The state of Education... YIKES! I had no idea.

golfgal said:
Actually, I would be worried about your district with only 67% pursuing a college education, THAT is a much more telling statistic then the graduation rate. Every district calculates their graduation rates differently, many take however many kids start the school year as seniors and how many finish the year and that is their "graduation" rate, never mind the 50% that dropped out after their sophomore year. Some districts will take how many sophomores start/finish. Graduation rates almost NEVER include who starts in 1st grade and goes all the way through 12th grade, which would actually tell people something about the district.

Looking at the % of kids going to college is a much better indicator of the quality of education your district is offering, like our district where 94% of the students go on to a 4 year college, 3% going to 2 year colleges and 1% into the military so basically the entire graduating class is going on to some kind of further education which is great.

I never said further education. I said a college or university. If you're in a district where 99% of all high school graduates head to college, then your district had better start teacher other districts how to achieve similar results. From the research I did, 67% going on to attend a college/university is pretty darn high. Other forms of education were not in our figures at all.

We have a higher % of students going onto college than many districts have of just getting them to received a diploma.
 
Papa Deuce said:
I live in the Philly burbs. I live in a good school district. I have known for a real long time that Philadelphia's PUBLIC School system is not highly regarded, to say the least. But reading a local newspaper today, I found out the following:

1. 40% of Philadelphia public school kids do not graduate.


I guess I am ignorant to what is going on in education these day. In the district I live in --- and I have no official numbers --- I would bet graduation rate is 90+ percent.

Is it really that bad everywhere?

We have a 90-95% (just googled) up in Northern PA, the Poconos region!

I even think 90% graduation rate is NOT GOOD! :confused3
 
I have a serious problem with the state judging my teaching by asking questions that are not part of my curriculum.

That I can understand. If the state defines the curriculum, then they should be testing based on the curriculum. I don't have a problem with them asking a couple of questions that are outside to get an idea what the kids might be picking up elsewhere, but they shouldn't be basing any major portion of a test on stuff that isn't required by the curriculum.
 
N.Bailey said:
I never said further education. I said a college or university. If you're in a district where 99% of all high school graduates head to college, then your district had better start teacher other districts how to achieve similar results. From the research I did, 67% going on to attend a college/university is pretty darn high. Other forms of education were not in our figures at all.

We have a higher % of students going onto college than many districts have of just getting them to received a diploma.


Around here having a high 90's percent going to a 4 year college is pretty common. Minnesota has long lead the nation in this area. I think that is probably why when people on these boards complain about how things are run in their districts I don't see them happening here. Overall education in MN is highly valued and thus parents tend to make sure their kids are doing well. The teacher conference post that is going around is a good example, a lot of schools don't WANT parents coming to conference, sad, other schools are seeing a 20% attendance rate or worse. Our schools get upset if they have less then 90% attendance rates at conferences, etc. Again, if a school around here only had 67% of their students going on to a 4 year college, they wouldn't have students left because parents would open enroll them in a better district.
 
golfgal said:
Around here having a high 90's percent going to a 4 year college is pretty common. Minnesota has long lead the nation in this area. I think that is probably why when people on these boards complain about how things are run in their districts I don't see them happening here. Overall education in MN is highly valued and thus parents tend to make sure their kids are doing well. The teacher conference post that is going around is a good example, a lot of schools don't WANT parents coming to conference, sad, other schools are seeing a 20% attendance rate or worse. Our schools get upset if they have less then 90% attendance rates at conferences, etc. Again, if a school around here only had 67% of their students going on to a 4 year college, they wouldn't have students left because parents would open enroll them in a better district.

I would love to see a link to your school district? Someone already stated, and I'm being lazy taking a stab at it (not wanting to look back), that only 23 to 25% of the country even carries a BA or higher.
 
Plus the graduation rates from four year colleges within five years is 51%. I think the bachelors degrees held in the US is around 27%.
 
Lisa loves Pooh said:
In Florida--compulsory age is age 6 until age 16.

If a student isn't legally obligated to stay in school much beyond 10th or 11th grade...it just keeps the option of dropping out open.
As a teacher, I can assure you that the age limit doesn't really matter. Kids who are going to drop out just quit coming whether they're 14, 15, or whatever. They miss 50, 60, 70 days per year during their freshman and sophomore years, then they quit coming altogether once they're "officially able to drop out". The school system is REQUIRED to contact their parents, but that usually doesn't make a whole lot of difference -- 90% of the time, if they had the kind of parents who were going to do something about it, they'd have already done it.

