Creepiest thing to ever be true? A boy feared a monster in his closet and was bullied for it. In the end, his older brother went into the closet to prove it was false, but when they opened it again, only his clothes remained...
Watched Beyond Belief: Fact of Fiction. I read that one on the internet a few months ago and just reading it freaked me out. It was on the episode right now, and it was still freaky.