We had ADRs at California Grill for 9:10 pm. We left POFQ around 8:45ish and arrived with a few minutes to spare. How nice to be able to jump in the car 20 minutes before an ADR and arrive on time! We will never go to Disney without a car again

.
As we arrived we saw the new restaurant--The Wave--next to the front desk. We had talked about possibly trying to go there for dinner on the night we were going to Pleasure Island, but when I called we couldn't get anything for earlier than 8 to 9 pm. (Originally we wanted to go to Wolfgang Puck Cafe but were told they only do walk ups. Later I found out that they actually take reservations but not through Disney, but there were none available for that night so we weren't sure we wanted to take our chances with doing walk-up.) We stopped to take a look at the menu and GF suggested that we ask the concierge about an ADR. We did and the castmember found an ADR in the 6pm hour right away--but for 4 instead of 2. She booked it and said, "Just tell them the other two in your party decided to stay at Magic Kingdom." So we got exactly the time we wanted

.
We headed up to the 2nd floor to check in and were given a pager. We were told it was a 20-25 minute wait at that point and were sent over to the elevator. About 30 seconds later the pager went off before we had even gotten off of the elevator.
We walked over to the hostess who took our pager and said--in a French accent--"Mr. and Mrs. Smith." I think I must not have been processing because I just nodded without thinking at first before I actually processed what she was saying.
Now GF does wear men's clothes and she does have short hair. And some people do refer to her as a male after a quick glance sometimes. But usually on second glance the breasts make them realize their mistake. At the very least, we usually see a moment of realization cross their face. But in this case, the hostess didn't seem to notice that GF is female. She just seated us and told us our server would be right with us.
We thought it was odd that not only did she assume that GF was male, but she also just assumed that we were a married couple, and that we shared the same last name, and that I use the title "Mrs." We couldn't help but

. For the rest of the dinner i kept referring to GF as "Mr. Smith."
Here is what we ordered:
DinnerCalifornia Grill
Iced tea x 24.38
Big Bang Roll19
Scilian Flatbread (charged as pork apple flat bread on the receipt strangely?)12
Kappachio fish33
Vegetarian Unplugged19
Cheese plate17
Peachy keen dessert10
Tax7.44
Total121.82 4 M credits
Our server was very nice and helpful as we asked what we thought of a couple of dishes. We decided to use one dessert credit for a cheese plate for our first course. Strangely we ended up not getting any bread--the first thing they brought us was the cheese plate and after that out came the appetizers.
The cheese plate was delicious as always. Actually this was one of the best ones we've had at any restaurant in Disney.
The left-most cheese was a soft brie that called "Brillat Savarin." It tasted like honey and it was great with some honey on top (though honey wasn't actually the accompaniment meant for that cheese). The description of the cheese plate explained that the cheese was named after a French 18th century gourmet who is famous for his quote "tell me what you eat, and I will tell you who you are." That's taking food just a little too serious for us

. But If we are what we eat, then GF is definitely a fish of some kind, and I am a block of sugar.
The other cheeses were Mahon (cow's milk described as sharp, lemony, salty), Monte Enebro (goat cheese), Pecorino Foja di Noce (sheep's milk), Fourme d'Ambert (blue cheese). I also liked the Mahon, Pecorino, and the blue, but I was not so into the goat. GF liked every cheese on the plate and didnt find any of them offensive (usually there's at least one she finds at least one disgusting). All were delicious. It was one of the top cheese plates weve had.
After the cheese plate came the Sicilian flatbread and the Big Bang Roll.
The flatbread usually came with Sopressata, Tomato Compote, Provolone Cheese and Pepperoncini Relish. I asked for the sopressata (some type of meat) to be taken off. The first bite I took of the flatbread was not so greatit seemed to be missing something. I realized that bite didnt include any pepperoncinithe second bite was much better with the relish on it. But I do think that the meat probably would really have made a difference. It just didn't seem like as good a dish as we're used to at the California Grill.
GF felt similarly about it. She thought it was something which would be good at a mid-price Italian restaurant, but she expected more at Cali Grill. It did give us good idea for making something like that at home though.
The sushi arrived on long thin plate. It was pretty to look atlots of fish eggs of 2-3 different colors. Strangely it was served with no soy sauce, but with a huge blob of wasabi, a thick brown sauce, and lots of ginger. GF really wanted soy sauce as the brown sauce didnt do it for her, but she did without. She enjoyed the sushi, but as usual it wasnt anything special. She said she felt like she could have gotten it for $6.95 at local sushi restaurant--that it included two tasteless kinds of fish, and a couple of crunchy things she couldnt identify, and then eggs. (Every time we've gone to CG and she gets sushi because no other appetizer appeals to her and she's disappointed. Next time we go Im going to make her get veggie appetizer so I can have some since she doesn't really appreciate the sushi anyway!)
Time for entrees. My Vegetarian Unplugged had four dishes: 1) heirloom tomato flatbread (2 pieces): tomato, provolone, roasted garlic, arugula, 2) salad with blue, sweet toasted nuts, and peaches, 3) gnocchi/mushroom/corn dish, and 4) unknown (potatoes, tomatoes, some kind of paste/pate thing.
I couldnt identify #4 and didnt really like it that much, so I didn't eat much of it. Looking at the menus now, I suspect that it was the side which was served with the salmon: roasted Fingerling Potatoes, Yellow Beans, and Porcini Mushroom Vinaigrette. #3 was very good. It was served with the Seared Hawaiian Kona Kampachi which GF had. #2 was also good, though it was only a salad so less exciting. And #1 was a better flatbread than the Sicilian one which we had for an appetizer. It was probably was better as a vegetarian flatbread because it was designed that way--not made vegetarian by me asking them to remove the meat.
GF got the Seared Hawaiian Kona Kampachi.
It was the first entrée at CG she really loved. She said the fish was cooked amazingly wellit was buttery, moist, tender on the inside, and slightly crispy on the outside. She liked the sauce which came with it--a creamy butter and corn like sauce. She though the corn and gnocchi and seaweed side dish was a little less successful. The corn and gnocchi was good on its own, but with buttery bland fish nothing really stood out; she thought the side needed to be more flavorful. But still, the fish was the highlight of the dish and she enjoyed it a great deal.
Since we had used one of our dessert credits for the cheese plate we only had one dessert credit to share. We usually get the Bananas Buzz at CG, but decided to try something new this time. We compromised and went with the Peachy Keen: Peach Cheesecake, Bellini "Bubble Tea", Spiced Tea Cake with Vanilla Creme Glace.
GF was very pleased with the dessert. Splitting it meant it was not too much at end of a large meal. Her favorite of the three items was the bubble tea because it tasted like "fresh squeezed peach juice with hint of sugar." I did not like the bubble tea very much because it only had a hint of sugar! She thought the tea cake with vanilla creme was really goodflavorful and rich but not too sweet. She didnt like cheesecake as much and the peaches on top of the cheesecake had "a weird spicy taste" which she didnt enjoy. But overall thought it was perfect end to the meal.
I was surprised about how good it was. I dont usually love peach, but I was feeing full so was up for most anything. I thought GF would really like that dessert so I said yes to that one. The bubble tea didn't do much for me, but the other two desserts were yummy.
Overall this was a great meal. It's pretty much always our favorite and this trip didn't disappoint.