What happened on American Idol last night?

[Liz]

We weren't home and I forgot to record it! If anyone can provide a recap I'd sure appreciate it! Thanks!

 

[elgerber]

Not too much to re-cap. Simon was not there, he was on a TV screen sitting in his spot, until Paula unplugged him. Ruben and Kimberly are going on (which is who I picked, they are great). Ruben and his brother made a Seacrest sandwich again, and gave him a bloody lip LOL. Did anyone see clips of Seacrest after the show? His lip was all red and swollen.

Erika

 

[becka]

Ruben and Kimberly are in the top 10. Clay was 3rd in the votes. I am really hoping that he will be one of the wild cards.

I still don't get why people like Ruben so much. He sang again last night and I didn't like it anymore the second time around.

 

[Luckymommyx2]

I think Clay will be an alternate. I really hope that Kimberly will sing something other than 'Over the Rainbow' for the ***th time!JMHO.

 

[Miss Jasmine]

I was happy to see Ruben go on, but really wanted Clay. I can do with out Kimberly and her stupid Over the Rainbow. Plus she needs some help in the fashion department. Sorry but that's JMHO. Something about panty lines that really annoys me.

 

[pajamommy]

I was happy to see Ruben go on, but really wanted Clay. I can do with Kimberly and her stupid Over the Rainbow. Plus she needs some help in the fashion department. Sorry but that's JMHO. Something about panty lines that really annoys me.

I couldn't agree with you more! I really don't like her for some reason, she has a great voice, but I don't care for her style or attitude I guess. I really wanted Clay to be the other one last night, or Hadas.

 

[jrmasm]

DH said "tight pants should be a privilege."

I missed the Tuesday show, what was the deal with Kimberly and Simon that led to last nights poll??

 

[Tess]

Kimberly could use a fashion makeover. Did anyone see Starr Jones on the view--she was talking about how Kimberly "never saw herself" as the "big girl" until she was placed in the "big girl category" on AI. Puhleeze. . . Starr went on to note she thought the "girl looked sexy" in the outfit she wore on Tuesday--not so, says I. Sheer is fine, BUT she needs some help because the outfit itself was just wrong--I wouldn't have liked it much better on Twiggy. Then there's Reuben's fashion statement--hip hop understated? Not sure what he's going for there. . . Guess that's why I'm not the fashion coordinator for the show--can you believe they actually GET help with these clothes!

I'm still shaking my head over Reuben's performance, just don't get it I guess--didn't give me goosebumps as some of these singers do--that's my only performance indicator, not appearance, clothes, etc.--although I'm not blind. I also hope Clay gets a nod for the top 10 by the judges.

Am I the only one that didn't get the attraction to the first "Kim?"--the blonde that argued with the hairdresser that won last week? She, also, didn't give me any tingles when she sang? I hope the judges choose SUBSTANCE over APPEARANCE when they get to make a decision on the wild card contestants. I think they give too much weight to the "image" factor.

 

[pajamommy]

Am I the only one that didn't get the attraction to the first "Kim?"--the blonde that argued with the hairdresser that won last week?

I didn't care for her either, I didn't like her voice or personality. I thought she talked too much!! And although I love Ruben, I hope he starts wearing something other than his area code, lol!!

 

[kamgen]

I was totally upset last night! what is America thinking????? I wanted Ruben and Hadas to make it....when Kim got announced over Hadas, I was upset....then when Kim beat out Clay, I was livid!
She just got up like she knew she was going to make it. The conceit drives me nuts!!!!!!!!!

Oh well, what can we do now...........I voted for my favorites.

Kamy