The WDW resorts where we have stayed in the last 2 years are (starting with our least favorite and ending with our favorite):
1. Dolphin - Found that it was like walking thru a maze to get to our room from the elevator (many twists and turns). Very big hotel which IMHO lacked that Disney feeling.
2. Contemporary - Enjoyed the convenience of the monorail and being able to walk to MK. Nice size rooms but didn't like the decor. Also didn't care for the themeing of the resort and kids thought the pool was boring.
3. Beach Club - On the negative side, our room seemed like it was miles away from the lobby but on the positive side, we were very close to the building exit (which was just a few steps away from Epcot's International Gateway entrance). We could walk out of our room and be at the entrance in less than 2 min.!!! Great pool but very crowded (and this was before the BCV opened). Rooms were nothing special.
4. Wilderness Lodge Villas (studio) - We stayed here soon after they opened so everything was brand new and very nice. The Lodge is beautiful, especially at that time of year (early Dec.). The x-mas tree and fireplace were lovely. To get to MK you had to walk down a path to the dock to catch a boat, which was not as fast or convenient as the monorail.
5. Boardwalk Inn - Enjoyed the fact that this was a much smaller resort and seemed very quiet. Of the Epcot resorts, the Boardwalk is our favorite, however we prefer the villas side. Nice rooms but our room had a very strong odor which I couldn't identify (perhaps a cleanser of some sort ???).
6. Grand Floridian - Very nice resort with beautiful grounds and lovely rooms. I stayed here on my last trip (May '02)when I went with my mother and we enjoyed our stay. I couldn't help thinking though that if this had been a family trip (my family of 5, inc. 3 young kids) we would have felt more at home at the Polynesian.
7. Polynesian - I would have to say that is my family's favorite MK resort. We enjoy the convenience of the monorail, like both of the restaurants, love the whole Polynesian theme with its beautiful grounds and waterfalls, like their large and comfortable rooms, and the kids really like the pool (almost as much as Stormalong Bay).
8. AKL - This is a beautiful resort, inside and out. The lobby is gorgeous, the rooms are beautifully decorated (the bunk beds were a big hit with the kids), enjoyed watching the animals from our balcony, and loved to shop in their store. The only negative would be that the only form of transportation to the parks is the bus (although you don't have to share with other resorts, which is good).
9. BWV - The one-bedroom villas here are our absolute favorite of all. They are huge (bigger than my first apartment, LOL!) and have so many nice features (lika a jacuzzi and washer and dryer etc.) that I could go on forever about how wonderfu they are. I could live in one of these villas at WDW for months and be happy as a clam, LOL!