Which one??? Captain's Grille or Cape May Cafe for dinner??

[disneydiva24]

I am undecided in which one to choose???Looking for outstanding food around the HS or Epcot area. I am between these two.
Thanks!!! 4 more days!!!!!!!

 

[Hopefully]

I think with 4 days left you may be limited by which one is available.
If both are available they are very different experiences.
Cape May Cafe is a buffet - serve yourself. It has a focus on Seafood, but has many choices for non seafood lovers as well. Many people rave about the Crab Legs. It is all you care to eat. We were not overly impressed, but certainly didn't hate it.
Captain's Grill is an airy sit down restaurant. It has a set menu and you will be served at your table. It is very low key and relaxing. We think the menu has a bit of something for everyone, and we enjoyed it.
I think the Captain's Grill is more likely to be available on short notice that Cape May Cafe.
Enjoy

 

[WendyWuWu]

We just returned from WDW and had supper one night at Captain's Grille. I had one of the best rib eye steaks there I've ever eaten. I highly recommend it. And if you want seafood, I saw large plates of crab legs being served there as well.

 

[disneydiva24]

Thanks!!! Decided on Captain's Grille!

 

[rznhal]

Thanks!!! Decided on Captain's Grille!

Great! Please let us know what you think! We have a reservation in February

 

[goofy4prez]

Thanks!!! Decided on Captain's Grille!

I think you made the right decision. I am not a big fan of buffet food quality and found Cape May to be like any other buffet; very average at best. However, the crab legs are a nice thing to indulge in.

Captains Grille is a nice and quiet place and is not over the top in it's decour. I have been there three times and have always had excellent service and found the food to be very good. It was a nice discovery for us and I hope it will be the same for you.

 

[B-Ride]

We ate at both last year and preferred Cape May although we aren't generally big buffet fans.