U.S. Military: Over 70% of today's recruits don't cut it

Pea-n-Me

DIS Legend
Joined
Jul 18, 2004
Messages
42,861
http://online.wsj.com/articles/recruits-ineligibility-tests-the-military-1403909945

Some snippets...

More than two-thirds of America's youth would fail to qualify for military service because of physical, behavioral or educational shortcomings, posing challenges to building the next generation of soldiers even as the U.S. draws down troops from conflict zones.

The military deems many youngsters ineligible due to obesity, lack of a high-school diploma, felony convictions and prescription-drug use for attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder. But others are now also running afoul of standards for appearance amid the growing popularity of large-scale tattoos and devices called ear gauges that create large holes in earlobes.

"The quality of people willing to serve has been declining rapidly," said Gen. Batschelet.

About a quarter of high-school graduates also can't pass the Armed Forces Qualification Test, which measures math and reading skills, Gen. Youngman said. "They aren't educationally qualified to join the military in any capacity, not just the high-tech jobs," he said.

U.S. Army First Sgt. James Sawyer, who heads recruiting across a swath of Los Angeles County, said tattoos have become the most common cosmetic reason that applicants are disqualified. The Army already banned tattoos on the face, neck and fingers, but according to regulations in effect May 1, soldiers also can't have more than a total of four visible tattoos below the elbows and knees, and tattoos must be relatively small. The goal of the tattoo rules is to maintain a professional-looking Army, Sgt. Sawyer said. He added that "the average person in California has a tattoo."
 
So, if you have someone who would make a perfect soldier, but has too many tattoos, he or she is out??? If they swap to a draft system sometime in the future, would that get you out of the draft?
 
I think the military probably needs to change some of its admittance criteria.

I mean, why on earth, can you not be a soldier if you've taken, or continue to take, medication for ADHD.

My son has taken it because he has ADHD, yet he's in college for engineering, he's very smart, never been in any trouble, and is very responsible. His current employer loves him. So, I don't get it.
 
I think the military probably needs to change some of its admittance criteria.

I mean, why on earth, can you not be a soldier if you've taken, or continue to take, medication for ADHD.

My son has taken it because he has ADHD, yet he's in college for engineering, he's very smart, never been in any trouble, and is very responsible. His current employer loves him. So, I don't get it.

What happens if your son is in A Situation where the meds aren't available?

They will allow a potential recruit to prove they haven't needed the meds in years or were misdiagnosed.
 
So, if you have someone who would make a perfect soldier, but has too many tattoos, he or she is out??? If they swap to a draft system sometime in the future, would that get you out of the draft?
Probably not. Right now the military is drawing down. They can afford to be more selective. Appearance in uniform is a factor they can be picky about for now. I would assume our country would be in dire straits before we ever reinstated the draft. Tats wouldn't be a limiting factor in that case.
 
What happens if your son is in A Situation where the meds aren't available?

They will allow a potential recruit to prove they haven't needed the meds in years or were misdiagnosed.


Well, he's not going to freak out or anything. It is good to hear that they will allow a recruit to prove they have been able to function without the meds.

The funny thing is (and my husband was active duty for 10 years and I worked as an admin assistant for two commanders), there's quite a few military members who were never treated for ADHD, who didn't do well in school, and couldn't quite cut it with college, who ended up in the military with their full-blown, untreated/uncontrolled ADHD. But I guess that's okay as long as the stay out of trouble.

My point is, I think the military needs to sort of revamp their thoughts on some types of issues. There certainly was a time when ADHD was considered a "mental" disorder and there was a stigma attached to it. That diagnosis has evolved into just a different type of brain processing. In fact, IMO, an untreated ADHD person could very well be an excellent soldier based on the way their brain functions--it's sitting in classroom situations, not moving, that's problematic. Most ADHD folks do very well in physical/active situations.
 
I think the military probably needs to change some of its admittance criteria. I mean, why on earth, can you not be a soldier if you've taken, or continue to take, medication for ADHD. My son has taken it because he has ADHD, yet he's in college for engineering, he's very smart, never been in any trouble, and is very responsible. His current employer loves him. So, I don't get it.
Because the military is not your average employer. They set their criteria to get the people they need. Your son sounds like an amazing young man. It doesn't mean he's qualified to serve in the military.
 
Because the military is not your average employer. They set their criteria to get the people they need. Your son sounds like an amazing young man. It doesn't mean he's qualified to serve in the military.

I'm not taking it personally and I know he's a fine individual. Having been involved with the military heavily, I just think it's funny/odd based on the recruits they DO take what they DON'T accept.

I do agree they can be more choosy and they should. I'm just not sure they should be ruling out tattoos and ADHD medication use. (My son has no tattoos by the way:goodvibes).
 
So, if you have someone who would make a perfect soldier, but has too many tattoos, he or she is out??? If they swap to a draft system sometime in the future, would that get you out of the draft?

The military is downsizing right now. They can afford to be picky. Were we in a desperate situation then I suspect the standards would change. Lol so I doubt a well placed tattoo could keep you out. My opinion anyway:)
 
The military is downsizing right now. They can afford to be picky. Were we in a desperate situation then I suspect the standards would change. Lol so I doubt a well placed tattoo could keep you out. My opinion anyway:)

I can see it now: there's a draft so everyone runs down to the local tattoo shop to get all-over body tats. Hmm...I'm thinking they won't care at that point.
 
I'm not taking it personally and I know he's a fine individual. Having been involved with the military heavily, I just think it's funny/odd based on the recruits they DO take what they DON'T accept.

I do agree they can be more choosy and they should. I'm just not sure they should be ruling out tattoos and ADHD medication use. (My son has no tattoos by the way:goodvibes).

I do not want my son serving and counting on someone who is dependent on a medication to be able to think and behave rationally without a medication. Just like I don't want to count on him being carried out of a situation by someone unable to lift and carry or breathe.
 
I think the military probably needs to change some of its admittance criteria.

I mean, why on earth, can you not be a soldier if you've taken, or continue to take, medication for ADHD.

My son has taken it because he has ADHD, yet he's in college for engineering, he's very smart, never been in any trouble, and is very responsible. His current employer loves him. So, I don't get it.

So does this mean that a child who took ADHD meds for even a short time when elementary age and would not have taken it for years by recruitment age would be disqualified? I get some of the rationale here, but I am wondering if this is an ever taken at all or haven't taken it for x-years rule.


ETA: it is medication within a year, but recruit must disclose about prior 3 years: http://www.additudemag.com/adhd/article/801.html (included links to military policy
Recruit can also be disqualified of they display some significant symptoms.
 
I do not want my son serving and counting on someone who is dependent on a medication to be able to think and behave rationally without a medication. Just like I don't want to count on him being carried out of a situation by someone unable to lift and carry or breathe.

For the latter, in combat, he may find himself in that same situation.

ETA: only recruits with asthma after age 13 are disqualified. Those who had it prior are not. http://usmilitary.about.com/od/joiningthemilitary/a/asthma.htm

I'm not sure I completely agree with you on the ADHD medication. But as they said, other conditions are disqualified as well.
 
So does this mean that a child who took ADHD meds for even a short time when elementary age and would not have taken it for years by recruitment age would be disqualified? I get some of the rationale here, but I am wondering if this is an ever taken at all or haven't taken it for x-years rule.


ETA: it is medication within a year, but recruit must disclose about prior 3 years: http://www.additudemag.com/adhd/article/801.html (included links to military policy
Recruit can also be disqualified of they display some significant symptoms.

The criteria is minimum of 1 year med free- has to be proven by a MD- that is what it was.
 
For the latter, in combat, he may find himself in that same situation.

I'm not sure I completely agree with you on the ADHD medication.

I want people who can think clearly unmedicated. A person with ADHD has an imbalance that does not allow that without medication. As a professional who deals with adults and children with emotional and behavioral disorders I am glad the military understands the issues involved.

Correct about the asthma rule. My son fretted for years he had it because he was out of breath when he ran.
 
Ftr, an adult with treated ADHD can absolutely be a great employee. But an adult or child who needs those meds to be happy and healthy really does need them.
 
I want people who can think clearly unmedicated. A person with ADHD has an imbalance that does not allow that without medication. As a professional who deals with adults and children with emotional and behavioral disorders I am glad the military understands the issues involved.

Correct about the asthma rule. My son fretted for years he had it because he was out of breath when he ran.

I think the military has some work to do on this. Do you know how many people are admitted to the military with undiagnosed ADHD? Of course not, but I would bet that the number is fairly high. I haven't been in the active duty side of the military in a many years; however, when I was, at least in the enlisted corps, there was many, many soldiers who obviously had ADHD, were in the military because that was all that was left for them to do as they could not pass muster for sitting another 4 years in a college classroom. I will tell you that my husband was one of them.

I realize this is all anectdotal, but I work with a man who is 62 years old. He was *finally* diagnosed with ADHD when he was in his 40s (when his son was being diagnosed). He had so many issues as a child with school and frustrations. He joined the Army at 18 and served admirably in Viet Nam. One of the defining times in his life, he says, was when he was a soldier, out of the classroom and "doing" where his severe ADHD did not rule his life. This man is one of the most severe cases I've ever witnessed when he takes a medication "holiday."

So, while I agree that the military can and should be choosy, I also don't believe, because of my firsthand accounts with adults with ADHD, that the situation is so dire that they not be allowed in the military because of it. Again, just my personal opinion and I realize that others have witnessed behavior to the contrary of my experience. But I can say with confidence, that the military is already full of ADHD soldiers who just happened to never use meds growing up.
 
I want people who can think clearly unmedicated. A person with ADHD has an imbalance that does not allow that without medication. As a professional who deals with adults and children with emotional and behavioral disorders I am glad the military understands the issues involved.

Correct about the asthma rule. My son fretted for years he had it because he was out of breath when he ran.

ADHD people can and do have great success by finding a career that is suited to them.
For many it is the military.

Funny though, some choose not to medicate for whatever reason.

It is impressive that you likely deal with people in regular interactions functioning just fine and you wouldn't know they had a "behavioral disorder".
 
Lol people have been "self medicating" with career choices for ever.

In the end you are saying that people being medicated for ADHD really don't need the meds. I'm not willing to go there. I know tok many whose lives have been changed because of them. Someone may be able to get by and find something that makes life tolerable. But I'd rather those people thrive.

In the end id rather my sons life not be in the hands of someone who should be medicated but isn't.
 
ADHD people can and do have great success by finding a career that is suited to them.
For many it is the military.

Funny though, some choose not to medicate for whatever reason.

It is impressive that you likely deal with people in regular interactions functioning just fine and you wouldn't know they had a "behavioral disorder".

Lol not sure why you are offended by the term. That is usually the issue that gets them sent my way.

No one is arguing your second point btw. Unless you are involved on a personal level with someone with an issue that needs or is better served with meds you wouldn't realize it. Pretty obvious. When you actually live or work with someone on a daily basis is when you know them. Again obvious.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom