Tutto Italia or Mama Melrose

[Nubbsy]

We want to do 1 Italian meal since the kids love it and trying to decide between these. Thanks

 

[MickeyNicki]

Been to both and Tutto is sooo much better than MM

 

[stitch1094]

Mama's has been on a steady decline for us. Last trip (July 2008) the meal and service were absolutely horrid. I don't think we would go back for a long. long time.

Haven't tried Tutto. Take a look at the menus. VERY PRICEY! $12 for a cannoli? Are you kidding me?

 

[SGMCO]

Tutto is Excellent!!
Specially on the DP, it's only 1TS credit.
It would be expensive OOP but still very good food.

 

[NeverlandClub23]

If you're on the DDP or don't care about cost, Tutto Italia. The best (and most expensive) meal during our last trip (and we eat at all TS places on every trip and it was right up there in cost with Cali Grill, I think I ended up spending $150-175 for just the two of us including tip [our server was excellent!]).

BUT Mama Melrose's is really good (menu isn't huge but we found a lot we liked). The atmosphere is cozy and fun and we had the best server, Holly, that we've had at any WDW restaurant (edited to add: this was in 2005 so things may have changed since then).

 

[aubriee]

We like both, but MUCH prefer Tutto Italia. There's no comparison in the quality. I like the steak or spaghetti fra Diavolo at Mama Melrose, but love the fish and clams at Tutto Italia. We also prefer the appetizers and desserts more at Tutto Italia.

 

[ROEDISNEY]

Been to both like them both but IMO Tutto is much better.

 

[northwenald]

I have not been to Mama Melrose in a few years but Tutto Italia is great !!! I went twice last year and both meals were excellant.