Where in WDW is the best Key Lime Pie?

[abeyst]

The Key Lime at the Main Street Bakery is Pie. It's HUGE, you should share with someone.

I CAN eat my weight in Key Lime Pie-I plan on keeping every bite for myself! Luckily my kids hate it so I don't have to feel bad hogging it all for myself!

Thank you everyone for your clarification. I'll update the list, in case there's anyone else who would like to reference it.

 

[abeyst]

Let me know if there's any additions or revisions. Thank you again to all who posted.

TARTS
Boardwalk Bakery
Grand Floridian

PIE
Cape May Cafe
Crystal Palace
Fultons
House of Blues
The Land
Main Street Bakery
Olivia's
Yachtsman Steakhouse

Narcoosee's (Key Lime Creme Brulee)

 

[Gary M]

I didn't order it, but DW likes the key lime pie at The Flame Tree BBQ in AK. It's a counter service restaurant.

 

[RoyalCanadian]

I'll second Gary M's suggestion of the Flame Tree BBQ at AK -- DW had it and enjoyed it just this past Monday (10 JAN) while I was revelling in the wonders of a frozen lemonade.

 

[ciera321]

I always get key lime pie at any Rainforest I eat at. It's a huge piece and sooooo creamy and yummy!!!

 

[skondo10]

We always enjoy the Key Lime Pie at Olivia's. It's the best Key Lime Pie I have ever had. It is shaped like a giant tart. I actually think they call it a Key Lime Tart (but it is fairly big).
On our Dec. trip I tried the Key Lime Pie at the Yachtsman and it was pretty good as well. But I would definately say Olivia's is the way to go!

 

[BadgerBruce]

Had excellent key lime pie at Wolfgang Puck Express at Downtown Disney West Side.

 

[abeyst]

I've been to the World so many times, and I never knew so many restaurants had key lime pie. Thank you, thank you, thank you all for your suggestions. (You've given me so many, maybe my next post should be "Where in WDW is the WORST key lime pie?" !! )

My mouth is already watering just thinking about all the pie I get to eat next week!


TARTS
Boardwalk Bakery
Grand Floridian

PIE
Cape May Cafe
Crystal Palace
Flame Tree BBQ
Fultons
House of Blues
The Land
Main Street Bakery
Olivia's
Rainforest Cafe
Wolfgang Puck Express
Yachtsman Steakhouse

Narcoosee's (Key Lime Creme Brulee)