Why American Idol is a VERY bad idea...

[CandleontheWater]

Apparently you are barred from selling the "dream ticket" on Ebay if you win and choose not to use it. I asked that question when I went for the passholder sneak peak in December. The CM also told me that they would award the dream ticket to whoever won, even if they were over 29. That person could then choose what to do with the ticket (other than selling it).

I'm not sure how they would prevent people from selling them, but I'm sure Disney has that all figured out from a legal perspective.

 

[goofy4prez]

I also think this attraction is a bad idea but more because I think it's a waste. I can hear karoake(sp?) at home and the only interest I have in AI is seeing the horrible audition shows at the beginning of the season...

So many other cool attactions they could have done...

I'm not going to say they couldn't have spent money elswhere, but if you get the opportunity to go to the attraction you'll see that it's not like Karaoke. My wife competed in AI and we also attended the show and trust me there was no feel of karaoke at all.

 

[maxiesmom]

I also think this attraction is a bad idea but more because I think it's a waste. I can hear karoake(sp?) at home and the only interest I have in AI is seeing the horrible audition shows at the beginning of the season...

So many other cool attactions they could have done...

How do you know it is not "cool" if you haven't even seen it for yourself?

Why are so many people so quick to criticize an attraction they haven't even seen? That to me is not cool.

 

[crazytp93]

I went back and re-read the rules to see where I got the info., to win the "dream ticket receipients" (IE the final winner) "must satifsy AMERICAN IDOL TV program reuirements...only ages 16-28 & US citizens..."

you can try out at 14 and older I guess you just anit gona win the final compatetion.

The ticket is transferable to anyone you like.

 

[fireflymedic]

if my wife wone the "dream ticket" and could not use it because she is 40 + there would be fireworks at Disney (but not the fun kind)

 

[TDC Nala]

if my wife wone the "dream ticket" and could not use it because she is 40 + there would be fireworks at Disney (but not the fun kind)

She can't use it, because American Idol the TV show will not accept contestants over the age of 28. The beef would be with them, not Disney. Although I still think Disney ought to throw in some merchandise.

 

[Nyghtewynd]

I'm going to audition, I hope. I'm too old to actually audition (and to be honest, I have neither the time nor the inclination to do so), but it'll be fun to try it once. I worked as a karaoke DJ for a year, so it's not like I've never done it before. I'll sing, they'll say "no chance", and I'll be able to say that I tried out for AI. Nothing wrong with that.

 

[southernbelle5672]

I tend to agree with the OP. If young preteens can try out for this show and have the possibility of "failing" I'm sure it could hurt some feelings. Hopefully, parents prepare their children for that sort of thing but let's face it, it doesn't always happen. The rejection could ruin the day for a 14 year old.

 

[rudetreehill]

Great post, and really something to think about. And it's definitely something for parents to think about before putting their kids through the "experience!"

 

[grossmansr]

I tend to agree with the OP. Who wants to be rejected at Disney? That's not fun. I wasn't particularly excited to begin with because I can't carry a tune to save my life. So auditioning is out. What does that leave? Sitting in the audience? Somehow that's underwhelming. So I feel pretty blah about the whole thing.

However, I'm sure there are just as many or more people who can't wait to experience this. So I'm not knocking it. And I'll probably go check it out to see if my expectations are wrong. But I'm not jumping out of my seat in anticipation.

 

[Robo]

...you'll see that it's not like Karaoke. My wife competed in AI and we also attended the show and trust me there was no feel of karaoke at all.

No.

Because at karaoke the entire audience is not "required" to wildly cheer and stomp their feet as though the economic crisis has been solved...
when a coached and rehearsed amateur singer has just hit the actual correct note from the score.

I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me
I got the music in me!

 

[luvthemouse71]

How do you know it is not "cool" if you haven't even seen it for yourself?

Why are so many people so quick to criticize an attraction they haven't even seen? That to me is not cool.

You're right...haven't seen the attraction, nor do I plan to waste my park time doing so. If you love it, that's great. I just find AI annoying for the most part, and I don't see the attraction in watching people sing, particularly when many of these people have deluded themselves into thinking they're talented.Now, if they did this like the Gong Show, that would be a different story

Maybe its because many of my friends were into karoke and I spent many a night listening to them sing. Often the same song every single time.

And I wasn't criticizing the attraction itself, just the idea behind it, which I find silly and boring. I guess I'm wondering why this should bother you?

 

[LittleMissMagic]

Well... rejection is a big part of American Idol. I mean... how many of us watch the auditions and nothing else? If it weren't for the harsh judges, Idol wouldn't be any fun.

Now, I'll admit, I was never too crazy about this attraction. I want something I can play!!! (You do not want to hear me sing! ) As mentioned above, I don't want to listen to people sing karaoke!

