Where should I post them to sell (not here!) I couldn't find any on ebay, and have never dealt with craigslist. Is there any place you all would suggest?
I would do Craigslist for local pickup only for CASH only. Ebay will charge you fees and then you have to use paypal (more fees) plus if you get a scammer buying the tickets they can file a chargeback claiming the tickets are no good and get all of their money back.
YES! I had this happen to me about 7 years ago on Yahoo Auctions...was not a pleasant experience. Did you try the trading thread? Maybe you can trade them here for something(s) or gift cards that someone else is looking to get rid of....just a thought.
I thought that trading items in exchange for gift cards were against the rules. Why are they different than trading for cash (which is just another name for selling)?