I completely understand that they need to put a limit of some kind, I think it is ridiculous that they don't allow roll-aways for one extra person. They could designate a certain number of rooms, ON THE GROUND FLOOR, as rooms with roll-away usage.
 
We are a family of 6 and this is our 1st trip. We decided on the cabins and I am excited to get there and try it out. Not sure what we will do for the next trip. I can see us staying offsite at some point but I really like the free dining option we got staying onsite. I too wish there were more options but I can understand why it is geared to a family of 4. I guess I should say that 6 of us will be in the cabins and the two grandma's will be staying at POP.
 
I agree with the PP's that say that Disney DOES have lots of options for families of 5.

There are the Deluxe resorts, cabins, POR, family suites, connecting rooms at any resort and of course, DVC.

Personally, I don't think they are adding Suites to the Moderates because that would compete directly against DVC sales. Right now, they do offer the Family Suites at the AS Music and soon to be, Art of Animation Resort. I just don't think that the Value resorts compete too much against DVC sales.

We've stayed in a Family Suite and we've stayed DVC. There is a big difference in the rooms, resort and amenities IMO. Because of these differences, many people will buy into DVC. We held off buying into DVC as historically, the 1BR villas would not sleep 5. However, the two most recent WDW DVC resorts (Kidani at AKL and BLT) sleep 5 in a 1BR, plus there are two bathrooms in a 1BR. That was a big part of our decision to buy into DVC after not doing it for years. For us, it actually works out to be slightly less per night to stay in a 2BR standard view room at BLT than it does to stay at the All-Star Music (taking into consideration our annual dues and amortization of our initial buy-in). YMMV Granted, we can never take advantage of "free dining" or discounts, but those were rare for the Family Suites historically. Regardless, the extra room and differences in the resorts make it worth it for us when compared to the All-Star Family Suite. If Disney had a similar Family Suite at a Moderate, we may not have bought into DVC. I think that may be the case for others as well.

We stayed recently in Hays, KS when driving across Kansas to visit my parents. We paid more for a Holiday Inn Express room that slept all 5 of us than we paid have paid in the past for POR or even two connecting rooms at the All-Stars (granted the WDW rooms were discounted). Not to mention all the off-site accomodations in Orlando that are so cheap. This past summer, we stayed at the Vistana 2-BR condo for $119 per night as we decided to extend our stay and we had no more DVC points for the year. The Vistana Resort condo had about 1,100 square feet including a full-size kitchen, a dining area with a large dining table, a master BR with a king size bed, jacuzzi tub, two sinks, shower and a second BR with two queen beds and a large bathroom. Not to mention the laundry room/pantry and a large living room with a pull out double sofa as well as a large screened deck with table/chairs and ceiling fan. The room slept 8. There are definately reasonable choices for families who visit WDW or Orlando, as well as some very expensive options too.
 
While I completely understand that they need to put a limit of some kind, I think it is ridiculous that they don't allow roll-aways for one extra person. They could designate a certain number of rooms, ON THE GROUND FLOOR, as rooms with roll-away usage.

They do allow and offer rollaways... There is supposed to be an add'l charge for one but we have never been charged and we have had a rollaway at CBR and CSR... POR also has rollaways available, you just have to ask.
 
While I am totally aware that it isn't just escaping from the room that causes the issues, I still stand by my statement. There is no age limit on the person sleeping on the trundle bed at POR and the walkways for those rooms are no wider than for the rooms without trundle beds. What would be their reason for limiting the number of people staying in the Cabins? There are no walkways because you go directly to the outside. If the issue was just the number of people on the walkways and stairs then they would not allow visitors on property to visit guests.

While I completely understand that they need to put a limit of some kind, I think it is ridiculous that they don't allow roll-aways for one extra person. They could designate a certain number of rooms, ON THE GROUND FLOOR, as rooms with roll-away usage.
I think it's more than just safety. I think it also has to do with overtaxing the property as a whole. POR expects a certain number of five-person parties, based on their standard bedding configuration. They plan for this - equipment, staffing, supplies, stock... it's entirely likely given all the options available to parties of 5+, WDW isn't willing to overtax the Value or other Moderate resorts by allowing more than four Guests per room.

