hi -
its definately a personal thing - could you go to a store and try them on? For me, the crocs scutes and the caymans are great and the crocs beach and payless airwalks are okay,,,,,the scutes are like double cushioned in the heel so they are extra comfie - but if you have a narrow foot, dont know if they would run wide,,,,last fall, i brought a brand new pair of caymans, and never had any issues with them!! you will see zillions of them at disney - last week the kids were wearing the disney ones everywhere you looked!!! it was soooo cute!!!