And if they're forced to come to school -- even if they're court-ordered -- it doesn't mean that they're listening, taking notes, and actually learning something. These kids just aren't motivated to work in school, and they cause trouble. These are the kids who cut up in class, skip, etc. Some of them are there for free lunch, others are there to sell drugs, and others are just hanging around 'til they're old enough to get free drivers' ed classes. The teacher is forced to take time away from the kids who WANT to learn to provide these kids with make-up work, discipline them, and do paperwork about their non-performance. These kids have already "left school" long before they actually leave school. While I'd love to believe that it's possible to help every child reach his full potential, the truth is that some kids (and parents) just aren't going to do their part. If they're not going to make it, it's better for the others to have them clear out so that the teachers can focus on those who WANT to graduate.

Don't get me wrong: I'm not saying teachers shouldn't TRY to reach every kid -- I'm just saying that for some kids, but in the real world it just isn't going to happen. For example, today's the last day of the 9-weeks. I have one kid who's missed more than half my classes (no illness, no extinuating circumstances, just laziness). Every time he comes to school he is extremely belligerant, telling me that it's teachers like me -- you know, the kind who expect kids to actually read, write, learn, the kind who doesn't just excuse everything he does, but actually expects him to do something academic -- who make kids want to drop out. At this point, his opportunity to pass my class is gone; he's made too many low grades, he's missed too many days. It'd be better for the class if he were to leave and (if he decides to do better) come back to start fresh next semester.
Lisa loves Pooh said:
However, I think if the student opts for a GED, then they wouldn't be counted as a "drop out" for that as my friend said it was aimed more for those that were "delinquent" type of drop outs.
A kid who leaves public school and goes to the community college to earn a GED -- the good enough diploma -- IS counted as a drop-out. Also, if a kid drops out in the fall semester, then returns in spring semester but drops out again, he is counted TWICE as a drop-out. Many kids drop out multiple times during their high school careers -- those kids tend to end up not graduating.
 
delilah said:
Generally, in our public school district, between 95-100% graduate, and about 80% or more head off to college. I think our district is skewed toward higher income and education level of parents.
The school system in which I teach has similar numbers; however, I know we're above average.

The 80% going to college is a bit misleading. That's 80% who START college -- around here, about half who start will graduate from college. For some it'll be a financial issue, but for most it's because "we" have decided that everyone "should" go to college, and lots of kids who really aren't college material end up there because "everyone" told them that was the right path.
 
castleview said:
In the paper the other day, there was an article about the inner city closest to me. The public school system is offering free tutoring to all students. There are over 20,000 students in this school system and only 23 parents showed up to learn about the program. :confused3
I've been teaching for 15 years, and I can say this with certaintly: Very, very few kids are incapable of passing high school classes. Not every kid can pass honors level classes, and not every kid can make As in every class, but every kid can squeak by in general level classes. And for kids who genuinely can't keep up with the majority (those with learning disabilities or English-language learners), there's a tremendous amount of federally-required help.

The vast majority of kids who don't make it in high school fail because of choices they make. Obviously, they make different bad choices, but these are some of the typical problem areas: they don't attend school regularly, they don't do their reading, they don't listen and take notes in class, they don't study . . . then all of a sudden they find them selves so far behind that they genuinely CAN'T catch up.
 
Fitswimmer said:
OK, I still don't get this. If the test is measuring what the average student at that grade level should know in basic subjects like math and reading-isn't that what the teachers are doing anyway?

We took something called Iowa tests when I was in school back in the Dark ages. It was always the easy week in school. The stuff on the test was much easier than our regular classwork.

I'll try to address this another way. I teach 3rd grade. Pretty standard curriculum, nothing too meaty (like westward expansion... ugh!). Of course I cover the curriculum mandated by the state along with the "teachable moments" that occur in my classroom.

While standardized testing (ISTEP in Indiana) assesses what the students have learned in my class... and while I'm confident MOST of my students understand and can apply the skills... I must spend weeks "teaching to the test" to prepare them for the different FORMATS they will see on a test.

Let me try to give an example:

The skill is "Perimeter". My students all know that to find perimeter, you measure each side of the polygon, then add the sides together. If they were going to fence in their yards someday (a REAL LIFE application, mind you)... I know they would remember how to measure each side of the their yard then add that together to know how much fencing they would need.

HOWEVER...

On the ISTEP test, they might see these kinds of questions:

Look at the polygon below. Then look at the number sentence next to it. Is the number sentence finding the:

A. area
B. circumference
C. perimeter
D. diameter


OR

The perimeter of this triangle is 12. If all of the sides are equal, what is the length of each side?

Now... these are legitimate test questions that test the knowledge of perimeter. But if you just throw these in front of an 8 or 9 year old... they are going to stress out. They know they know perimeter... but to be asked about it in those different FORMATS needs practice!


SOOOOO..... (whew... didn't mean for this to be so long!)... in my opinion, THAT's what "Teaching to the test" means. It means spending time teaching test-formatted questions, instead of delving into more interesting concepts and having time for more "teachable" (student-driven) moments.