As for restricting rollaways to the first floor, that would work for about three days - until the first person started yelling about 'discrimination against large families' because they couldn't get the top floor room they wanted.
 
While I am totally aware that it isn't just escaping from the room that causes the issues, I still stand by my statement. There is no age limit on the person sleeping on the trundle bed at POR and the walkways for those rooms are no wider than for the rooms without trundle beds.

You are missing the fact that the Alligator Bayou buildings are indeed different than the Mansion buildings. They AB buildings are only 2 levels high, and they do not have elevators. The Mansion buildings are 3 or 4 levels high, and do have elevators. Both things affect how many people are allowed to occupy each building.

Also, Disney does not guarantee any room type at all. Even paid for ones, and I can attest to. There would be no way to truly designate those rooms as roll away rooms. And even if they did, your room is not your room until you have a key in hand.
 
Our family is a family of 5, and now they are all at an age where they count (over 3). We have stayed in 2 bed villas (booked though Disney), rented DVC and more recently spent 11 nights in 1 room at YC. The suites at the Values don't appeal to me at all, but I am not going to complain. We LOVE deluxes and do what we can to make our vacations work :)

I recently looked at staying in NYC for a weekend.... it you think Disney tough try getting a room for 5 in that city! Good luck!
 
Big family here as well. I've always disagreed with the pricingbfor the suites and such. To me they are priced exponentially with Disney assuming that it isn't 2 parents and a mass of kids, but parents, kids, and some grandparents to cover the bill.
 
A disadvantage of one room for a large family is only one bathroom.
This can cause you to miss rope drop.

This is sooo true. ;) Even knowing how much I wanted to get to see a new resort that I was willing to risk the cot in POR for DD, hubby really wants to go back to All-Star Music because the extra bathroom was so nice to have. So I just had to make sure he understood that we'd need to pay for an upgrade or go with quick service dining. "ask a disney specialized travel agent about every detail and every permutation of what we could end up spending, please..." :lmao:
 
I agree about one bathroom, we have 3 girls and one bathroom just doesn't work. I think if you have a lot of kids you just need to know that everything you do (eating out, vacationing, etc) is going to be harder and cost more. It isn't Disney's fault, they are looking at AVERAGE family sizes and planning for them.

We have done DVC, 2 value rooms, 2 moderate rooms, and one deluxe when we could still fit in one. They all have their pros and cons, it depends on your family and your budget.
 
This is sooo true. ;) Even knowing how much I wanted to get to see a new resort that I was willing to risk the cot in POR for DD, hubby really wants to go back to All-Star Music because the extra bathroom was so nice to have. So I just had to make sure he understood that we'd need to pay for an upgrade or go with quick service dining. "ask a disney specialized travel agent about every detail and every permutation of what we could end up spending, please..." :lmao:

It isn't that much to upgrade the dining, and worth it if you want a family suite.;)
 
It isn't Disney's fault, they are looking at AVERAGE family sizes and planning for them.

I think this is key. The average family size is going down too, in nearly all developed countries, as is the birth rate. More families are opting to have only one child.
 
There are loads of options for families of five:

Family Suites at ASMu
Family Suites at AoA (coming soon)
Cabins at Fort Wilderness
Trundle bed room at POR
Standard room at YC, BC, BWI, GF, Poly, CR
One bedroom villa at AKV, BLT, OKW
Two bedroom villa at AKV, BLT, OKW, SSR, VWL, BWV, BCV

That's 17 different resorts that offer a single room or villa that will sleep 5 or more.

I know that some of those options will not be in the budget for some families, and that many families want Disney to offer an affordable option for 5 or more.

The problem is, how should Disney define 'affordable'? For some, a room at GF is easily affordable. For others, it's not. There's a significant portion of the US population that couldn't afford one night at a value resort.

It's pretty clear that Disney's realized that they need more suite-type rooms at a lower price point, that's why they're moving forward with the construction at AoA.
Disney can't offer nice, big, affordable rooms for families of 5 because it would just cannibalize sales of their smaller rooms and DVC. That's why the Art of Animation "value suites" are priced like deluxes.

But lucky for all us large families, there are plenty of affordable off-site options.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom