Which RP Idea Do You Like Better?

[Silvermist20]

I've been thinking of doing an RP since I gave mine away and I just love doing them. (Before anyone thinks, "Well why didn't you just keep them?" they were too much. Everytime I'd log on there'd be 5 pages of new stuff going on and it was too much. So I'll stick to doing one RP.) Here are my ideas:

1. Neverland RP~I know either Cindy or Noelle was going to do this but when I got off of my break of being on here I looked through both pages and I didn't see it anywhere. So I'll be glad to do one.

2. Wonderland RP~Each person would be either a person who fell into the rabbit hole or someone from Wonderland, whether it be a talking flower, an animal, someone related to someone from Wonderland, anything. It would basically show everyone's adventures and what exactly happens in Wonderland.

3. Another Murder Mystery~I also didn't see any of these and they're so much fun! So I'd be willing to do another one.

4. Camp Of Disney: Another Year RP (I'll think of a better name if this is what people think I should do)~I think Noelle thought that this would be a good idea. Basically just COD with new campers and possibly new councilors.

5. The School For The Abnormal RP~A school of kids who aren't normal, whether they have a weird power, look different, etc. (I know this has been done many times, but whatever.)

6. The Mystery of Kelsy Smith RP~This is about a girl named Kelsy Smith who went missing and no one knows what happened to her. No one knows if she ran away, was murdered, etc. Her friends try to find out the mystery of what exactly did happen to her while also living their normal lives. (I may or may not change the name of who goes missing if this is what people think I should do.)

7. Island Of Misfits RP~I did this one before but it was getting a little off topic. So This time I'll make sure things don't get off topic if this is what people want to do. Pretty much the same as when I last did it.

So what do you guys think? Which one should I do? (Whoch one do you guys like the best and think will be pretty active)

 

[maps823]

Murder Mystery or Neverland RP but they all sound great!

 

[Fairywings]

I've been thinking of doing an RP since I gave mine away and I just love doing them. (Before anyone thinks, "Well why didn't you just keep them?" they were too much. Everytime I'd log on there'd be 5 pages of new stuff going on and it was too much. So I'll stick to doing one RP.) Here are my ideas:

1. Neverland RP~I know either Cindy or Noelle was going to do this but when I got off of my break of being on here I looked through both pages and I didn't see it anywhere. So I'll be glad to do one.

2. Wonderland RP~Each person would be either a person who fell into the rabbit hole or someone from Wonderland, whether it be a talking flower, an animal, someone related to someone from Wonderland, anything. It would basically show everyone's adventures and what exactly happens in Wonderland.

3. Another Murder Mystery~I also didn't see any of these and they're so much fun! So I'd be willing to do another one.

4. Camp Of Disney: Another Year RP (I'll think of a better name if this is what people think I should do)~I think Noelle thought that this would be a good idea. Basically just COD with new campers and possibly new councilors.

5. The School For The Abnormal RP~A school of kids who aren't normal, whether they have a weird power, look different, etc. (I know this has been done many times, but whatever.)

6. The Mystery of Kelsy Smith RP~This is about a girl named Kelsy Smith who went missing and no one knows what happened to her. No one knows if she ran away, was murdered, etc. Her friends try to find out the mystery of what exactly did happen to her while also living their normal lives. (I may or may not change the name of who goes missing if this is what people think I should do.)

So what do you guys think? Which one should I do? (Whoch one do you guys like the best and think will be pretty active)

1 - This just seems way too vague and flat. It seems just like a general idea that seems too open, so like it would have no direction, no real plot and fall through

2 - Same as 1

3 - These take a lot of work because you have to keep up with who the murderers are and who the detectives are and who's dead and you have to think of clues that aren't obvious but aren't so obscure no one can figure it out after weeks.

4 - No point. Plus if you try to do two different years at a time people will get horribly confused

5 - Done a lot and Cindy currently just started the Academy for Heroes

6 - This sounds too much like a good novel, and good novels don't neccessarily make good RPs - the cast of characters would likely have to be small and the plot would have to be pretty specific which means not very much to add or contribute which you need a lot of in an RP

Good RPs are based on plots, not settings most of the time.

If you really want to do something, why don't you just bring back your fairlie RP or the Islands of Misfits one, where they plane crashed onto a deserted island?

 

[Silvermist20]

1 - This just seems way too vague and flat. It seems just like a general idea that seems too open, so like it would have no direction, no real plot and fall through

2 - Same as 1

3 - These take a lot of work because you have to keep up with who the murderers are and who the detectives are and who's dead and you have to think of clues that aren't obvious but aren't so obscure no one can figure it out after weeks.