AND ONE MORE THING

I completely agree with the breakdown of families and work ethic as a MAJOR reason why schools are failing. Although I have 6 weeks to prepare my kids for ISTEP testing... a LOT of my day is WASTED disciplining students and dealing with behavior issues that get WORSE EVERY YEAR. I just wish parents would teach their kids to respect adults and quit calling teachers and complaining every time their child gets in trouble. oooopsss.. did I just say that out loud. sorry!! :rolleyes:

Thanks for listening. Hope this doesn't bring on too many flames.... :furious:

and seriously.. I DO love teaching. It's just so hard sometimes!
 
disney junky said:
Plus the graduation rates from four year colleges within five years is 51%. I think the bachelors degrees held in the US is around 27%.


I just checked with the US Census Bureau and our county in MN has 35% that hold a BA or higher, 94% that have a high school diploma or higher in the 25 and over population. The US average is 24%. Statistics are just that, a bunch of numbers. I would venture a guess that if you took out the population of people over 50 years old that the BA degree holder % would be much higher.

Looking at our circle of friends, everyone has at least a BA degree so statistics are really not all that useful in situations unless you are able to dissect them more then just general information.
 
golfgal said:
I just checked with the US Census Bureau and our county in MN has 35% that hold a BA or higher, 94% that have a high school diploma or higher in the 25 and over population. The US average is 24%. Statistics are just that, a bunch of numbers. I would venture a guess that if you took out the population of people over 50 years old that the BA degree holder % would be much higher.

Looking at our circle of friends, everyone has at least a BA degree so statistics are really not all that useful in situations unless you are able to dissect them more then just general information.

I don't know exactly where you live, but I ran our district against several (I checked about 10 different ones) in Minnesota and across the board, Minnesota has come out higher in the area "Some college, 1 or more years, no degree" than our area. A few districts in Minnesota came out higher for those who hold BAs, but the ones I checked where never by a landslide and more showed our district held more BAs than those I checked. I then checked "Master’s degree" "Professional school degree" and "Doctorate degree" and of those that I checked in Minnesota (again, I don't know your exact district) not a single district that I checked beat ours.

I guess I just felt insulted by your comments and feel a need to defend our school.

http://nces.ed.gov/surveys/sdds/main1.asp
 
SOOOOO..... (whew... didn't mean for this to be so long!)... in my opinion, THAT's what "Teaching to the test" means. It means spending time teaching test-formatted questions, instead of delving into more interesting concepts and having time for more "teachable" (student-driven) moments.

Thanks!! That's the best explanation I've heard about why the tests cause problems for teachers. That question you used as an illustration stressed me out! I can't imagine a 3rd grader.

Last year I met up with a teacher I had in HS. He was our choral director and music teacher then, last year he was in his final year as Principal before retirement. He said that the essential difference btw the years I was in school and today was the parents. If the teacher called home back then, the first question was "What did he/she do?" and the response after the description of the offense was "Oh, he/she is in serious trouble. It will NOT happen again and there will be an apology tomorrow". Now, the response to the call home is "What did you people do to my kid??" and " My child would never do any such thing, you must be lying about him/her because you don't like him/her" It's what drives good teachers out of the profession and keeps kids from succeeding. If something isn't done to change attitudes we are in serious trouble as a society.
 
I think you've all made some great points about the problems with education. As parents I think we can't just talk the talk about education being important. Our kids really need us to show them that we have a love for learning. Education is a lifelong process...we're never really finished :thumbsup2

BTW, my 2 cents on the testing controversy - as a 2nd grade teacher what I see on standardized tests is not always representative of student learning. Some kids just don't test well.
 
Fitswimmer said:
If the teacher called home back then, the first question was "What did he/she do?" and the response after the description of the offense was "Oh, he/she is in serious trouble. It will NOT happen again and there will be an apology tomorrow". Now, the response to the call home is "What did you people do to my kid??" and " My child would never do any such thing, you must be lying about him/her because you don't like him/her" It's what drives good teachers out of the profession and keeps kids from succeeding. If something isn't done to change attitudes we are in serious trouble as a society.

I 've seen fantastic teachers leave the profession for this reason. Parents and educators need to work together to provide the best possible education for our children. Unfortunately this doesn't always happen.
 
N.Bailey said:
I don't know exactly where you live, but I ran our district against several (I checked about 10 different ones) in Minnesota and across the board, Minnesota has come out higher in the area "Some college, 1 or more years, no degree" than our area. A few districts in Minnesota came out higher for those who hold BAs, but the ones I checked where never by a landslide and more showed our district held more BAs than those I checked. I then checked "Master’s degree" "Professional school degree" and "Doctorate degree" and of those that I checked in Minnesota (again, I don't know your exact district) not a single district that I checked beat ours.

