I'm the same way except with Paul. My DH plays bass and piano so i'm partial I guess. I also find Paul's songs more my taste than most of John's. Ringo's songs are fun too though.
Paul, for the reasons stated above (cute and dreamy )
Plus, I like his voice best (swoon). It's amazing that "Here There and Everywhere" and "Oh, Darling" are sung by the same guy. Such range!
I'm also more drawn to the songs he wrote, such as Things We Said Today, Yesterday, for no one, here there and everywhere, hey jude and on and on.
I think Abbey Road side B is their masterpiece. Just wonderful.
I've been fortunate enough to see him twice in concert, and those shows have been out of this wold. The love and energy he puts into them is something to behold