Which restaurant should I try next?

[robinb]

I have been to a lot of the WDW restaurants, but I always like to try a new one.

Which are your TOP-3 favorites on the list given? If it's not on the list then I have already been there .

 

[Mickey_Man]

I voted for five of your choices:

Captain's Grille = I want to try it here, but that's all I can say about it.
GFC = Loved it for breakfast, liked it for lunch.
Raglan Road = loved it every time (3) we've been there.
Spoodles = I have had ups and downs here in the six times we've eaten there, but it is worth trying.
The Wave = the 2nd most anticipated new meal experience of my upcoming summer trip. I cannot wait to try it here. (Biergarten is #1 )

 

[Leanne1977]

Raglan Road would be my top choice from your list. We had a lovely meal here and really enjoyed the atmosphere.

The GFC was also nice. We have only been for breakfast and it was very very fresh and tasty.

The only other one I have done from your list is Maya Grill and I hated it. The food was awful and the service was dire! We would never return.

I hear the Turf Club is getting good reviews and we are hoping to try it now we are DVC members.

 

[robinb]

It looks like a tie between Gackin' Yeti and Raglan Road so far. Any more opinions?

 

[Hopefully]

I voted for Raglan Road, San Angel Inn and The Wave. I have not been to the Wave yet, but I would love to try it.
We LOVED Raglan Road and it will be a must on our next trip. Adult DS was talking yesterday about the many menu items he wants to try. It is a beautiful restaurant, the food was excellent and the service was outstanding. I made an 8:30 ADR knowing the band started at 9. We enjoyed our dinner and then lingered to enjoy the entertainment. Our waiter was wonderful about keeping an eye on our beverage glasses and stopping by as necessary for a refill It was a fun evening.
We also ate at San Angel Inn. I nearly cancelled this several times based on the many vocal negative reviews here on the DIS. But DH and DS wanted to eat here. It was the surprise of the trip! It is beautiful and not too dark or crowded as some complain. The food was really good and we all enjoyed our meal. And the service was just right, attentive without being hovering. We will also return here.
Have a Great Trip.

 

[KatMark]

We have only done one of your choices and that was Maya Grill for breakfast. I'm not sure if you are looking breakfast for dinner. It was a good buffet. If you are looking at dinner, we ate at Boatwright's last year on our last night and it was by far the worse meal we ever had at Disney. However, I understand that the breakfast there is out of this world--especially the sweet potato pancakes (?).

 

[Tink888]

My vote is for Raglan Road. We had a great meal there in Nov and the band was a lot of fun. We have ADRs and will be trying Yak & Yeti, San Angel and Grand Floridan Cafe in Sept. Boatwrights was okay but not worth making a special trip for if you aren't staying at POR IMO. Haven't tried the others.