When we returned to WDW in 2007 we stayed at Coronado Springs (a moderate.) It was OK, but it didn't live up to our first resort.
I haven't done... So, really you need to think about what you want in a resort... There are many good ones to choose from and it really is personal preference and $$$$...
Depending on what you want to spend, there are so many great options. With little kids, we really liked POP, the theming is cute, the price is right, they have their own bus and there is a food court for quick meals with tired kiddos. We feel like we don't spend a lot of time in the rooms, so as long as it's clean, safe and fun, we are happy....good luck with your plans!!![]()

If you are doing value--Pop is better in my opinion. It has its own bus system to the parks. At All Stars you may have to ride with Music, Movies and Sports guests with Movies usually being the last drop off. It is a little aggrevating at night when you are tired. Pop is newer although we have had nice rooms at All Stars. We trully do not spend any time at the resort so Moderate and Deluxe do not fit us, we stay at the value resorts. We do not swim or drink and we usually eat at the parks. I believe All Star has suites now which may be more economical for a family with several kids.
The cool thing about Moderate and Deluxe resorts are that their pick up and drop off is much closer to the gate that those of the Value resorts. We Value Dissers have more walking to do.
Have a fun time planning!!
Thank you all for the suggestions. I'm not really sure what the "budget" will be yet. I was looking at renting DVC points for one of the resorts. I just haven't quite figured that process out yet. Any pointers on that would be great.
I suppose we could show up at Boardwalk Villas in June, only to find that the owner we rented from has sold her points and cancelled our reservation. But I really don't think that will be the case. I guess that's why not everyone rents points - something could go wrong and Disney has nothing to do with it. But I have faith!
check out the bonnet creek