Once we were finally able to speak with the manager (name withheld to protect the inocent). Within 2 days he had credited back our credit card for $495.23. He listened to us and took care of the situation, unlike the guest services manager (name also withheld to protect the inocent). He told us that accounting had the $495.23 overage all along. However they did not do anything about it until he contacted them.
We find this very odd that accounting had this money for nearly two weeks and did not do anything about it. And the fact that the guest services mangaer told us right off the bat that there was no overage in the drawer.
Thanks to the manager for correcting the situation. Although it should have never gotten to him as the guest services manager should have looked into it when we asked her to.
Moral of the story - always make sure that you get a receipt and that it really is a receipt.

We find this very odd that accounting had this money for nearly two weeks and did not do anything about it. And the fact that the guest services mangaer told us right off the bat that there was no overage in the drawer.
Thanks to the manager for correcting the situation. Although it should have never gotten to him as the guest services manager should have looked into it when we asked her to.
Moral of the story - always make sure that you get a receipt and that it really is a receipt.