We went to Tutto Italia on the recommendation of a friend who really knows Italian food (from Italy, owns an Italian food import shop). We rarely go out for Italian food when we're out of town because we live in an area with really good Italian restaurants. I'm so glad that we went to Tutto because it was just amazing!
DD13 had the foresight to order the best meal: Bucatini Gratinati which is pasta in a light cream sauce with prosciutto and peas. It was so delicate and not heavy at all. I ordered the salmon which was well prepared and DH ordered the oricchette which doesn't seem to be on the menu anymore. I believe he also ordered a main course, but I don't see that either as the menu changes seasonally (we were there in February). Our appetizer was also delicious for something pretty basic, we ordered the mozzarella and tomatoes with basil and olive oil. The desserts were great and very rich, we ordered the Bugie and the tiramisu.
Hope you decide to go to Tutto Italia--Enjoy!