Which WWoHP restaurant is better?

[ekk205]

Three Broomsticks vs Leaky Cauldron? also if any secret surprises at the leaky cauldron could be left out, that would be great, i haven't been there yet, hoping to eat there this year!

rank on:
~food-
-quality
-amount
-variety
~service
~crowds
~immersive or not
~personal taste
~magicalness

thank you!

 

[ladybugx]

I'm biased toward Three Broomsticks because I don't eat red meat or fish, and almost every single dish contains red meat or fish at Leaky Cauldron (according to the menus I've been able to pull up online. I haven't yet gone to Diagon Alley). Everyone else seems to like Leaky Cauldron better, though. haha. From what I've seen in pictures, the atmospheres are similar in both, so I'd choose based on what you want to eat.

 

[HM]

We at three Broomsticks this last trip and opted not to eat at the Leaky Cauldron. The menus have many of the same items, so once we did one, we decided to try something much different another day. Leaky Cauldron seems to have more entree choices though.

 

[damo]

I liked the Leaky Cauldron. Their food is more unique. We had the Ploughman's Platter and really enjoyed it.

 

[snoopboop]

They're quite similar in most respects. I personally like the food choices better at the Leaky Cauldron, though there are several entrees that are available at both places. I believe that all of the same beverages are available in both places as well.

Not very helpful, I suppose! LOL! I love them both and think you can't go wrong either way.

 

[Pembo]

I agree with snoopboop. I could get my fish and chips and butterbeer at both and that made me happy. They have a different vibe but I loved them both.

 

[PurpleMouse]

I liked the atmosphere at the Leaky Cauldron best. But by about 1%. Very very similar feel to both places.

Food was excellent at both as was service.