Where in WDW is the best Key Lime Pie?

[abeyst]

I'm a huge key lime pie fan, but I don't know where to find it at WDW. Instead of checking all the menus on Deb's site, I thought this might be a little quicker, and I can get some personal testimonials.

Thanks!

 

[magicmouse2]

Me too yet I dont remember seeing it anywhere ?Maybe the cheesecake factory at DQ sells it ?

 

[Minnie824]

Back in 2000, DH and I went and we had it at Fultons. It was excellent! They also had Key Lime Tarts at Boardwalk Bakery which were very good too, but I vote for Fultons.

 

[EEyorelover22]

At H&V in June 04 they have mini Key Lime pies...they were wonderful so I wonder if you could find it at the bakery at MGM since I think they make the items for H&V. I love Key Lime pie and they do have a Key Lime cheesecake at Cheesecake Factory sometimes, but the texture is very different and if you don't like cheesecake, you might not like this.

 

[StaceyA]

I had key lime pie for the first time ever in Dec at Crystal Palace, I thought it was really good, but I have nothing to compare it to!

 

[crisi]

Narcoosee's has a key lime creme brulee.

 

[PrincessCandaceMarie]

Try the Key Lime Pie at Fulton's at DTD, at the Bakery on Main St. in MK, and The Land at Epcot MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

 

[Alice28]

The two times I dined at Cape May Cafe, it was on their dessert buffet and it was pretty tasty.

 

[Docsknotinn]

Another vote for Fulton's.

 

[bekkiz]

I liked the one at House of Blues a lot!

 

[beccasmom]

Olivia's at OKW has it, but I'm not sure if they always offer it.

 

[Bride In The Attic]

When we ate at Cape May Cafe our CM specifically said their Key Lime pie ranks among the best - it was very good.

 

[abeyst]

OK, so we have the following:

Boardwalk Bakery (Tarts)
Grand Floridian (Tarts)

Cape May Cafe (Pie)
Crystal Palace (Pie)
Fultons (Pie)
House of Blues (Pie)
The Land (Pie)
Main Street Bakery (Pie)
Olivia's (Pie)
Yachtsman Steakhouse (Pie)

Narcoosee's (Key Lime Creme Brulee)

Let me know if this needs updating. Thank you everyone for your responses. I'm mainly interested in a slice of pie and not the tarts (I've had those), but I'll take whatever I can get. This is one list I will be printing out before we leave next week!

 

[erikthewise]

While I haven't tried them all, I certainly enjoyed the one I had at Olivia's. It has a scrumptious graham cracker-style crust. If it isn't the best, it should be!

 

[CoolDisneyCat]

During our Dec. trip we had key lime pie at 2 places not yet mentioned.

At the Grand Floridian Cafe they have little tarts with caramalized sugar on top. These are very very good. I'm not sure "tart" is the correct word, but the GF Cafe sizes all their desserts small so you can get more than one.

We also enjoyed very good key lime pie at the Yachtsman Steakhouse. We had it as part of the dessert sampler, but you can order it seperately as well.

Have fun taste testing and picking your fave!

 

[Alice28]

OK, so we have the following:

Cape May Cafe (Tarts or pie?)
Crystal Palace (Tarts or pie?)
Main Street Bakery (Tarts or pie?)

Boardwalk Bakery (Tarts)

Fultons (Pie)
Olivia's (Pie)
The Land (Pie)
House of Blues (Pie)

Narcoosee's (Key Lime Creme Brulee)


Let me know if this needs updating. Thank you everyone for your responses. I'm mainly interested in a slice of pie and not the tarts (I've had those), but I'll take whatever I can get. This is one list I will be printing out before we leave next week!

I know it was sliced pie at Cape May Cafe.

 

[briannesmom]

The Key Lime Pie at House of Blues was awesome and they give you a really big piece too

Amy

 

[Davids-Coco]

The little ones at GF are the same ones they have in GF concierge. They are definately tarts... and I could eat my weight in them every night cuz they are so good. LOL, makes concierge worth the money... the weight is another story!

 

[StaceyA]

OK, so we have the following:


Crystal Palace (Tarts or pie?)

When I had it at the Crystal Palace it was pie.

 

[queenmichelle]

The Key Lime at the Main Street Bakery is Pie. It's HUGE, you should share with someone.

I personally found the key lime tart at GF cafe to be not so good. It was a bizzare combination of flavors. A chocolate crust the key lime filling and camalized sugar on top. The sugar was kind of burnt so I scraped it off after a couple of bites but it still had a burnt taste to it. Yuck!