4 - No point. Plus if you try to do two different years at a time people will get horribly confused

5 - Done a lot and Cindy currently just started the Academy for Heroes

6 - This sounds too much like a good novel, and good novels don't neccessarily make good RPs - the cast of characters would likely have to be small and the plot would have to be pretty specific which means not very much to add or contribute which you need a lot of in an RP

Good RPs are based on plots, not settings most of the time.

If you really want to do something, why don't you just bring back your fairlie RP or the Islands of Misfits one, where they plane crashed onto a deserted island?

Well the Fairlies one died in like 2 weeks and the Island of Misfits one was starting to get a little off topic. Maybe I could make another Island of Misfists one and make sure there's a more stable plotline.

 

[ColdNeverBotheredMe]

A murder mystery sounds fun! I'm not really super familiar with the idea of an RP though, just from what I've read on here a bit... But from what I can tell, I think a murder mystery would be a good idea, if a bit complicated.

 

[Fairywings]

So I dug into my reserve list and an idea I thought you might like is one I dubbed Famous in Disney, where the people are made up child star celebrities (whether movie, music, tv or modeling or whatever) and one has a birthday so she/he invites all her/his friends out to live in Disney villas for a year.

Take it or leave it

 

[GoofyFunyun]

I like the wonderland idea.

I also like wing's idea.

It'd also be awesome if Island of Misfits came back

 

[tigerkitty]

I love the idea of Neverland, and I loved the Island of Misfits, but it died. I really love both ideas. Wonderland is also a great idea!

 

[Silvermist20]

So I dug into my reserve list and an idea I thought you might like is one I dubbed Famous in Disney, where the people are made up child star celebrities (whether movie, music, tv or modeling or whatever) and one has a birthday so she/he invites all her/his friends out to live in Disney villas for a year.

Take it or leave it

I like that idea. And maybe instead of just child stars maybe adult stars (like in their 20's) as well as child stars. About to PM you.

 

[Silvermist20]

So I came up with this: Either a Murder Mystery or the Famous in Disney RP. Or both. The murder mystery will be set somewhere in Disney that I'll think of (possibly a resort for something different). And since I remember people wanted a couples Murder Mystery, then that's what it would be. (That'll be explained more if that's what people want.) I didn't find it too much work to do it, so I'd be happy to do one again. The Famous In Disney RP would be mainly run by me and co-run by Wings. It would basically be the idea that Wings had said before and I'll maybe come up with more ideas for it if that's what people want. So Murder Mystery, Famous in Disney, or both? (FYI I wouldn't mind doing both. Murder Mysteries only last about two months or until it dies and then I'll only have the one to worry about.)

 

[1elle2]

I've always loved murder-mysteries, they're a lot of fun usually.
Maybe a foster home for people related to Disney characters would be fun, but that's just a random idea I came up with just now lol

 

[Fairywings]

Im fine wiyh both

 

[Fairywings]

Im fine wiyh both

I have characters for the Famous at Disney one and I could easily pick one for the murder mystery

 

[Fairywings]

I've always loved murder-mysteries, they're a lot of fun usually.
Maybe a foster home for people related to Disney characters would be fun, but that's just a random idea I came up with just now lol

I like this too if you like this Silv

 

[Silvermist20]

I like this too if you like this Silv

No offense to Noelle, but I wasn't a huge fan of her idea. It just seemed a little vague. (But then again she did come up with the idea right on the spot.) I also don't really know how we'd go along with that. I'll still let people decide between a murder mystery, the Famous in Disney RP, or both.

 

[Fairywings]

No offense to Noelle, but I wasn't a huge fan of her idea. It just seemed a little vague. (But then again she did come up with the idea right on the spot.) I also don't really know how we'd go along with that. I'll still let people decide between a murder mystery, the Famous in Disney RP, or both.

I already said this, but FD or both, since I already have characters for FD and it's easy to pick a murder mystery character

 

[Silvermist20]

I think since only 2 people replied to the question I'm making the executive desicion to do both. I'll start with the Murder Mystery. Then I'll post signups for the Famous in Disney RP.

 

[Fairywings]

I think since only 2 people replied to the question I'm making the executive desicion to do both. I'll start with the Murder Mystery. Then I'll post signups for the Famous in Disney RP.

Okay. You want me to make you a sign up form for Famous?

 

[Silvermist20]

Okay. You want me to make you a sign up form for Famous?

If you could make it and PM it to me then I can tweak it, make the rules, and post the sign up thread. I kind of have some ideas about the sign up form, but you probably have some good ideas too.