I think the BWV is a REALLY nice resort, but we did sell our points there to buy BCV. Our reasons were:
1) Can stay at BCV and pool-hop to BWV, but not the other way around (not that we are pool hoppers, but nice to know we can).
2) The BW is built up and away from the water, the BCV has a beach where you can sink your toes in the sand, watch Illuminations from the beach all the while enjoying an "adult beverage" from Hurricane Hannas. My dd also loves to go to the beach to feed the ducks.
3) We love that the hotel was built "around" the pool, and that the pool is on the lake side of the hotel. There really is no more beautiful sight than sitting in a chair at SAB looking at the BWV (day or night), or sitting in a chair at SAB watching Illuminations over the roof of the beautiful hotel.
4) We like the amenities of the BCV better than those of BWV. We think the Marketplace is nicer (and less crowded) than the Screen Porch. We love the fact that you can get custom salads, sandwiches, gourmet desserts and yummy gelato in the shop, as well as fill your mugs. We love the fact that there is a character b'fast on site for out dd. We LOVE Beaches and Cream, and even Hurricane Hanna's is GREAT. We love just "hanging out" and eating at SAB...seeing all the soothing blue colors, and hearing the waterfalls.
5) We love the fact that some rooms overlook Epcot and Illuminations...not all, but some...and, we simply ADORE getting those rooms. One room we had overlooked SSE, and was over the water. Every morning our dd would wake up and throw bread off the balcony to feed the turtles....it was really cool!
6) SAB itself....it really is a magical pool!!! For a couple of years, it was the ONLY pool my dd would swim in, and she talked about it almost non-stop. The sand-bottom experience was SOO cool to her, that it got her over her fear of the water. She would sit in the kiddie area and play for HOURS...she couldn't get enough of it. SAB is the ONLY reason we go to WDW at warm times of the year.
I do like many of the
DVC resorts (we have, at one time owned at 4 of them), but now we just own at BCV...we simply cannot get enough of that place. I would definitely think, if you are torn between the two, you might want to wait to purchase until you can see BCV for yourself. It sounds like you already have some "resort envy". You wouldn't want to sell SSR and buy BWV, only to discover that you REALLY like BCV!! BWV may be the best resort for you, but there really is only one way to be sure.
Good luck!!!
Beca