DH and I were on a great member cruise in 2005. We enjoyed hearing the guests especially Ducky Williams talk about his work, and there were opportunities to win some of his work, and at the end everyone got one of his prints of M&M with the Wonder.
I didn't keep most of the gifts that came to your room, so I wan't particularly impressed with them, but I enjoyed the commaraderie that was present when you talked to the other guests.
I would love to do another one, but September next year is out for me, and I don't want to waste money for a January cruise to the Bahamas.
Some here have the opinion that the MCs are huge selling opportunities for DVC and don't like that aspect. There is that, but still people flock to get on one. We'll see if DVC can "sell" one to members in January.
Best wishes as you decide. I think more people here talk negatively about them, yet as I said, they have booked a whole ship in a single day in the past, (including Disboarders) so there's something about them that appeals to a great number of people. I hope to do another one, but not in January!
Bobbi