Which Butterbeer is your favorite?

[DisneyOma]

I like frozen the best out of the choices you provided but... the butter beer ice cream is my favorite.

I agree, the ice cream was the best - wish they made floats! I also wish the ice cream wasn't the ribbon-flavor style though. I want the flavor all the way through it.

 

[gerberdaisy1234]

I haven't tried the Ice Cream (I tried the Chocolate Chili and Apple Crumble instead both delicious). I thought all the varieties were good, but I'd rank them.

1)Frozen
2)Hot
3)Cold

Chocolate Chili!?!?!

 

[johde]

Chocolate Chili!?!?!

The best way to describe it was Chocolate ice cream with just a bit of a tickle in the back of your throat at the end. Although, the more you ate the more pronounced the chili became. But it never got what you'd call hot. It stayed in the spicy range.

 

[Kivara]

Chocolate chili was good (we tried all the hard scoop ice cream flavors) but my faves were earl grey/lavender and the clotted cream.

 

[PrincessJo]

Frozen is good, but the ice cream is my favorite now.

 

[chelynnah]

Do not ever get the drink over at New Fantasyland at Gaston's Tavern. Seriously. We looooove the frozen butterbeer, and had to throw out one full whatever-it's-called when the 3 of us could barely finish the other one we got (2 to share among 3 people sounded reasonable).

Really? Hubby and I loved the drink at Gaston's I could have had two! And we loved the Butterbeer when we were last there in January 2013. I didn't know there were varieties of the Butterbeer. I think we just had the drinks. Will have to look for the frozen option in November.

 

[chelynnah]

I haven't tried the Ice Cream (I tried the Chocolate Chili and Apple Crumble instead both delicious).

Hmmm something tells me that this will become a favourite with DH. Will have to tell him about it.

 

[lilkarebear]

I like all versions. Frozen is probably my favorite. Hot was really good but I burnt my tongue on it. The drink was trapped under the topping and then ouch, it escaped onto my tongue, lol.

I wish the ice cream wasn't just vanilla soft serve with the ribbon of butterbeer flavor. Although it is good, I would rather have it as a hard serve ice cream I think.

 

[sharona]

I agree, the ice cream was the best - wish they made floats! I also wish the ice cream wasn't the ribbon-flavor style though. I want the flavor all the way through it.

I wish it were hard serve which I prefer over soft, but it was still awesome.

 

[NewsiesGoil]

So far, the ice cream is my favorite! I'm excited to try the hot stuff this December. I was wearing my Butterbeer Tour shirt the last time I went there (May) and a couple of cast members said hot was the best way to drink it, but it was waaaay too hot out!

 

[Annchristine65]

I agree, the ice cream was the best - wish they made floats!

MMMMM, A scoop of the butterbeer ice cream in the cold butterbeer would be divine!!!

 

[macraven]

i like reading everyone's favorite but still sticking with my frozen in the voting.

all the other choices are in second place for me.
i love them all.

 

[RAPstar]

I prefer the cold. The frozen is too sweet, and the ice cream doesn't even taste like it. I look forward to trying the hot, and maybe the fudge.

 

[RAPstar]

MMMMM, A scoop of the butterbeer ice cream in the cold butterbeer would be divine!!!

It would be hard to scoop considering its soft serve

 

[rhondag508]

1. Cold
2. Ice Cream
3. Hot
4. Frozen

 

[Annchristine65]

It would be hard to scoop considering its soft serve

Ok, well then a dollop? I don't know, but I'm sure they could get in there somehow.

 

[cbsnyber1]

Is pumpkin juice still sold? I liked that stuff . . .

 

[macraven]

Yes

It will be there waiting for you to return

 

[bchbetha]

Thumbs up for all but frozen!

 

[schumigirl]

Is pumpkin juice still sold? I liked that stuff . . .

I really enjoyed the pumpkin fizz sold in the Hogshead.........wasn't sure if I would but the girl let me try a little before I bought it which was kind of her.........couldn't drink a lot, but I enjoyed it more than butterbeer.