Why is Disney so family of 5 unfriendly?

you can fit 5 in a shades of green room, and they are actually VERY roomy and you would not be squished in at all. I know that you would not be able to get the dining plan, but what if you just got a Disney gift card, and put the money that you were going to spend on the dining plan on that card, and then used the card every time you ate out. I KNOW that you will end up either breaking even or have extra money left on the gift card at the end of your stay.

If you put all your dining money on a gift card, it will be just like you pre-purchased all your meals, and have the feel of an all-inclusive vacation. Plus you will save money staying at Shades, and be in a GREAT location. Walking to the Poly and taking the monorail beats out staying off site or at a value.

If going back to Disney is your priority, I urge you to think outside the box, and don't let the dining plan hold you back. Good luck!
For some people, like our family, the Disney Dining Plan is a big part of why we keep coming back each year. For a larger family, it can be a huge money saver - especially if you can travel during free dining dates.
 
We are also a family of five and I agree that it can be tough to find budget friendly options. Our last trip we stayed at CR and had the dining plan. We loved both the resort and the DDP, but we cannot afford to stay at a deluxe this time around. So, we are trying off site at Bonnet Creek. I think we are going to love the extra room and not being tied to ADR's. My girls are not big eaters though and I envision lots of meal sharing. I think it will save us money to pay OOP, but I do think the DDP is a savings if you have big eaters and/or eat at least one table service meal a day on Disney property.

Good luck with your decision! I wish we could go the first week in December. I've heard it's a great time to go!
 
The dining plan may be a way to pay upfront, but overall, the dining plan isn't a savings over just paying as you go.

It's not that cut and dry. It really depends on your eating habits and where you plan on eating. If you do a lot of character meals, that my itself is most of a day's cost on the plan. Each family is different.
 
It's not that cut and dry. It really depends on your eating habits and where you plan on eating. If you do a lot of character meals, that my itself is most of a day's cost on the plan. Each family is different.

:thumbsup2 I agree completely!

I get a little frustrated when I read so many posts for people who "KNOW" that the DDP is not a good deal for any family. I've said it before, and I'll say it again, (heck, I've even broken it down by cost on another thread), that for YOUR family it may not make financial sense, but for MY family of 6 who likes a sit down/character meal daily, it is. What makes financial sense for my large family in all likelihood will not make sense for a small family.

To the OP: We've stayed at POR and didn't love it and it was pretty cramped. Our absolute cheapest option for staying onsite is to get 2 rooms at a Value during Free Dining. We have stayed at Wilderness Cabins with a great discount and paid for dining, but it was more expensive than 2 rooms at POP. The truth is that when you go from 2 kids to 3 (or 4), your costs increase substantially and unless you rent a place offsite there's really no way around it :sad2: Sigh...good thing I think they're worth it most days :goodvibes
 
One thing to consider about renting DVC points is you don't need the dining plan for the entire length of your stay - so if you plan before you rent, you could have your reservations set to add dining for the specefic times you need it, and save on a few days of dining. (Make sure you rents from a member who's OK with this, and you need to pay for dining at the time of booking).

But not all DVC locations are ok with 5, so check ahead too.
 
I have been reading these boards just dying to stay on site when we take the kids. But I have come to the conclusion that the cost savings involved in renting a nice house offsite makes up for the cost of the dining plan. You can stay off site and use the savings to pay as you go for food and the $14 a day for parking.

Really the convenience of onsite transportation is nice but unless you are staying at a deluxe it may be just as easy to just drive from a close off site location.
 
If you are going to eat at least one table service meal per day, the dining plan can save you a fortune.

This isn't necessarily so. When people look at what they would have paid if they would have ORDERED THE SAME THINGS then yes, the dining plan saves you money. However, if you really look at what you would REALLY order (no appetizers or desserts, or maybe just one of EACH for the 6 of us to share is what we usually do IRL) then the dining plan does not save a bundle. Plus, we have one vegetarian (always the cheapest thing on the menu) and a 13 years old that eats like a bird and really can just share meals.

All of our kids are adults which costs a bundle for the dining plan. It is all about convenience. Of course, free food is a great deal:thumbsup2
 
:thumbsup2 I agree completely!

I get a little frustrated when I read so many posts for people who "KNOW" that the DDP is not a good deal for any family. I've said it before, and I'll say it again, (heck, I've even broken it down by cost on another thread), that for YOUR family it may not make financial sense, but for MY family of 6 who likes a sit down/character meal daily, it is. What makes financial sense for my large family in all likelihood will not make sense for a small family.

To the OP: We've stayed at POR and didn't love it and it was pretty cramped. Our absolute cheapest option for staying onsite is to get 2 rooms at a Value during Free Dining. We have stayed at Wilderness Cabins with a great discount and paid for dining, but it was more expensive than 2 rooms at POP. The truth is that when you go from 2 kids to 3 (or 4), your costs increase substantially and unless you rent a place offsite there's really no way around it :sad2: Sigh...good thing I think they're worth it most days :goodvibes

Good points! Yes, if you have more than 2 kids you spend more money every day, on every vacation, on everything!!
 
This isn't necessarily so. When people look at what they would have paid if they would have ORDERED THE SAME THINGS then yes, the dining plan saves you money. However, if you really look at what you would REALLY order (no appetizers or desserts, or maybe just one of EACH for the 6 of us to share is what we usually do IRL) then the dining plan does not save a bundle. Plus, we have one vegetarian (always the cheapest thing on the menu) and a 13 years old that eats like a bird and really can just share meals.

All of our kids are adults which costs a bundle for the dining plan. It is all about convenience. Of course, free food is a great deal:thumbsup2
For our family of 6 the Basic Dinig Plan saves us money - free or not, it's a good deal.
 
I am the oldest child of a family of 7 (2 parents 5 kids) so if you can imagine finding a room for that many people! My parents would rent a house, which was nice to have space with that many people.

However I just punched the few details you gave and I came up with:

Disney's All-Star Music Resort Total: $972

Check In December 5, 2011
Check Out December 9, 2011
4 adults and 1 child.

Family Suite (All suites have one queen-size bed, a living room with a double-size sleeper sofa, and 2 twin-size sleeper chairs, 2 bathrooms, a mini-kitchen, vanity area with sink, and table and chairs. All rooms are non-smoking. Amenities include in-room wall safe, voice mail, high-speed Internet access (additional fee), microwave, iron and ironing board. A hairdryer and Pack 'n Play® playard are available upon request. Wheelchair-accessible rooms are available. Located close to the Main Building, these rooms offer views of the parking lot, courtyard or pool.)


You mentioned you were eligible for Shades of Green which means IF Disney extends their military discount (they have extended since it's been established in 2009) you would be eligiable for the military discount on their rooms (Value Resorts: 30% off Moderate Resorts and Cabins: 35% off Deluxe Resorts: 40% off). This would bring your room total to $680.40 before taxes.

IF Disney extends their Military Salute Special Ticket (they have extended this ticket every year since it was established in 2009) You may purchase up to a maximum of six 4-Day Military Promotional Tickets with your choice of either the Park Hopper or Water Park Fun & More option for $138 per ticket. Your ticket cost would be $828.00

You can now add Disney Dinning to your discounted room however there is no discount added to the dinning. Deluxe Dinning is $78.99 per night per adult and $21.99 per child. Your dinning costs would equal $1351.80

The total cost of your whole trip (room, tickets and food) would be (before tax): $2859.80

That is only $571.96 per person for the week or $142.99 per person per day.

I'm not sure what your budget is or how much is too much but I think that is pretty darn good! :rotfl: You could also downgrade your dinning to the regular Disney Dinning plan and save $568.00. I hope that helps! :)

**Disney extending their military promotions is ONLY based on personal experience booking Disney vacations with the yearly military promotion. I do NOT have any information other than past history that I am basing the extension of the military discount.**
 
For some people, like our family, the Disney Dining Plan is a big part of why we keep coming back each year. For a larger family, it can be a huge money saver - especially if you can travel during free dining dates.

But they are not looking at free dining. They just want to get the dining plan, and from what I read in that post it is mostly because they like the mentality of "its all paid for up front". I totally understand this mentality, my husband is this way. :thumbsup2 But, They can have that mentality and stay at shades of green if they put the money they were going to pay for the dining plan on a gift card, and then just use that for the duration of the trip.

Yes, the dining plan does save money if you are going to pay out of pocket for EXACTLY the same amount of food that is offered with the plan, but if you miss one ADR, skip a snack one day, don't get dessert with lunch or order the chicken (instead of the more expensive steak), you will not be saving money.

If your everyone in your family is HONESTLY going to eat one snack a day, dessert with lunch, a dessert with dinner and the most expensive entree on the menu (at least 2/3 of the time)- then definitely you will win with the dining plan. Only you know if that is the case with your family.
 
But they are not looking at free dining. They just want to get the dining plan, and from what I read in that post it is mostly because they like the mentality of "its all paid for up front". I totally understand this mentality, my husband is this way. :thumbsup2 But, They can have that mentality and stay at shades of green if they put the money they were going to pay for the dining plan on a gift card, and then just use that for the duration of the trip.

Yes, the dining plan does save money if you are going to pay out of pocket for EXACTLY the same amount of food that is offered with the plan, but if you miss one ADR, skip a snack one day, don't get dessert with lunch or order the chicken (instead of the more expensive steak), you will not be saving money.

If your everyone in your family is HONESTLY going to eat one snack a day, dessert with lunch, a dessert with dinner and the most expensive entree on the menu (at least 2/3 of the time)- then definitely you will win with the dining plan. Only you know if that is the case with your family.
They aren't looking for free dining? What makes you say that? It seems that the OP is looking for the best deal for a family of five to stay on-property at WDW and she stated that she really likes the dining plan. She stated that they had free dining previously and liked it. They are trying to plan a trip for December and for the last 3 years free dining has been offered for dates in December. For a family of 5 or more staying at a value resort with two connecting with a free dining discount is about the best deal you are ever going to get from Disney. Especially if the majority of your kids are 10 or over. We are a family of 6 and it has saved us a fortune every time we have gotten this discount - that's why we come back every year.

As for the Dining Plan being a good value when it's not free. Well, I guess we can debate that all day, but I stand by the fact that we save money with the basic plan even if it's not free. And yes, GASP, we actually eat that much food. I don't know why it's so unrealistic to think that 2 meals per day and a snack is too much food for someone to eat in one day. In fact, we find it to be the perfect amount of food.
 
We're also a family of 5 and we rent DVC points from DVC owners on this board. We usually get a 1 bedroom for about what it would cost for a Value Resort. The time you go will alter how many points you need, but it is good to investigate this as an option. Good luck!!

If you rent points can you add the table service and tickets ?
 
If you rent points can you add the table service and tickets ?

If you rent points, you need to talk to the person you're renting from upfront about the dining plan. As long as they agree, you can add the dining plan to your reservation. You can plan before you make your reservation, and add the dining plan for select days (it's more complicated, but can save money). You do not need tickets through WDW for the dining plan when you rent points. So, you can buy your own tickets thru Undercovertourist or whereever, and save money on that too.

But, with a DVC rental, the dining plan is paid for upfront, at the time of booking.
 
Not sure if you drive in or fly, but rember if you get a 1 or 2 bedroom you get a washer and dryer (so you dont have to pack but 2 or 3 sets of clothes) and a kitchen.

I eat breakfest and dinner in the room. I freez food or have frozen stuff to prepare so I'm not cooking that much. Will requie you to pack a cooler though, I have a van so I have room.

It would safe you the money of the "meal deal".

I have rented points form DVC also its a way to safe some money.
 
Yes, the dining plan does save money if you are going to pay out of pocket for EXACTLY the same amount of food that is offered with the plan, but if you miss one ADR, skip a snack one day, don't get dessert with lunch or order the chicken (instead of the more expensive steak), you will not be saving money.

If your everyone in your family is HONESTLY going to eat one snack a day, dessert with lunch, a dessert with dinner and the most expensive entree on the menu (at least 2/3 of the time)- then definitely you will win with the dining plan. Only you know if that is the case with your family.

I can see I'm gonna have to break it down again for ya'll :rotfl:

Our last trip, our family consisted of 2 adults, 1 Disney adult and 3 kids under 10. We enjoy doing Character meals so that we can meet the Characters without waiting in line and wasting time in the parks. One character meal at Crystal Palace is $36.99/adult and $17.99/child. For our family that would have been $175. If we ate lunch at Cosmic Ray's it would have been $8.39 for a grilled chicken sandwich (let's say we just got water to drink) and $4.99 for a kid's chicken nuggets. That's about $40. $175 + $40 = $215. Now, this includes no snacks and no sodas which are both included in the DDP and if we chose just to do a snack/ person would add another $24 on to make it $239 for the day. The meal plan cost my family $174 which makes a savings of $65/day. Even without snacks we would be saving $40/day. I didn't even include desserts or sodas in this - so you can see I'm adding it up as if we didn't order "EXACTLY" the same amount of food included in the DDP. In addition, our family shares meals, so we pay absolutely nothing OOP for food.

