OT, but I have hypothyroidism too, and my doctor has never recommended avoiding these vegetables. What reason were you given? Thanks!
I'm interested, too. Oddly, my hypothyroidism was "cured", but I was never told that, either. And I don't want it to come back!
A lot of it depends on your dr. or endocrinologist and whether he believes nutrition plays a part, or if he's the kind who is just going to give a prescription for a synthetic drug and that's the only way to heal/treat hypothyroidism.
I believe nutrition does play a key part. I also have hypoglycemia, so I know what I eat plays a major part in my health. I didn't just want to get an endo who was going to give me a prescription and tell me to come back in 3 months and he'd adjust my meds.
Just as hypoglycemics & diabetics have to monitor their sugar/carbs intake, and people with high blood pressure have to avoid salt, there are many studies which state eating cruciferous vegetables: broccoli, cauliflower, turnips, cabbage, bak choy interfere with the thyroid functioning for people with hypothyroidism.
This is just my experience, but it has been making sense to me. I ate ALL of these. I also ate hardly any salt, and the salt I did eat was sea salt, which is devoid of iodine. Iodine deficiency is also a cause of hypothyroidism.
I ate a lot of soy, which also causes problems with hypothyroidism.
I found I have uterine fibroids and fibroidy "girls." (NO! I am not a hypochondriac!) Part of the reason the fibroids are growing is because my Aunt Flo has gotten the size of Jabba the Hut. I am trying to shrink the uterine fibroids so I do my have to get a uterine embolization to have them removed.
Hypothyroidism and Iodine deficiency cause BOTH excessively heavy periods
and fibroids.
To me, all those dots in my body are connected. In the last four months, as I changed my diet, included a lot of
natural supplements for hypothyroidism and adrenal fatigue, including iodine, cut out red meats & soy, (which are high estrogen foods, and I don't need more estrogen down there creating fibroids,) my Aunt Flow, which was lasting for about 20 days, super heavy every day, and I went through a whole bag of the super-extra-heavy, overnight, extra, extra-long Always pads, down to a much healthier 4 heavy days and a few days of spotting.

The "girls" seem less bumpy.
My energy level has gone way up. My moods and snarkiness are so-so, depending if I've been regulating all of this, day to day. I just added sublingual Vit B12 to my supplements, and the last of the brain fog is going away!
I really hope I can make my hypothyroidism completely disappear, not just regulate it. If eating different veggies help, I'm all for it. As long as I'm still eating other vegetables I can swap in, I figure I'll be fine. If everything I'm doing is just a placebo, well it's working.
