I am confusing myself...so I thought I'd ask those who have stayed here.
We are a family of 7, 2 adults and 5 children ages 7-17
As of today I am booked to stay during
free dining in 2 rooms at the Caribbean Beach Resort. We figured with free dining is a non brainer...
Well the more I see Bonnet Creek the more the 2 bdrm deluxe room interests me, and a great price as well.
My issue is this... my husband does not want to rent a car, he has no interest in driving and parking while on vacation in Disney. We never have, we have always stayed on property. So, I am concerned about transportation. And, after its all said in done.. and pay for meals and tickets and transportation... am I really saving anything?
Thoughts from those who have done this!!! WWYD?
In your situation, it may not be such an easy decision.
In general, You will be able to save a LOT of money on the room costs alone with Bonnet Creek. Most prices people report around here can be in the $100-$120/night range for a 2bdrm [with some prices cheaper, some a little more... depending on time of year, how long you stay, and who you rent from]. I'm willing to bet that's less than you are paying for just a single room at the CBR. You may want to look at a larger room at WBC though since the 2bdrm has the 1 king bed in the master bedroom, 2 full/queen beds in the 2nd bedroom, and a queen pull out in the living room. The 3bdrm will add another bedroom with a king bed and might make it more comfortable and relaxing since the kids won't be on top of each other as much....and it also might make it easier to separate the kids based off sex or age if you wanted (either getting ready in the morning, or maybe allowing younger kids to go to bed earlier than the older ones).
Where things are going to get a little more complicated is you desire to not rent a car and the question about food.
At CBR, Your airport transportation, park transportation, and food [thru the
ddp] are all included. At Bonnet Creek, These are going to get split out to seperate line items. Generally we would say just rent a car since the price of a rental will still likely bring you cheaper than what you are paying for onsite at CBR, and that would take care of the airport transportation and park transportation and give you some added freedom. since you don't want to drive however, there are other things that need to be considered.
Airport transportation: Taxi or Towncar. You will want to price out your options here. Some Towncar services will include a grocery stop on the way which can help you with the food concern. The advantage over ME: It's straight from the airport to the resort without stops at other resorts. disadvantage: extra cost and potential complication if you are used to ME.
Park Transportation: The Bonnet Creek shuttle is currently charging $6 per per per day for use. For your family of 7 alone, that would be $42/day. [for comparison, if you drove, parking at the parks is $15/day]. It also runs a set schedule that sometimes doesn't run as much mid-day. There are examples of past schedules posted here and in other threads.... but it's something to consider as the bonnet creek shuttle won't be as convenient as Disney Transportation if you are the type who likes to come and go from the resort during the day.
Food: I'm someone who honestly has a hard time justifying the cost of the DDP since I don't normally eat that much food. With multiple kids however who can eat a LOT, the DDP could make more sense for you. The DDP could also be useful for you if you are the type who will let your kids roam the parks on their own at all, since you will know they can use their hotel room key to get food. Generally however, I'd say look at what the menu's at the restaurants you think you will end up eating at contain. You can find them, with prices, on the DIS. Get an idea on what you might realistically eat. Not everyone is going to eat 3 "entree's with drink and dessert" every day, and you may even find that sometimes you might end up splitting something. Either way, look at the food options, and figure out what you are likely to end up spending "out of pocket" for that food. Then you can see if it makes financial sense to stay off site and pay for your food, on onsite with free dining.
With offsite, There are a couple tips you can use. Examples include ideas such as: Making a grocery stop and getting some breakfast foods... cereal, waffles, bacon, eggs, juice, etc. Then you can eat breakfast in the unit while everyone is getting ready before headed to the parks. It also would give the family something to do while doing the morning bathroom dance. (Some eat breakfast while others shower/get ready.... then the bathroom people eat while those who ate get ready).
For park food, if you like the idea of having your meals pre-paid, You can put the money on Disney Gift Cards (like what you would spend on the DDP normally). You then don't have to worry about havng the money for food since you've already put it aside in your disney giftcards. Bonus: anything you didn't spend on food at the end of your trip you can use on souvenirs... or purchases at your local
Disney Store.
Obviously, The park ticket cost is going to be the same onsite or off. (although you can find discounted tickets at places like Undercover Tourist if you aren't required to get them as part of a package)
Another thing to consider too with a family that large.... No daily housekeeping at Bonnet Creek. While the more space may help keep things less cluttered with bags/clothes..... If your kids are the type who will make a mess, You won't have someone coming thru every day to clean up that mess. For some people, the daily housekeeping can be something easily missed when it's not there. (But bonus: washer/dryer in the room, so you could get away with packing less clothes overall.... or even just washing bathing suits easily between uses).
So is it a good fit for you? I can't tell you. You know your family, budget, and vacation needs better than I do. If you didn't mind driving, I think you could easily save some $$$.... but the ability to not worry about driving and transportation, or even the ability to have someone else clean up after the family during your trip.... could be things you consider priceless and worth the premium you are paying to stay onsite.
I hope this has helped.... and if you have any other questions about the resort I'm sure we'd be happy to answer them for you if it helps you decide if this is something for you.