This is probably something I'll go to once and never again.

 

[singjenn]

1st of all let me say that I'm a fan of the show and thought it was a good idea for an AI attraction. I'm all for any attractions that disperse crowds! However, I was at DHS in mid-January and auditioned for the show and now feel it's a huge mistake to have this attraction.

Let me say that I'm not a great singer, and have no delusion that I'm any good. I enjoy Karaoke and can sing without anyone cringing. I was asked by a CM to try out and I did it as a lark. I didn't think I would get through, except that possibly being a soft opening there wouldn't be many people trying out and who knows. I was more interested in seeing the backstage and seeing how the process works. So....I go in and sing a bit of "It had to be you." I'm told that my voice is not strong enough. He was certainly right. The CM's are overly nice to you as you do the "walk of shame," obviously trying to make you forget you were turned down, rejected by Disney. Me and my 12 year old daughter were laughing and I even did a joking "I'm a star, you guys don't know anything!!" rant to the CM's outside just as you see on the show.

But here's the thing....I felt a little bad the rest of the day. I felt a little stupid for trying out and a little bad for being rejected. Now if I felt even slightly that way, how are all the people going to feel who are rejected and think that they were good? And think of this, everyone who tries out, dozens or hundreds each day, are going to be rejected by Disney. Even the ones that get through, only one of them who wins will not be rejected. And most of them will be rejected by the audience members. Who wants to feel like that on vacation at Disney? Can you imagine being a 14 year old who thinks they can sing and find out their just not good enough?

Just my thoughts. I will go see the show when I'm there, but I'll be thinking about the "rejects."

I thought it didin't start util Feb 14th? I agree with you about 80%. I only read a few of the replies and I also agree with them. I think everybody is right.

But my question is this..... I think I read somewhere that the whole reason for this is to help the winner bypass some of the audition process for the "real" American idol. If that's the case then what about people who are over age....like me? That seems unfair for me or anyone else to audition and win, then only to take a spot away form someone who actually had a chnace of going to the real audtions. I think it would make more sence to just ahve the attraction but be just for fun. Anybody else with me?

 

[rentayenta]

I think it sounds terrible.

 

[wdwhooked]

I understand that some might be disappointed if they are not chosen to be on in the AI attraction but not try out or allow your children to try out because one might be rejected is a problem. I am not trying to be rude, however this is one big problem we have today in America. Not to allow our children to fail because it may hurt their feelings or cause them to be upset is equal to not allowing them to grow with all that life has to offer. We all know that in the real world there will be those who win and loose. At some point we all must experience rejection and then move on hopefully causing us to become a better person. It is better to prepare our children to possibly be rejected than not to even try at all. Of course we are talking about Disney and this might not be the place to teach such life lessons, however this attraction might just be a great opportunity to learn a lot about oneself and for our children to do the same. Look how many times Walt was rejected and now we see the outcome of some of his dreams that have come true. He did not stop trying after being rejected many times throughout his carrier and he became a better person for it. I say give it a try, you might just win or at least learn something along the way and isn’t that what Disney is about.

 

[jrt1176]

I am not a fan of the show, but this thread is hilarious.

If you have a secret desire to be a singer and day dream about it while working in a cubicle I guess this is your chance!

Rejected? Well, at least you have a day job!

Rejection from this is going to ruin someone's trip? Only if you really thought you were a "star" deep down...

We coddle kids too much these days anyway...

If you're going to get on that stage you have to know you're going to get rejected unless you actually have some talent!

 

[FunFamily]

We watched one of the shows -- it was outstanding, and I say that as someone who is not even a fan of the television show.

As for concerns about the impact on others, your sentiments are kind and considerate. But, WDW experiences are best enjoyed by people appreciating and respecting their own limits and comfort zone.

People competing are aware of the potential negative outcome. This is no different than motion disclaimers for attractions like Mission Space and Soarin'. The same for "you will get wet" at Kali River Rapids and Splash Mountain. The list can go on... Each guest can decide if they should participate in an attraction by also deciding if they can deal with the advertised potential outcome of an attraction. The good news for all on these forums is that there is so much to do that there is plenty for everyone's tastes.

For those that have yet to see the attraction, please give it a try. I found it uplifting and energizing being an audience member, and again, I am not even a fan of the show itself.

 

[d1gitman]

...if they did this like the Gong Show, that would be a different story...

i don't think that will EVER happen ANYWHERE...lot's of conspiracy theories around the Gong Show...ever notice it isn't in reruns? Google it and see what you find...

By the way, the Gong Show was great.

 

[Uncleromulus]

I'm going to enjoy bypassing this new "attraction"---