I asked this same question several weeks ago since we will be at WDW for our 10th anniversary this summer. The consensus seemed to be California Grill, Citricos or Narcoossee's. Jiko and Artist Point were also mentioned but less often. Since we are not big on seafood, Narcoossee's went off the list (although they have non-seafood dishes too) but we have reservations at the other two and will try to decide once we get closer to the trip. It sounds as if California Grill is louder so less romantic but better if you are going with kids, which we are. Hope that helps!