Tony's or Capt'n Jacks?

[jcemom]

Ah, so either way it's MK to DtD and back to MK? Hmm... I'd probably choose another restaurant in or near MK. Liberty Tree, Kona... anything else appeal to you?

 

[MBELSANTI]

Ah, so either way it's MK to DtD and back to MK? Hmm... I'd probably choose another restaurant in or near MK. Liberty Tree, Kona... anything else appeal to you?

I am actually thinking of maybe make ressie for the day of Pirate & Princess party. Instead of doing parks all day, just relax during day, early dinner at DTD and then off to PPP. I am sure I will change my mind again between now and then. .

 

[Camping Cat]

Well I have not ate at Cap'n Jacks but we ate dinner at Tony's in December before the Christmas party and we really enjoyed it. They were super busy but our waitress was very attentive and even let me try two different soups even though only one appetizer per person is allowed on the dining plan. We both had the NY strip and it was very good. I would go back without any qualms.

I agree with you. We had the same experience....ate there before MVMCP and all 4 of the adults in our party really enjoyed our dinner. After reading this thread, it almost seems like there must be two Tony's at WDW.

 

[vellamint]

Seeing that I am first generation Italian- American, maybe I should stay away from TOny's LOL

STAY AWAY ... very far away. I am full Italian and was very disappointed/unimpressed with this meal. and I felt they rushed us in and out.

 

[suzimar57]

we've eaten at both tonys and capn jacks

tonys: bad!!!! stay away!!!! (think: chef boy ar dee)

capn jacks: good - love the twin lobster tails!!