I am a planner, I enjoy it mostly. Its part of enjoying the trip before taking it, in some ways. I have done the ADR race for restaurants, done the fp race in the parks at rope drop, and am familiar enough with the disney parks to know what I am doing once we are in there.
Sometimes, its the thrill of the hunt that I love. Scored a great ressie at a great time, slipped into the single riders line with the kids and literally walk on a ride that has an hour wait,, ect.
But this new way of booking fp's , I don't love. I mean, I love the idea that I don't have to be the runner, criss crossing the park for the team. I love that I can pick the actual hour I want to ride an attraction (at this point in time, anyways), so I can plan what area of the park I want to be in, and not have to criss cross all over to avoid lines. I picked my restaurants 180 days in advance so I knew what park I was planning to be in, so have to pick the fp's for that day is not that big of a deal. Thats the arm chair planner in me - we only go every couple of years, so sitting down and figuring this out is enjoyable for me (not for everyone - I completely understand that).
Here are the 'buts' in new system.
1. Being a 'vet' that educates herself on boards like these on how to maximize, or get what you want, does not mean that I can get what I want. For example, the BOG dinner ressie, no matter how well you are armed, its very likely that you can't get it, even if you are staying onsite. Shut out. I don't have any interest in eating here for dinner, but I find it mildly alarming that if I did, I might not, or could not get it. The Anna Elsa meet and greet are becoming next to impossible as well. (I did manage to get one at 45 days out, by sheer dumb luck, but we ended up dropping it because the time sucked, and the girls said they would rather do other things.)
2. Relating to point #1, I think that as more people, i.e. the average traveler starts using mickeys system, the more 'things' will be impossible to get, or very hard to get, unless you are booking at midnight on the first day it becomes available to you. So, 7dmt might be next to impossible, or Soarin or TSMM. As an arm chair planner, I want to keep switching things maybe to massage the perfect plan, and if the number of 'must dos' become white rinos, i.e., the harder its going to get what you want, or to change the plan. I love massaging the schedules or outlines as our trip comes closer, but this may become impossible.
3. I love planning, but half the time when we are in the park, we throw out the 'plan' and do different things, because we feel like it, or someone is sick, or a ride is down, or its piss pouring rain. And being a savvy vet, I know how to still have a lot of fun in the park on the fly. With this new system in place, I am not as confident, because of the impact on all those fun, high capacity rides that we could jump on before, are now bunged up and slowed down with fp+s. And if we have not used up all our fp+s for the day already, and or if those kiosks are miles deep with the public, it could be a real problem for me.
4. The mouse tinkers with park hours and emh schedules, that could render your 'perfect' plan useless. You can't change it because of your ressies, or elusive fp+s, and you can end up frustrated and feeling screwed. After all, you jumped through all the hoops, did all the booking, and now your 'plan' has been tampered with by the park hours god.
5. Weather: We are going to be there in less then a week, and I have been watching how big long storms that are really wrecking havoc with rides going down. Being locked into fp+s will particularly suck for things like the 7dmt. I hold only one fp+ for it, and don't want to do the rope drop race for this ride. Our time for 7dmt is later at night, on our last night, which may have been poor planing on my part. Cant change it now, and I guess if weather (or ride mechanism) does not cooperate, we just won't be seeing it. I am really glad I did not do any mid afternoon fps, but could imagine that people who did all afternoon fp's would have been pretty frustrated this summer because it would have botched their day for sure. I know Disney can't control the weather, but it can really impact on a day that has been preplanned down to scheduled rides. Snowball effect.
Now, I compare all of this to my Uni portion of our trip.
Step 1: book on site
Step 2: enjoy
Universal is the vacation from our vacation. Even the planner in me loves the little to no planning needed. Sure we have to work around the DA opening craze, and will probably do EE to get a shot at gringotts, but I know I don't have to subsequently plan the rest of the day, or fret at what time we will be done, because everything else is easy.
I absolutely prefer Universal over Disney these days. Sorry Mickey!