Which is better- Mama Melrose or Tutto Italia?

[Belle_princess]

Just trying to decide.

 

[MrsLS]

Tutto, it was more authentic Italian. Mama melrose was not very good and the service wasn't good either.

 

[chocovrdmicears]

Definately Tutto.
Mama Melrose was ok...more of a typical 'chain' Italian rest.
Tutto, for us, had more of an authentic Italian taste.

 

[WDWBW09]

My wife and I have had meals at Alfredo's and Mama's. Both meals and atmosphere were fantastic. We were very sad to see Alfredo's leave WDW. So sad we made it a point to visit their restraunt in NYC. Of coarse it was different as is those who dine their.

Sorry missing Alfredo's can't help it...Never been to Tutto's

I don't believe you can go wrong with either.

 

[lisatx04]

Tutto's, in my opinion, is better. Better service, better food.
Hope this helps.

 

[Girlie1]

Another vote for Tutto's

 

[Golf4food]

Tutto.

 

[sammysmom]

We ate at Tutto for the first time last year and absolutely loved it The restaurant itself is beautiful and the food was amazing. Going there again this year! Good luck with your choice

 

[BraveLittleToaster2]

Tuttos is good, but insanely expensive...

 

[x5x5x5x5x5]

I agree with the previous poster - Tutto is good but in my opinion not worth the price. If you are on a dining plan, go for it - but if you are paying out of pocket, I would go for Mama Melrose. I've probably lunched there (never dinner) half a dozen times and had excellent service and good meals. We are not quick in and out diners - even our lunches take an hour and a half or longer. Usually we split the meat and cheese plate appetizer and then split an entree and a bottle of wine. I'd like to do that at Tutto but we'd spend twice as much. And to be honest, the only couple of times we dined at Tutto, our servers were not very friendly - BUT, seeing as how we've not gone there a lot, maybe we were just unlucky. Mama's certainly feels more casual and I believe you can sit outside at Tutto. Either way, you'll enjoy!

 

[irunnoft]

Tutto Italia is far better than Mama Melrose's. In my opinion, Epcot has the best TS of all the parks. The last time we ate at Mama Melrose's, I can only describe the food we were served as swill.

 

[MickeyNicki]

Tutto is much better, we like MM but it is more like Olive Garden to us. Our fave Italian is Il Mulino...that place is insanely fantastic!

 

[ROEDISNEY]

No ? Tutto

 

[MomtoGKC]

Tutto is much better, we like MM but it is more like Olive Garden to us. Our fave Italian is Il Mulino...that place is insanely fantastic!

We totally agree! We always try to go to Tutto (we rarely do sit downs except for this - one place all three of my kids love), but if we want to do a special dinner Il Mulino was SO good!!!

 

[bluejasmine]

Never been to Tutto.. Just b/c it seems to fancy after a day of the parks..

We love Mama Melrose..Olive Garden is one of my faves.. Maybe Im too easy to pls?? LOL