Well, before the boys of *NSYNC, they were the boys of the MMC.
You name him, I probably swooned for him.
But for almost seven years BEFORE *NSYNC, it was Elijah Wood. We broke up after he became precocious, which was actually before he became a hobbit.
*sigh* I still long for his Huck Finn days.
Oh, and several of the Newsies made headlines for me too.

It was, and remains, my favorite all time movie, and it's not ALL about the story and the music.
Of course, now....my heart belongs to Clay.

(And even though neither of us are teens, he IS the real Idol!!)