We were very disappointed in the shuttle service from an offsite hotel the one time we stayed offsite, the very first time we ever stayed at WDW with our 3yo young son. We had booked a 2 night stay. We were staying with relatives in Florida, and had decided to make a two day side trip to WDW, the whole group of us, 4 adults and three children. We were informed when we arrived that shuttles needed to be "scheduled" 24 hours in advance. At this particular place, shuttles were very infrequent. So, we ended up driving, of course, and paying for parking. As I remember, we had only one vehicle, a van. After that experience, we decided to stay onsite, just for the reliable transportation alone. This particular hotel was about the same cost as the All-Stars at the time. I don't even remember the hotel. Decided it just wasn't worth the inconvenience for the cost involved. We made our next reservation at the All-Stars. Now, we have DVC. Sometimes we drive, and if we want to split up, we are free to take the buses and shuttles.