Can't really help as although we've dined at both we've only eaten at the Steakhouse in the Village for the Sunday Brunch. I liked both though, for the food as well as the theming.
we have eaten at both and found the food to be very tasty at both. We probably had slightly quicker service in the steakhouse. On the day we ate in the silver spur there was a slightly strange burnt oil smell but that was probably a one off