Hi!
Tough decision!
Favorite: 1900 Park Fare
Least Favorite: CRT/PSB
We were just there in May and ate at all 3 restaurants, but different meals:
CRT- breakfast. It was a zoo and we were so rushed! Our waiter (David) was horrible! He was condescending and seemed so phony. We were supposed to celebreate DD's 3rd birthday and the waiter totally forgot even though it was on the reservation ticket! The princesses were nice, but made very quick rounds!
We've eaten lunch and dinner here before and liked the menu.
------
1900 Park- dinner. We love this place. It really does have the best buffet food, as others have said. The chilled strawberry soup is yummy. It's nice and cheerfully decorated.
Cinderella, Price Charming, Suzy & Perla (mice) are the only circulating characters during dinner. They are able to make two rounds and spend lots of time with you. DD loved dancing with the mice! Fairy Godmother sits in the lobby for pics.
------
PSB- Lunch. This was ok. Food was ok. Cold table buffet was ok-- there was a tray of deviled eggs and someone before me had left all the yolk filling on the tray and only took the egg whites!?!
Princesses rushed by. Servers were very nice and had lots of info about the food.
Waiting area is woefully small and usually have to wait outside. Slow seating!
------
If I had to drop one, it'd be PSB. I'd rather eat in the CASTLE!
Have fun!