Yeah, I think we are all speaking the same language. The original plan was 6 park days, no hoppers, but then my DD6 really wants to do a water park. doing 5 park days plus a water park gets pretty spendy since 1 of those days is not discounted (that's how they get you). Could do 4 park days plus the water park and take a resort day. We've never done that. That's the cheapest option but I think my wife really wants 2 MK days. Another wild card is ROTR. If we don't get a boarding group we'd want to leave and do a different park and try again on a different day - thus park hoppers are back in play. Decisions, decisions...
I also need to see if I can pay for the AAA discount tickets using Disney gift cards (anyone know? Probably not). I can definitely use gift cards to buy the tickets from Disney so not much of a discount if I can't (quick check on one option was about 7% discount using AAA vs. 5% with my Target red card).