The Official American Idol Season 8 Thread.

[The Wendy Bird]

I think we can almost all agree the worst ever American Idol winner was Taylor Hicks.

 

[crazytp93]

Im a big David Cook but he is absolutely not the best Idol has seen.
IMO, I dont think he is better than Adam.

Big Carrie Underwood fan too but I dont think shes best either.
I think Kelly Clarkson v.s. Carrie Underwood, Kelly would win in a heartbeat.



Psssh, nah.

lol.
i'm good with revenge.

 

[BabyPiglet]

I think we can almost all agree the worst ever American Idol winner was Taylor Hicks.

That season just kind of sucked. They didn't really have a better option, but he wasn't too bad. I actually wanted Kellie to win. I wasn't a Daughtry or Ace fan like most of the world was.

I'm not really a Jordin Sparks fan. I had forgotten she was even an AI until just now, that's how boring she was. That season sort of sucked too, what with Sanjaya and all. Without a doubt, Melinda was the best and she should've won.

I wasn't really a David Cook fan either (again, it's the whole 'rock' thing). Me and my mom really really wanted Carly or Micheal to win.

 

[The Wendy Bird]

That season just kind of sucked. They didn't really have a better option, but he wasn't too bad. I actually wanted Kellie to win. I wasn't a Daughtry or Ace fan like most of the world was.

I'm not really a Jordin Sparks fan. I had forgotten she was even an AI until just now, that's how boring she was. That season sort of sucked too, what with Sanjaya and all. Without a doubt, Melinda was the best and she should've won.

I wasn't really a David Cook fan either (again, it's the whole 'rock' thing). Me and my mom really really wanted Carly or Micheal to win.

I have to agree that season did suck. I did like Daughtry and think he has been a success so far. Jordin Sparks like you said did not have a personality. I loved Kellie Pickler and I still do.
The whole Sanjaya thing was just stupid.

I thought David Archeleta was better and I loved Michael Johns.

 

[disneychick2721]

Kelly Clarkson is amazing. I really think Ruben Studdard had an awesome voice for what type of music he sings.

I think we can almost all agree the worst ever American Idol winner was Taylor Hicks.

Ah yes I love Kelly Clarkson with a passion. Her music is so freaking good.
Ruben was good at the time.

Yes. I think we can definitly agree that Taylor sucked.
Chris should have won.

Anyone think this is hinting something ? Daughtry is performing tonight...
EVERYONE thought Chris Daughtry would win, he got off fourth.
EVERYONE thinks/thought Adam is going to win, down to four.
Hmmm ?

lol.
i'm good with revenge.

im better.

That season just kind of sucked. They didn't really have a better option, but he wasn't too bad. I actually wanted Kellie to win. I wasn't a Daughtry or Ace fan like most of the world was.

I'm not really a Jordin Sparks fan. I had forgotten she was even an AI until just now, that's how boring she was. That season sort of sucked too, what with Sanjaya and all. Without a doubt, Melinda was the best and she should've won.

I wasn't really a David Cook fan either (again, it's the whole 'rock' thing). Me and my mom really really wanted Carly or Micheal to win.

I thought that was one of the best seasons. with the expection of a few people.

I liked Jordin. Her album was pretty good. Shes touring with the JB this summer.

Carly had the rock thing going on..

 

[StitchfansJr]

hahahahahaha. funny ad. xD

 

[Captain Brain]

Im a big David Cook but he is absolutely not the best Idol has seen.
IMO, I dont think he is better than Adam.

Big Carrie Underwood fan too but I dont think shes best either.
I think Kelly Clarkson v.s. Carrie Underwood, Kelly would win in a heartbeat.



Psssh, nah.

If Kelly and Carrie ever had a singoff, it would be impossible to have a winner. They both can sing amazingly, but they sing two different types of music. They couldn't sing a third party genre's song, because they both can do great covers. (Home Sweet Home, by Carrie, for example)

Out of all the runners up, I think that David Archuleta has the best voice, by the way.

 

[Captain Brain]

Ah yes I love Kelly Clarkson with a passion. Her music is so freaking good.
Ruben was good at the time.

Yes. I think we can definitly agree that Taylor sucked.
Chris should have won.

Anyone think this is hinting something ? Daughtry is performing tonight...
EVERYONE thought Chris Daughtry would win, he got off fourth.
EVERYONE thinks/thought Adam is going to win, down to four.
Hmmm ?



im better.



I thought that was one of the best seasons. with the expection of a few people.

I liked Jordin. Her album was pretty good. Shes touring with the JB this summer.

Carly had the rock thing going on..

I love Jordin. She's performing next week, actually. Her new song is called Battlefield.

 

[crazytp93]

Ah yes I love Kelly Clarkson with a passion. Her music is so freaking good.
Ruben was good at the time.

Yes. I think we can definitly agree that Taylor sucked.
Chris should have won.

Anyone think this is hinting something ? Daughtry is performing tonight...
EVERYONE thought Chris Daughtry would win, he got off fourth.
EVERYONE thinks/thought Adam is going to win, down to four.
Hmmm ?



im better.



I thought that was one of the best seasons. with the expection of a few people.

I liked Jordin. Her album was pretty good. Shes touring with the JB this summer.

Carly had the rock thing going on..

we shall see

 

[The Wendy Bird]

Ah yes I love Kelly Clarkson with a passion. Her music is so freaking good.
Ruben was good at the time.

Yes. I think we can definitly agree that Taylor sucked.
Chris should have won.

Anyone think this is hinting something ? Daughtry is performing tonight...
EVERYONE thought Chris Daughtry would win, he got off fourth.
EVERYONE thinks/thought Adam is going to win, down to four.
Hmmm ?



im better.



I thought that was one of the best seasons. with the expection of a few people.

I liked Jordin. Her album was pretty good. Shes touring with the JB this summer.

Carly had the rock thing going on..

That would be quite intersting if that scenerio happened.

 

[Axel]

That season just kind of sucked. They didn't really have a better option, but he wasn't too bad. I actually wanted Kellie to win. I wasn't a Daughtry or Ace fan like most of the world was.

I'm not really a Jordin Sparks fan. I had forgotten she was even an AI until just now, that's how boring she was. That season sort of sucked too, what with Sanjaya and all. Without a doubt, Melinda was the best and she should've won.

I wasn't really a David Cook fan either (again, it's the whole 'rock' thing). Me and my mom really really wanted Carly or Micheal to win.

I, too, dislike Jordin Sparks. And I agree, Melinda was good. But I'm a Blaker girl...I loves me some Blake. Or some Chris. How about some Cake?! *I crack myself up sometimes*.

As for Kelly vs. Carrie? Kelly, hands down, is the better of the two.

 

[The Wendy Bird]

I, too, dislike Jordin Sparks. And I agree, Melinda was good. But I'm a Blaker girl...I loves me some Blake. Or some Chris. How about some Cake?! *I crack myself up sometimes*.

As for Kelly vs. Carrie? Kelly, hands down, is the better of the two.

What ever happened to Blake? I thought he was amazing with his voice and beat boxing and of course he was hot.

 

[TinkRockz106]

everybody can see that the finale 2 are going to be ..Allison Iraheta and Adam Lambert!!

Lets go Allison Iraheta!1

Lets go Adam Lambert!

 

[saratogadreamin09]

David Cook was really good as was David Archeleta, but David Cook was kinda like Chris Daughtry from the previous year. In my opinion Adam has more of a smooth voice and also very powerful.

I hated david archuletta, he always looked so weird and he couldnt sing anything but slow songs. IMO, Adams voice is not smooth, its very rough (which isnt a bad thing)

Im a big David Cook but he is absolutely not the best Idol has seen.
IMO, I dont think he is better than Adam.

Big Carrie Underwood fan too but I dont think shes best either.
I think Kelly Clarkson v.s. Carrie Underwood, Kelly would win in a heartbeat.



Psssh, nah.

Kelly Clarkson is great, but Carrie Underwoods voice is so pure and natural. Same with Cook, they both have such pure voice and such raw talent

I think we can almost all agree the worst ever American Idol winner was Taylor Hicks.

ITA

That season just kind of sucked. They didn't really have a better option, but he wasn't too bad. I actually wanted Kellie to win. So did I, so many people I knew didnt like her just because she was a dumb blonde I wasn't a Daughtry or Ace fan like most of the world was.

I'm not really a Jordin Sparks fan. I had forgotten she was even an AI until just now, that's how boring she was. That season sort of sucked too, what with Sanjaya and all. Without a doubt, Melinda was the best and she should've won. ITA, i remember cheering for Melinda from the audition week, she was AMAZING

I wasn't really a David Cook fan either (again, it's the whole 'rock' thing). Me and my mom really really wanted Carly or Micheal Michael was amazing, I dont think he shold have won but he should have made the top 5to win.

 

[The Wendy Bird]

everybody can see that the finale 2 are going to be ..Allison Iraheta and Adam Lambert!!

Lets go Allison Iraheta!1

Lets go Adam Lambert!

That is what I am hoping.

 

[saratogadreamin09]

If Kelly and Carrie ever had a singoff, it would be impossible to have a winner. They both can sing amazingly, but they sing two different types of music. They couldn't sing a third party genre's song, because they both can do great covers. (Home Sweet Home, by Carrie, for example)

Out of all the runners up, I think that David Archuleta has the best voice, by the way.

IMO, Clay Akein was the best runner-up by far. He was so much better then Ruben and should have won that season

 

[The Wendy Bird]

I hated david archuletta, he always looked so weird and he couldnt sing anything but slow songs. IMO, Adams voice is not smooth, its very rough (which isnt a bad thing)



Kelly Clarkson is great, but Carrie Underwoods voice is so pure and natural. Same with Cook, they both have such pure voice and such raw talent



ITA

The David's last year we good, but I think Adam is better.

I agree that Kelly is great and the success has showed. Carrie Underwood has an amazing voice for her genre.

 

[saratogadreamin09]

I thought Season 7 was the best season ever


I loved everyone in the top 12 and I didnt really pick a fav untill the top 6. Everybody had such great voices and was so likeable. Its going to be hard to every top season 7 in my mind

 

[saratogadreamin09]

The David's last year we good, but I think Adam is better.

I agree that Kelly is great and the success has showed. Carrie Underwood has an amazing voice for her genre.

There is no question that Adam is better then Arhie

But Id love to see Adam try to do half the songs that David Cook did and do them as well. I just cant see Adam doing "Always Be My Baby" or "First Time Ever I Saw Your Face"

 

[The Wendy Bird]

IMO, Clay Akein was the best runner-up by far. He was so much better then Ruben and should have won that season

I thought Ruben had a better voice overall then Clay, but Clay had way more personality than Ruben.

There is no question that Adam is better then Arhie

But Id love to see Adam try to do half the songs that David Cook did and do them as well. I just cant see Adam doing "Always Be My Baby" or "First Time Ever I Saw Your Face"

I think he could do those songs and do them well. He really has only had one week this season that was not close to the best performance of the night. Of course this is just my opinion. I still think Adam has this season wrapped up.