Bicker and Kaytieeldr - you're right; I wasn't using the correct term on the first call. On the second call though, I did look it up and quoted the website to the agent.
I tried to post an update last night, but the board must have been on maintenance 'cause my post timed out. Here's what happened:
Two more phone calls and I was told that the prices had gone
up even though I checked and double-checked US Air's website (even cleared cookies!) while I was on the phone with the reps.
The third call I asked for a supervisor. I was told that none were available, but I was given a number to call. Which referred me to another number, which referred me to another number and to yet again another number!
I decided to try their live chat. The agent couldn't help me, but gave me the number for the internet help desk.
This time, I started off by telling the agent that I needed to confirm the price on the flights I was looking at on the web page. She confirmed the fares
at the lower price! I then told her I had flights at a higher price and wanted the Guaranteed Air Fare Refund. She told me I wasn't eligible for a refund. It was then that I uttered the magic word...."voucher." Apparently, they are not going to say the "V" word until you say it first.
I can hear her clicking away on the computer and she then informs me that there is only one fare available at the lower price, so I'll only get one magic voucher.
As a side note, at no time did I raise my voice or lose my cool - I just kept plugging away at it.
I felt like that was a lot of run-around for $72. Thank goodness I was on my cell with free long distance. Even if I would have had to call all of those numbers to get to the right person, it wouldn't have been a big deal - every request might have its' own department and I'm ok with that.
What I'm NOT ok with is that I feel like I was flat-out lied to until I had to practice a little deception by not declaring what my real purpose was in making the call.
US Airways has a reputation for bad customer service. I don't think this was just a matter of lacking in customer service or even bad customer service - it was a bad business practice.
I may yet try to call back and talk to a supervisor. Not to yell and scream, not to try to get any compensation, just to relay my disappointing experience.