I guess I just felt insulted by your comments and feel a need to defend our school.

http://nces.ed.gov/surveys/sdds/main1.asp

Well, not knowing your district I went to your website, checked out our district with 3 districts in PA and our District was SIGNIFICANTLY higher in the college degree areas like 33% for our district compared to 8-9% for the districts I checked. I picked 2 Lehigh and Wayne Highlands, knowing nothing about the state and just thinking that Lehigh would be near the college there, who knows. It just goes to prove my point that stats mean nothing.
 
golfgal said:
I just checked with the US Census Bureau and our county in MN has 35% that hold a BA or higher, 94% that have a high school diploma or higher in the 25 and over population. The US average is 24%. Statistics are just that, a bunch of numbers. I would venture a guess that if you took out the population of people over 50 years old that the BA degree holder % would be much higher.

Looking at our circle of friends, everyone has at least a BA degree so statistics are really not all that useful in situations unless you are able to dissect them more then just general information.

You cite your county's statistics and then say statistics are just a bunch of numbers, while at the same time touting the statistics as a measure of effectiveness of your educational programs in Minnesota. What is your point?

The fact that your circle of friends have Bachelor's degrees is a measure of....the educational level of your circle of friends.

In the school I teach, our graduation rate runs about 89% and it's measured from ninth to twelfth grade. NCLB has a specific formula so there shouldn't be any fudging of numbers. That's not great but in our area which is rural agricultural and not affluent, it's not unexpected.

Twelve percent of our student population receives special services (learning support). That's the highest in our county. Most schools run about 5-8%.

About 68% of our students go to post secondary school. Again, not a lot, but the number of students who complete those certificate or degree programs is much higher than average.

In the county I live, 46.6 percent of the population has a high school diploma (age 25+), 9.5 percent have bachelor's degrees, and 5.9 percent have masters degrees or higher.

Are we a dumb county with lousy schools? That could be a conclusion reached by some, but in reality, there are virtually no white collar opportunites to increase those levels, our schools do the best we can with the support we get from the parents, and our families are for the most part hard working and successful (success not being a measure of education or income but satisfaction with what they do).

I get a little defensive because these are real people with real jobs and real houses, real successes and real failures. They aren't numbers.
 
I work in Va public schools and have children who attend. The curriculum mandated by the DOE is focused directly on passing the SOL test (Standards of Learning). My oldest's 2nd grade class studied the country Mali as part of the curriculum. I am sure it is a fine country and has a great history that needs to be studied, BUT there were many 2nd graders who had never been past the county line! What point of reference did they have to relate to Mali? What was wrong with learning more about the US? Or the region that they live in?

Another problem is the pacing guides which determine how long it will take for the teacher to move through the curriculum. In 3rd grade my oldest was having a difficult time with learning elapsed time. The teacher told me that the whole class was having difficulty but the pacing guide forced her to move on to other topics within that subject. This means the students whose parents do not help them (the majority) may not have gotten the concept of elapsed time down pat. So when they come to a topic that has to build on knowing elapsed time those kids won't be able to do that either.

To me the teachers are not able to teach a well rounded curriculum. The sole and complete focus of the system is for every school to achieve AYP (annual yearly progress) in order to maintain funding and control over the county system. To do that the kids have to pass the test.

In VA, kids in Sped have the options of testing accomodations or alternative testing. I know that there are schools who give their Sped students the alternative test, whether they could take it with accomodations or not. They give them all the alternative test so the chances of the school getting AYP are greater.
 
I just wish parents would teach their kids to respect adults and quit calling teachers and complaining every time their child gets in trouble.



I just read this again and had POSTERS REMORSE.... ahhh. the morning after!! :badpc:

Anyhoo.... I'm sorry I said "parents"... I should have said "some parents". I HATE it when people post things about "teachers" as a whole and then bash them. Of course there are bad teachers out there, but most of us are good. I know there are LOTS OF GREAT PARENTS out there, but the bad ones are REALLY killing my desire to continue teaching.

Okay.. I feel better now! ;)
 
Sooze said:
Anyhoo.... I'm sorry I said "parents"... I should have said "some parents". I HATE it when people post things about "teachers" as a whole and then bash them. Of course there are bad teachers out there, but most of us are good. I know there are LOTS OF GREAT PARENTS out there, but the bad ones are REALLY killing my desire to continue teaching.

Okay.. I feel better now! ;)


There is room for improvement on the school side of things. In our Mass district, way too much money is spent on new and improved programs that, for instance, require 7 soft cover math books for each student per year (Connected Math :sad2: ), when the Catholic schools manage with ye olde textbook and pencil and paper.

That being said, the biggest problem is the PARENTS!!

The how dare you, not my kid parents. There is a breakdown in the American family and it started when it became okay for women to have babies and not be married or able to support those babies.

I don't have an answer, but I believe that there is nothing more important to a child's success in life than a committed, involved father.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom