Tony's or Liberty Tree Tavern?

[ktlm]

I can't make up my mind and could really use some help/opinions. Which would you pick for dinner and why? The menus at both restaurants look good. I'm a big fan of both the turkey meal and chicken parmigian. I initially really wanted LTT and booked Tony's because it was not available. After I talked myself into the fact that I was going to really like Tony's, LTT opened up. Now I can't decide what to do!

 

[Frothy]

Always enjoyed LTT so I would switch

 

[HsvTeacher]

My DH and I went to both Tony's and LTT a few weeks ago. Tony's left a lot to be desired. (I had the chicken parm and DH had the seafood diavolo.) LTT, on the other hand, was absolutely WONDERFUL! I don't usually like turkey and dressing, but theirs was out of this world good! I would recommend going there!

 

[rcraw45425]

LTT all the way. Tony's usually sucks

 

[HotMama]

Liberty Tree!! Yum. Yum. Thinking about it makes me crave the apple dessert at the end of the meal with ice cream.

We also went to Tony's once. It was cute inside, but the food was just OK.

Plus at Liberty Tree the characters look so CUTE in their costumes!

 

[rcraw45425]

Liberty Tree!! Yum. Yum. Thinking about it makes me crave the apple dessert at the end of the meal with ice cream.

We also went to Tony's once. It was cute inside, but the food was just OK.

Plus at Liberty Tree the characters look so CUTE in their costumes!

Characters are gone from LTT except during the CP refurbishment the first part of next year.

 

[danielle782001]

Even without the characters we would still go with LTT over Tonys...We love the lunch menu...We also enjoy the family-style dinner...The atmosphere is great and so is the service!

 

[HsvTeacher]

Even without the characters we would still go with LTT over Tonys...We love the lunch menu...We also enjoy the family-style dinner...The atmosphere is great and so is the service!

Oh my! Lunch is the best of both worlds....Tavern Fried Cheese, Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake, and Turkey and Dressing! Mmmmmm!

 

[minnie1012]

I have never eaten at Tony's but in September LTT was the favorite dinner of everyone in my party (6 of us).

 

[NuttyDisneyMom]

LTT all the way. Tony's usually sucks

 

[GovieMom]

I'm so happy to be reading all the endorsements for LTT. We've eaten at Tony's before (so-so) and at LTT for lunch only (superb!). We all loooove Crystal Palace, but since it will be closed during our trip, I thought we'd try LTT for dinner. Glad to be hearing good things so far!

 

[familyS]

LTT

It is great having a relaxing, family style meal.

 

[mward73]

I'm glad I read this post! I had made our reservation for Tony's b/c DS loves Lady & the Tramp. I just switched us to LTT for lunch instead (I'd rather have good food. lol)

 

[ROEDISNEY]

Like them both but if I had to pick one then no ? Tony's hands down.

 

[ktlm]

Wow- all but one for LTT. I'm still going back and forth as the Tony's time is the exact time we were looking for, which is 50 minutes earlier than LTT. LTT is at 6:10 and Spectro is at 7:00, which I'm guessing puts Spectro back in the Liberty Square area around 7:15? I think I saw on another post that if Spectro is going by while you are at LTT, they let you run outside and watch and then come back in and finish your meal? Is that true? We'd like to see Spectro, but if we don't get that good of a viewing spot, it's not that big a deal as we saw it last December (DD's 1st trip) and this past May(thanks to the 4/3 deal and bounce back we've been lucky enough to get to go to WDW for summer and winter vacations!) I've never eaten at LTT and I haven't eaten at Tony's since I was a kid (a long long time ago). I'm thinking maybe pick LTT and show up 30 minutes early and hope we either get seated early or at least on time?

 

[HotMama]

Wow- all but one for LTT. I'm still going back and forth as the Tony's time is the exact time we were looking for, which is 50 minutes earlier than LTT. LTT is at 6:10 and Spectro is at 7:00, which I'm guessing puts Spectro back in the Liberty Square area around 7:15? I think I saw on another post that if Spectro is going by while you are at LTT, they let you run outside and watch and then come back in and finish your meal? Is that true? We'd like to see Spectro, but if we don't get that good of a viewing spot, it's not that big a deal as we saw it last December (DD's 1st trip) and this past May(thanks to the 4/3 deal and bounce back we've been lucky enough to get to go to WDW for summer and winter vacations!) I've never eaten at LTT and I haven't eaten at Tony's since I was a kid (a long long time ago). I'm thinking maybe pick LTT and show up 30 minutes early and hope we either get seated early or at least on time?

Once our meal lasted longer than expected and we were eating when Spectro started. So we slipped out the back door of LTT and watched the parade. So it worked out good for us because I love love love Spectro!

 

[gerows]

If you are makindg ADR's I would go with LTT. You can always get into Tony's for lunch without reservations. We were there in August for one of the most crowded weeks in MK that I have seen and we went to Tony's twice without any reservations and waited 5 min once and 20 min the 2nd time. Numerous other trips have been the same too. I think it's because of the location. People that are in the park aren't going to walk to the entrance in the middle of the day just for lunch, and the foot traffic is either to excited that they are in MK that they aren't going to stop to eat just yet, or they are heading home. The building it a nice place to get out of the sun and relax for a bit too. Hit the movie theater way in the back of the camera museum.

 

[lisam427]

i have never eaten at tony's but we ate at ltt this past sept. it was sooooo good. i would say to go to ltt defenetely.

 

[tinkgurl]

We love Tony's.