
I don’t know enough about how lawyers use this type of information to craft an argument in front of a judge, but as a citizen (and that’s where jury’s come from), it sure looks to me these folks were taken advantage of.
I am not sure that I am going to go that far…because there is an assumption that people selling felt coerced into signing…meaning if I was a jury member I wouldn’t necessarily come to that conclusion.
Some may have cared less. When it went down, some owners paid without hesitation and some signed too.
But, if the extension was approved in a way that didn’t match the law at the time of what was required…which I think may have needed an owner vote,,,and its determined that DVD didn’t follow the correct rules, then I would think remedy comes into play.
IMO, the remedies might be making the extension null and void…and going back to 20242.
Impossible for that as too much time has passed and many bought new with that.
I don’t see where they would decide that owners are entitled to 15 years free with just cost of dues.
So, my guess is it probably would be something else and I’d lean thst the appropriate remedy is to allow owners who did neither to still pay for the extension at the initial price so they can sell or keep with 2057, or sign a quit claim.
At least those are the remedies I think correct the wrong, if it’s determined that the way they extended the ground lease, without a vote of owners, was not proper.
Even the actual language I have seen states all contracts are extended so that new language from 2017 may not need to be used.
What it’s going to come down to is how many owners who still own who did neither want to fight it and how many owners who sold but felt coerced into signing a quit claim want to fight for something they no longer own.
We shall see!