Who is the best American Idol performer to date?

Who is the best AI performer to date?

  • Kelly

  • Clay

  • Reuben

  • Fantasia

  • Diana

  • Bo

  • Carrie

  • Taylor

  • Kat

  • Chris

  • Elliott

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.
I said Kelly. She's just amazing. I can't understand why she stuggled to make it in the business before AI. I hope every label that turned her down before gets sick when they see or hear her knowing what they had and let go. I also liked Constantine. I loved his versions of "I Think I Love You" and "Bohemian Rhapsody".

Taylor is my favorite from this season. :goodvibes
 
Fantasia! :love: I loved that a**-kickin way she commanded the stage and enthralled everyone.
 

Without a doubt - Fantasia. When the Idol judges refer to someone having their "moment", they are referring to Fantasia's version of "Summertime". That was a moment we have not seen repeated on American Idol.

Just my two cents, of course.
 
Since it's "performer" and not singer, I said Taylor. :)
 
Anyone who doesn't answer Willam Hung has their head in the sand.

:rotfl2:
 
I have to say Chris. I think he has one of the best voices! Kelly is also great. Fantasia has to be the worst. I never understood what people liked about her?
 
Goes to show is RIGHT! I never understood what people saw in LOTS of people but that's their opinion and everyone has a right to one.

I loved:

Taylor (duh!)
Ruben
Fantasia
Clay
Bo Bice!!!


Couldn't stand:

Carrie Underwhelm
Vonzell Baby V
Diana DeGarmo
 
So far Clay for me. I am basing this also on what I've seen in person. I've seen Kelly and Clay on the same night, and was reminded why I never understood why she won. She bored me on stage and honestly, most of the audience was kind of "ho hum" as well. At least she didn't do well with a huge crowd... I see her doing better with a smaller audience.

Clay's awesome in concert! I hope to see Bo this summer, but from what I've seen he's great too!

I don't trust what I see on TV, as I was not as wowed in person as I was in concert even with Clay.
 
Monte Cristo said:
Anyone who doesn't answer Willam Hung has their head in the sand.

:rotfl2:
That's what I'm saying! I had to pick "other" because he wasn't on the poll! What kind of cheap thread is this?
 
lucyblondecat said:
Wow. Fantasia was my least favorite to date.

Goes to show there is someone for everyone! :banana:

I didn't like Fantasia either. We even stopped watching AI that season because of her. But you're right, someone on the show for everyone.

On this poll I voted for Kelly. I also really like Carrie Underwood, Chris and Taylor.
 
I wanted to vote for Clay as I never saw the first season with Kelly but she has some great songs out so I had to vote for her. But as far as who I've seen on AI; definetly CLAY!! :love:
 
Clay Aiken is my personal favorite. I just love his voice. I also love Kelly’s songs.
 
I voted for Chris. Also loved Carrie (her CD is great).
 
Clay - no contest! :love:
Then
Constantine
Kelly
Fantasia
Carrie
and I like Chris & Katherine this season
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom