WDW requiring credit card ressie for meals-NUTS!

I agree with you. Two years ago we all came down with the swine flu at Disney and ended up cancelling 2 days worth of ADR's and ordering room service at the Polynesian. I can't imagine being charged a couple of hundred dollars in missed dining reservation fees on top of it.
Not everybody is out to work the system. Anyone can run into a problem on vacation that can disrupt a dining reservation, and it doesn't always conveniently happen before the 24 hour mark. It'll be interesting to see how this policy plays out over the next few months.

You really think Disney would be heartless and charge you?

I think they are smart to not post a laundry list of acceptable reasons to escape the penalty.
 
You really think Disney would be heartless and charge you?

I think they are smart to not post a laundry list of acceptable reasons to escape the penalty.

I don't think heart has anything to do with it. It's all about the bottom line, I get that. I wonder what kind of reasons, proof, etc. would be acceptable. I mean - if the whole idea is keeping people honest - how do you allow exceptions? One strike, two strikes ... I'm curious as to how it will be handled going forward.
 
You are not being ignored...folks just don't necessarily agree. It is just one of those chances you take.

However--what folks may or may not realize is this...

Take your doctor's office. Mine have strict policies. But they do understand that things do happen. I had one where I completely forgot about an appointment and even though they have a strict no-show policy, they did not charge me the fee.

Today--I was late for an appointment by 30 minutes! I had the time right in my phone, but totally remembered it wrong. They have a strict policy to cancel the appt. But I was seen anyway. I made a mistake and they aren't ogres.

These policies are to deter the epidemic lack of courtesy.

People are freaking, but they are forgetting this is Disney. I don't think there will be this epidemic of fibbers making up valid reasons to cancel. I think that as long as you call--it might turn out okay.

As far as weather...no, I don't think they should make a weather exception unless a weather calamity is forecast (hurricane or other emergent weather condition).

As far as the stars aligning with kids--frankly, I am a bit over the kids excuse. I know that my kids may slow me down...so I plan accordingly. And if I have to eat a fee because our plans explode, so be it.

I think folks tend to be too uptight with planning the perfect vacation and the thought of a penalty for a last minute cancellation is just too much to take. But in the end--failure to plan on my part does not constitute an emergency on their part.

(and no--real emergency issues that are not of my own doing as a guest or as a parent are different. But allowing only 15 minutes to get from Magic Kingdom, to Hollywood studios, through security and to the Brown Derby for dinner does not count as a problem caused by Disney. Nor is skipping junior's nap so he could ride his favorite ride causing him to have a meltdown that delays our departure and makes us too grumpy for dinner.)

Well said Lisa.
 
Plenty of ways to get around it. I go with my daughter, son-in-law, husband, plus me. That is 4 people with 4 different email addresses, plus my 2 granddaughters also have email addresses -- this isn't rocket science.

I understand it isn't rocket science. Before reading the different threads about this topic, I had NO idea that double/triple booking was possible. Every time I attempted to make an ADR around the same time, to replace one with the other, the computer gave me an error to either cancel or stop your attempt. I never have had a "need" to double/triple book.

I was obviously naive.
 
I don't think empty tables in a restaurant can automatically be attributed to no shows. We have had trouble getting reservations before and I once commented that I was surprised to see empty tables since the online booking tool had said they were booked solid and there were walk-ups hoping to be seated (the people in front of us at the check-in stand were hoping for a walk-up).

The waitress told me that they weren't staffed for maximum capacity that night (we were there during a slower season.) I assume that meant that they had booked all the reservations they felt they could handle with the staff they had on hand... but they didn't have enough staff to work every table in the restaurant, so some tables were sitting empty.

We've never missed an ADR. I don't have a problem with the new policy as long as they offer an exception for a true emergency (illness, etc.) However, I really think the better solution would be just to shorten the ADR booking window. I'm a pretty big planner (and I've never double-booked), but even I don't want to think about where I'll eat six months from now. If they shortened the window (to three months? one month in advance?) maybe people would have a better idea about their touring schedule and wouldn't make so many back-up reservations.

If they make exceptions for illness than that is what everybody is going to claim they had to get out of paying. They can't let some ppl slide and not others. I hope they strictly enforce this new rule. And I hope they implement other ways of thwarting those who still are going to hoard ADRs through multiple account/relatives/friends names, etc.
 
Frankly, I think Disney is being generous by allowing guests to even cancel at 24 hours.

It should be 72 hours at the minimum!!>>>> LMAO!! I agree! Better yet, why not 7 days notice???

If they make exceptions for illness than that is what everybody is going to claim they had to get out of paying. They can't let some ppl slide and not others. I hope they strictly enforce this new rule. And I hope they implement other ways of thwarting those who still are going to hoard ADRs through multiple account/relatives/friends names, etc. >>>>>> clap! clap! clap! Very well said!! Thats what i was trying to say earlier. how can they make exceptions for one family and not another? They need to stick to their guns, $10 pp no exceptions.

:thumbsup2
 
I was charged $10 a person 7-8 years ago when my DD threw up during the night and I cancelled our ressie for 4 at the epcot princess breakfast in the morning, past the cancellation grace period.. I understood why they didn't make an exception but still felt ripped off. Can't say that we booked many princess meals after that.

Guess I can some what understand this new policy, but it still seems cheap and petty. Get sick at Disney and in addition to being sick on vacation, losing time in the parks, losing $$ on expensive tickets, you'll now get charged if you miss cancelling a ressie in time.

This past August at Ohanna one of ther servers was going on and on about 'no recession here, packed every night'. Guess this is just another way to pull in more bucks.

Hmmmm, do I really need to dine at these places?
 
You are not being ignored...folks just don't necessarily agree. It is just one of those chances you take.However--what folks may or may not realize is this...

Take your doctor's office. Mine have strict policies. But they do understand that things do happen. I had one where I completely forgot about an appointment and even though they have a strict no-show policy, they did not charge me the fee.

Today--I was late for an appointment by 30 minutes! I had the time right in my phone, but totally remembered it wrong. They have a strict policy to cancel the appt. But I was seen anyway. I made a mistake and they aren't ogres.

These policies are to deter the epidemic lack of courtesy.

People are freaking, but they are forgetting this is Disney. I don't think there will be this epidemic of fibbers making up valid reasons to cancel. I think that as long as you call--it might turn out okay.

As far as weather...no, I don't think they should make a weather exception unless a weather calamity is forecast (hurricane or other emergent weather condition).
As far as the stars aligning with kids--frankly, I am a bit over the kids excuse. I know that my kids may slow me down...so I plan accordingly. And if I have to eat a fee because our plans explode, so be it.

I think folks tend to be too uptight with planning the perfect vacation and the thought of a penalty for a last minute cancellation is just too much to take. But in the end--failure to plan on my part does not constitute an emergency on their part.

(and no--real emergency issues that are not of my own doing as a guest or as a parent are different. But allowing only 15 minutes to get from Magic Kingdom, to Hollywood studios, through security and to the Brown Derby for dinner does not count as a problem caused by Disney. Nor is skipping junior's nap so he could ride his favorite ride causing him to have a meltdown that delays our departure and makes us too grumpy for dinner.)

I felt like I was being ignored bc everyone is ASSUMING that the people who are displeased with this new announcement are abusers and there are many who are not.


I think weather should be a huge factor....this is suppose to be a vacation, I dont want to have to go somewhere if the weather is rainy or cold. I would like choose what we do and not have to blow $40 bucks bc of Mother Nature.

I think from a marketing standpoint if they dont make expections for sickness and weather, they are going to have a lot of unhappy guests. If we had to plug on with our orignal plans during those record low colds all to avoid fees, my family would have been miserable. We were already pretty miserable when we had to keep our CP dinner and show in order to avoid a fee on the coldest night in FL history. And we dont go to WDW on that tight a budget, but I certainly dont have $40 to blow either. But bc at the time WDW was so flexible I was able to rearrange reservations the night before and my family had a great time despite a few bumps in the road, but if we had to attempt to trek around AK in the cold all to avoid a dining fee, we would have been very unhappy visitors! Instead we switched to Epoct that day bc most of the attractions were indoors, we stayed warm and enjoyed our vaction.
 
WRONG! I rearranged two ADRS but one was not in the 24 hour range. Would I have been charged $40 or is WDW going to allow for a weather issue?

I think this is going to make a vacation less enjoyable when you have to constantly worry if all the stars are going to line up so you know you can make your ADR at Chef Mickey. Things happen ESPECIALLY when traveling with kids, I am always courteous and call and cancel.

So I am one of those people who always played by the rules, and does not like this new policy one bit!

But I guess I am on ignore bc no one seems to be acknowleding those posters.

I actually think that Disney is attempting to curb the double and triple booking of ADR's and is not going to penalize folks who call and cancel within a reasonable time frame. I realize that the new policy seems to be cut and dried but Disney policy is seldom hard and fast so I bet that there will be no charges unless people choose to simply skip their ADR. I know that it is easy to make those additional reservations, pick the one that works for your family and ignore the rest that are made for that same time frame. I believe that is what Disney is trying to manage.

I think that a family friendly destination like Disney will try not to impose penalties on folks who try to work withing the framework that is set up.

These policies are to deter the epidemic lack of courtesy.

People are freaking, but they are forgetting this is Disney. I don't think there will be this epidemic of fibbers making up valid reasons to cancel. I think that as long as you call--it might turn out okay.

As far as weather...no, I don't think they should make a weather exception unless a weather calamity is forecast (hurricane or other emergent weather condition).

As far as the stars aligning with kids--frankly, I am a bit over the kids excuse. I know that my kids may slow me down...so I plan accordingly. And if I have to eat a fee because our plans explode, so be it.

I think folks tend to be too uptight with planning the perfect vacation and the thought of a penalty for a last minute cancellation is just too much to take. But in the end--failure to plan on my part does not constitute an emergency on their part.

(and no--real emergency issues that are not of my own doing as a guest or as a parent are different. But allowing only 15 minutes to get from Magic Kingdom, to Hollywood studios, through security and to the Brown Derby for dinner does not count as a problem caused by Disney. Nor is skipping junior's nap so he could ride his favorite ride causing him to have a meltdown that delays our departure and makes us too grumpy for dinner.)

I agree that Disney is reacting to this mess the ADR system has become. People who work so hard to cover every possibility that may happen and still have the perfect meal set up so that every possibility has a back-up plan are part of the reason it is next to impossible to get an ADR for one of the more popular TS restaurants unless you are calling as far out as is allowed.

When I plan meals I try to take into account how my DGD will be at that particular time of day. Hauling her out for rope drop and going all day means that there is not going to be a California Grill meal during the Fireworks display. No way are we going to get to Crystal Palace for 8:05 when we kept her out til closing the night before. There was one time we miscalculated how long she would last and there was no way we would drag her through EPCOT when she was clearly too tired. We cancels Coral Reef early in the day and made alternate plans at our resort restaurant so that she could wind down and rest. Had we been charged the penalty I would have paid it but if there are no exceptions for cranky kids I foresee several nightmares a night for guests who get the pleasure of sharing their meal with children whose parent miscalculated and do not want to lose any money. I have been in the YS twice when parents judgement was clouded and it was not pleasant. One screaming baby up way too late was not the way I envisioned our family meal. Sitting next to a very sick child sprawled out over two chairs while the rest of her family ate dinner was also a little disturbing. :sad2::sick:

I don't think heart has anything to do with it. It's all about the bottom line, I get that. I wonder what kind of reasons, proof, etc. would be acceptable. I mean - if the whole idea is keeping people honest - how do you allow exceptions? One strike, two strikes ... I'm curious as to how it will be handled going forward.

Personally, I think that Disney is not reacting to the bottom line in regards to the ten dollars. I think that there is a lot of negative feedback from folks who are paying for the DDP and then cannot get into the restaurant of their choice while in reality there is room for them.

Not everyone books their vacations a year out, gets up at the crack of dawn to call at 7AM 180 days out and continually fine tunes their plans for every day. There are plenty of folks who book their vacations a few months out and then try to use their dining credits only to find that they are out of luck unless they want to arrive at very inconvenient times. I think that Disney is trying to accommodate those people who want to enjoy the dining and character aspect of Disney but are left out due to those uber planners who are abusing the system
 
I think it's a great idea. Many times we have tried to make ressies and were unsuccessful, even months out. Maybe this will deter those that make multiple ressies and don't keep them. I say hold them accountable.
 
I think people too often confuse need and want. I checked Maslow's hierarchy and no where on the pyramid is a Disney dinning reservation.

Well, the last time I checked, a Disney vacation wasn't anywhere on that hierarchy either. So saying that any of this is "necessary" is silly.

The bottom line is Disney wants people to use the ADR system a certain way and they are instituting a policy that attempts to punish those who try and use it a different way.

Yep. Their company, their rules. If it bothers people that much, there are plenty of other places to take a vacation. Wailing about it on the DIS gets you exactly nowhere. ;)
 
Yep. Their company, their rules. If it bothers people that much, there are plenty of other places to take a vacation. Wailing about it on the DIS gets you exactly nowhere. ;)

That's what The Dis is for, whining and complaining about how unfair life is. :rotfl:
 
I felt like I was being ignored bc everyone is ASSUMING that the people who are displeased with this new announcement are abusers and there are many who are not.


I think weather should be a huge factor....this is suppose to be a vacation, I dont want to have to go somewhere if the weather is rainy or cold. I would like choose what we do and not have to blow $40 bucks bc of Mother Nature.

Really? well I guess you never should visit Disney Paris. We plowed through a meter of snow in the park to get to the restaurant. Bad weather is just something that exist in somebody's mind. We just laugh at rain or cold and I guess 99% of the WDW visitors does the same.

I think from a marketing standpoint if they dont make expections for sickness and weather, they are going to have a lot of unhappy guests. If we had to plug on with our orignal plans during those record low colds all to avoid fees, my family would have been miserable. We were already pretty miserable when we had to keep our CP dinner and show in order to avoid a fee on the coldest night in FL history. And we dont go to WDW on that tight a budget, but I certainly dont have $40 to blow either. But bc at the time WDW was so flexible I was able to rearrange reservations the night before and my family had a great time despite a few bumps in the road, but if we had to attempt to trek around AK in the cold all to avoid a dining fee, we would have been very unhappy visitors! Instead we switched to Epoct that day bc most of the attractions were indoors, we stayed warm and enjoyed our vaction.

If we would have to worry about a lousy 40 Dollars we would just stayed at home.
Problems and weather happen and we just can't blame Disney for everything.

 
Yep. Their company, their rules. If it bothers people that much, there are plenty of other places to take a vacation. Wailing about it on the DIS gets you exactly nowhere. ;)

:rotfl2: But it's so much fun! :laughing:

I don't think Disney would be doing this at all unless they were losing money from people doing this so good for them for taking a stand. Hopefully it will help Disney and help us too.
 
That's what The Dis is for, whining and complaining about how unfair life is. :rotfl:

And blaming Disney for the weather and "sickness " mostly caused by reheating food from a dogie bag :rotfl2:
Let's reheat the left over fish, meat, pasta with the hair blower.:laughing:
 
I felt like I was being ignored bc everyone is ASSUMING that the people who are displeased with this new announcement are abusers and there are many who are not.


I think weather should be a huge factor....this is suppose to be a vacation, I dont want to have to go somewhere if the weather is rainy or cold. I would like choose what we do and not have to blow $40 bucks bc of Mother Nature.

Really? well I guess you never should visit Disney Paris. We plowed through a meter of snow in the park to get to the restaurant. Bad weather is just something that exist in somebody's mind. We just laugh at rain or cold and I guess 99% of the WDW visitors does the same.

I think from a marketing standpoint if they dont make expections for sickness and weather, they are going to have a lot of unhappy guests. If we had to plug on with our orignal plans during those record low colds all to avoid fees, my family would have been miserable. We were already pretty miserable when we had to keep our CP dinner and show in order to avoid a fee on the coldest night in FL history. And we dont go to WDW on that tight a budget, but I certainly dont have $40 to blow either. But bc at the time WDW was so flexible I was able to rearrange reservations the night before and my family had a great time despite a few bumps in the road, but if we had to attempt to trek around AK in the cold all to avoid a dining fee, we would have been very unhappy visitors! Instead we switched to Epoct that day bc most of the attractions were indoors, we stayed warm and enjoyed our vaction.

If we would have to worry about a lousy 40 Dollars we would just stayed at home.
Problems and weather happen and we just can't blame Disney for everything.


And I have no desire to vacation in Paris in those conditions.

And I guess the recession must not be so bad for some people if they have $40 + to waste on missed dinners. We are talking MEALS here people, not golf outings, not drs appts, not hotel rooms, but a meal! $40 is not going to make or break my family but I dont want to spend my vacation money on a convience fee.

I have we are going to start seeing tons of threads about people being charged when their kid is sick. I think we are going to see more cranky and sick kids in restaurants, all bc people are not going to want to pay a fee.

That is not how I like to vacation and it is not what I want to spend my hard earn money for on vacation! One of the things my family likes most about WDW is that we can plan but we also can change things up if we like. We always get park hoppers so that we can have our plans but still go with the flow. But once again you can do that and still be courteous and cancel. I think the fee should be for no shows, not if you call to cancel.

I hope it does curb double bookings but like I said my concern is now the lack of flexiblity this can create in touring plans and what WDW is going to waive the fee for. You could get one CM who is understanding and another who is going to uber strict and not let you cancel w/o the fee.


Disneyland in CA is looking better and better!
 
And blaming Disney for the weather and "sickness " mostly caused by reheating food from a dogie bag :rotfl2:
Let's reheat the left over fish, meat, pasta with the hair blower.:laughing:

Haha, that reminds me of the hotel commercial where the guy is heating up a waffle with an ironing board! :rotfl:
 
And I have no desire to vacation in Paris in those conditions.

And I guess the recession must not be so bad for some people if they have $40 + to waste on missed dinners. We are talking MEALS here people, not golf outings, not drs appts, not hotel rooms, but a meal! $40 is not going to make or break my family but I dont want to spend my vacation money on a convience fee.

I have we are going to start seeing tons of threads about people being charged when their kid is sick. I think we are going to see more cranky and sick kids in restaurants, all bc people are not going to want to pay a fee.

That is not how I like to vacation and it is not what I want to spend my hard earn money for on vacation! One of the things my family likes most about WDW is that we can plan but we also can change things up if we like. We always get park hoppers so that we can have our plans but still go with the flow. But once again you can do that and still be courteous and cancel. I think the fee should be for no shows, not if you call to cancel.

I hope it does curb double bookings but like I said my concern is now the lack of flexiblity this can create in touring plans and what WDW is going to waive the fee for. You could get one CM who is understanding and another who is going to uber strict and not let you cancel w/o the fee.


Disneyland in CA is looking better and better!

Well as ALL CM read over here I hope they use the uber strict policy.
Getting sick is no excuse for not showing up. I can't cancel my tickets for André Rieu, 160 Dollars.
Neither can I cancel my air flights because I don't like the weather or my kids are sick.
The abuse and so called excuse was costing Disney to much so they will end this. Disney was never meant to be a milk cow for milking the system and being used to solve the problems I have to deal whit in normal life. Most companies would tell me if I had problems whit sick kids It was not their problem and maybe it was better if I stayed childless instead of trying to put my problems on the companies financial back.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom