Which value Resort?

[disney-inspired]

I'm already planning our trip and it's not until January 2010! It will be me, DSis, her DBF, and our DC. It would be cheaper for us to stay in a moderate but us girls are not sharing a room with the boys.We are all college students so our budget is tight.

Here's a little bit about our cr3w:
Me - I LOVE LOVE LOVE Disney. I have been to WDW once in 2006. DL Veteran.
DSis- She likes Disney. Has been to WDW once in 2006. DL Veteran
DSis' DBF - Likes Disney, ok. Has never been to WDW. Didn't do DL too much during childhood. BIG FOOTBALL PLAYER.
DC - He likes Disney OK too. Never been to WDW. DL Veteran but nowhere near as many times as me!

So that's us! Also something to consider, we're looking for a place that gives us a good amount of choices for snacks on the DDP because we don't want to spend any extra than needed.

Please vote & explain why.

THANKS!

 

[Doc CW]

ASMo it has the theme of all three and the best food court of all the All Stars

 

[LibrarianChef]

I would go with the Pop. It is newer than the other All Stars. It also does not share a bus. The food courts in the Value resorts are pretty similar so I wouldn't give one a higher ranking over the other. The theming is fun. I prefer the theming for ASMo, but it is up to personal taste.