IF your family has more kids (say 4 under 10), the meal plan is an even better deal for you. Now, when our kids are all older, we're going to have to reevaluate, but for right now, we do save money by using the meal plan and we share all of our meals.

I would be so thankful if we could all just agree that you must do the math for your own family and not assume that because it does not work financially for your family, it does not work for anyone's :thumbsup2

Kelma - mom to 2 little princes and 2 little princesses
 
We are only a family of four, but have discovered that getting ONE AP and a TiW card is usually the best deal for out family in terms of savings.
 
I can see I'm gonna have to break it down again for ya'll :rotfl:

Our last trip, our family consisted of 2 adults, 1 Disney adult and 3 kids under 10. We enjoy doing Character meals so that we can meet the Characters without waiting in line and wasting time in the parks. One character meal at Crystal Palace is $36.99/adult and $17.99/child. For our family that would have been $175. If we ate lunch at Cosmic Ray's it would have been $8.39 for a grilled chicken sandwich (let's say we just got water to drink) and $4.99 for a kid's chicken nuggets. That's about $40. $175 + $40 = $215. Now, this includes no snacks and no sodas which are both included in the DDP and if we chose just to do a snack/ person would add another $24 on to make it $239 for the day. The meal plan cost my family $174 which makes a savings of $65/day. Even without snacks we would be saving $40/day. I didn't even include desserts or sodas in this - so you can see I'm adding it up as if we didn't order "EXACTLY" the same amount of food included in the DDP. In addition, our family shares meals, so we pay absolutely nothing OOP for food.

IF your family has more kids (say 4 under 10), the meal plan is an even better deal for you. Now, when our kids are all older, we're going to have to reevaluate, but for right now, we do save money by using the meal plan and we share all of our meals.

I would be so thankful if we could all just agree that you must do the math for your own family and not assume that because it does not work financially for your family, it does not work for anyone's :thumbsup2

Kelma - mom to 2 little princes and 2 little princesses

The last time we went, it was a big saver for us. I booked it after I realized I had ADR's every day, and we had 4 children under 10. Three of them were buffets. Now, with older kids, I probably wouldn't do it, because we never get desserts, and not always drinks, and would rather pay OOP for our meals, since most would be on the adult plan (and we're not going to WDW for the food).
 
We're a family of 7 and will be staying at FW in our own camper. We can't afford a room at a deluxe or rooms at another resort and then still buy tickets.
 
They aren't looking for free dining? What makes you say that? It seems that the OP is looking for the best deal for a family of five to stay on-property at WDW and she stated that she really likes the dining plan. She stated that they had free dining previously and liked it. They are trying to plan a trip for December and for the last 3 years free dining has been offered for dates in December. For a family of 5 or more staying at a value resort with two connecting with a free dining discount is about the best deal you are ever going to get from Disney. Especially if the majority of your kids are 10 or over. We are a family of 6 and it has saved us a fortune every time we have gotten this discount - that's why we come back every year.

As for the Dining Plan being a good value when it's not free. Well, I guess we can debate that all day, but I stand by the fact that we save money with the basic plan even if it's not free. And yes, GASP, we actually eat that much food. I don't know why it's so unrealistic to think that 2 meals per day and a snack is too much food for someone to eat in one day. In fact, we find it to be the perfect amount of food.

Free dining is a great deal......PERIOD! If they were able to GET free dining this would be a totally different discussion. The fact of the matter is that the free dining offer expired on 12/20 and no one knows if it is coming back.
SO.....if free dining does not come back they need to decide if buying it is worth it.
And the the people recommending renting DVC points, that is NOT cheap, especially if you have to get a 2 bedroom unit. We stayed in a 2 bedroom at SSR last May and got the 40% off room offer and it still was WAY more expensive than most off-site homes and condos. It was worth it to us, but it does not save money.
And the idea of eating meals at the DVC unit really doesn't fly. It works for breakfast and late snacks but going back and forth for every meal takes too much time out of touring:hippie:
 

New Posts

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom