We've owned the 2-in-1 T-fal Actifry for a few years now (I traded in credit card points to get gift cards, and then we waited for Boxing Day sales to buy it). We use it a few times a week at least, we love it. I think the little extra money is worth it to get the 2-in-1 as well, since it has a flat plate that rotates, but doesn't have the paddle smashing things around. You can actually cook two different things at the same time, and whatever you cook on the top plate requires zero oil. We've cooked steaks/chicken breasts/pork chops, etc on the top while cooking fries/etc in the bottom. We've also used ours for cooking chicken wings, perogies, home fries, etc, etc, etc - basically we love it. On the weekends when we have time to cook breakfast we cook those frozen hashbrown patties (like you get at McDonald's) on the top plate (seasoned with some seasoning salt and paprika). We use zero oil, and I prefer them to the greasy ones you get from fast food places. If ours broke, there would be zero hesitation in replacing it.