The demise of unrestricted resorts, by year.

I suspect they are cranky because in Florida a remedy exists. A Florida judge can nullify a quit claim deed if it can be proven that it was signed under duress, or coerced. Forcing someone to sign a quit claim deed that they had the legal right to abstain from signing, after assigning a “scarlet letter” 2042 expiration date (which artificially devalued their real estate interest), then in some cases, acquiring this cheap real estate through ROFER and marking it up to the correct 2057 valuation before reselling it for a profit … 😮 what genius cooked this idea up 🤦‍♀️
Now the question becomes if you signed a quit claim deed and sold your shares. Did the statute of limitations expire on you at some point? In other words are the only plaintiffs left the ones who never sold and never signed a quit claim? (These owners exist).
 
I suspect they are cranky because in Florida a remedy exists. A Florida judge can nullify a quit claim deed if it can be proven that it was signed under duress, or coerced. Forcing someone to sign a quit claim deed that they had the legal right to abstain from signing, after assigning a “scarlet letter” 2042 expiration date (which artificially devalued their real estate interest), then in some cases, acquiring this cheap real estate through ROFER and marking it up to the correct 2057 valuation before reselling it for a profit … 😮 what genius cooked this idea up 🤦‍♀️

Now the question becomes if you signed a quit claim deed and sold your shares. Did the statute of limitations expire on you at some point? In other words are the only plaintiffs left the ones who never sold and never signed a quit claim? (These owners exist).
This is what I was going to ask...do I as someone who purchased a quit claimed OKW contract have any legitimate case? Would it have to be the seller who signed it that would argue it was under duress? This is going to get messy at some point. I would love to know numbers...how many OKW original owners are left. How many quit claims were signed. etc. Although many original owners won't be around in 2042 all it would take is one...or the heirs of one to get the ball rolling on some sort of litigation. Or really I guess anyone involved could. I guess for arguments sake a resale owner like me could try to make the case that when I went to purchase an OKW contract I did so with the intention of it being in it's original state and never wanted a quit claimed version. It's still so far away but it is fun to speculate.
 
Now the question becomes if you signed a quit claim deed and sold your shares. Did the statute of limitations expire on you at some point? In other words are the only plaintiffs left the ones who never sold and never signed a quit claim? (These owners exist).
🤷🏼‍♀️ if you want to sell your real estate, specifically an OKW condominium, you have no reasonable alternative than to sign a quit claim deed which creates a defect on the property and lowers its value. If you don’t sign the document, DVD will block the sale of your property. Is there a statute of limitations on this? I have no idea, because it’s an ongoing scheme.
 
Last edited:
Florida timeshare law specifically states that when the ground lease was extended the new date takes the place of the original dates as if it (the original date) never existed.
I’ve not read this - do you know when the law was passed? I know I read that several owners had their lawyers write letters to DVC challenging the requirement that they pay or sign right then and there, but I don’t recall anyone saying that there was a law to that effect. It was only that there was a theory to that effect.

If such a law existed before the OKW extension was created, then I don’t know why no one challenged it in court. Social media wasn’t what it is today, though.
 
I’ve not read this - do you know when the law was passed? I know I read that several owners had their lawyers write letters to DVC challenging the requirement that they pay or sign right then and there, but I don’t recall anyone saying that there was a law to that effect. It was only that there was a theory to that effect.

If such a law existed before the OKW extension was created, then I don’t know why no one challenged it in court. Social media wasn’t what it is today, though.
I don’t know the date, but it is available. The last page of the timeshare statutes provides a revision history. I’ll look for it later today.
 
I’ve not read this - do you know when the law was passed? I know I read that several owners had their lawyers write letters to DVC challenging the requirement that they pay or sign right then and there, but I don’t recall anyone saying that there was a law to that effect. It was only that there was a theory to that effect.

If such a law existed before the OKW extension was created, then I don’t know why no one challenged it in court. Social media wasn’t what it is today, though.
The statute regarding timeshare extensions is 721.1255 and it was created in 2017. 721.1255 (2)(a) is the subsection that states that the extension is applied retroactively to the association documents. Statute 65.061 allows a quit claim deed to be nullified by quiet title action if it was improperly obtained by undue influence.
 
Last edited:
The statute regarding timeshare extensions is 721.1255 and it was created in 2017. 721.1255 (2)(a) is the subsection that states that the extension is applied retroactively to the association documents.

So, you wonder if this is what might play a role since it states it’s retroactive?

But, what I think this certainly supports is DVzd won’t be doing any future extensions.
 
So, you wonder if this is what might play a role since it states it’s retroactive?

But, what I think this certainly supports is DVzd won’t be doing any future extensions.
🤷🏼‍♀️ I don’t know enough about how lawyers use this type of information to craft an argument in front of a judge, but as a citizen (and that’s where jury’s come from), it sure looks to me these folks were taken advantage of.
 
🤷🏼‍♀️ I don’t know enough about how lawyers use this type of information to craft an argument in front of a judge, but as a citizen (and that’s where jury’s come from), it sure looks to me these folks were taken advantage of.
Hmm, I wonder whether any attorneys see enough $ in it for them to make it worthwhile to file suit. Doesn’t seem like it so far.
 
🤷🏼‍♀️ I don’t know enough about how lawyers use this type of information to craft an argument in front of a judge, but as a citizen (and that’s where jury’s come from), it sure looks to me these folks were taken advantage of.

I am not sure that I am going to go that far…because there is an assumption that people selling felt coerced into signing…meaning if I was a jury member I wouldn’t necessarily come to that conclusion.

Some may have cared less. When it went down, some owners paid without hesitation and some signed too.

But, if the extension was approved in a way that didn’t match the law at the time of what was required…which I think may have needed an owner vote,,,and its determined that DVD didn’t follow the correct rules, then I would think remedy comes into play.

IMO, the remedies might be making the extension null and void…and going back to 20242.

Impossible for that as too much time has passed and many bought new with that.

I don’t see where they would decide that owners are entitled to 15 years free with just cost of dues.

So, my guess is it probably would be something else and I’d lean thst the appropriate remedy is to allow owners who did neither to still pay for the extension at the initial price so they can sell or keep with 2057, or sign a quit claim.

At least those are the remedies I think correct the wrong, if it’s determined that the way they extended the ground lease, without a vote of owners, was not proper.

Even the actual language I have seen states all contracts are extended so that new language from 2017 may not need to be used.

What it’s going to come down to is how many owners who still own who did neither want to fight it and how many owners who sold but felt coerced into signing a quit claim want to fight for something they no longer own.

We shall see!
 
I think there has been some speculation about whether there would be ways for them to put entire units (assuming they own them all) into the trust in 2042. But I think the units that have been extended, even if just partially, would have to remain available to all owners of the O14 until 2057 - it’s the same association and that doesn’t change in 2042.

I think it just further emphasizes the mess they have in their hands. Would there even be entire units Disney owns in 2042? Seems pretty tough. I sort of think that a more likely answer is continued sales of OKW maybe with a true fire sale in 2042 if they need to.
 
I am not sure that I am going to go that far…because there is an assumption that people selling felt coerced into signing…meaning if I was a jury member I wouldn’t necessarily come to that conclusion.

Some may have cared less. When it went down, some owners paid without hesitation and some signed too.

But, if the extension was approved in a way that didn’t match the law at the time of what was required…which I think may have needed an owner vote,,,and its determined that DVD didn’t follow the correct rules, then I would think remedy comes into play.

IMO, the remedies might be making the extension null and void…and going back to 20242.

Impossible for that as too much time has passed and many bought new with that.

I don’t see where they would decide that owners are entitled to 15 years free with just cost of dues.

So, my guess is it probably would be something else and I’d lean thst the appropriate remedy is to allow owners who did neither to still pay for the extension at the initial price so they can sell or keep with 2057, or sign a quit claim.

At least those are the remedies I think correct the wrong, if it’s determined that the way they extended the ground lease, without a vote of owners, was not proper.

Even the actual language I have seen states all contracts are extended so that new language from 2017 may not need to be used.

What it’s going to come down to is how many owners who still own who did neither want to fight it and how many owners who sold but felt coerced into signing a quit claim want to fight for something they no longer own.

We shall see!
I guess the natural moment for the suit would be in 2042 when owners who didn’t sign a quit claim have their points removed from the DVC system.

The owner then contacts DVC and says “please restore my account to the current expiration, what you just did was unlawful.”
Disney says no we disagree, and then suit is filed by the 2042 expired owner and their attorney files for class certification and off we go.

Like so many consumer class actions, it probably ends with everyone getting an AT&T calling card in the mail as part of the settlement and the attorney collects a ridiculous legal fee lol.
 
The 2042 OKW owners & the rest of us will get updated. The way the UY points are currently listed in membership is current UY plus next 3. In the 2039 UY, 2042 will be posted. If contract shows “0”. That’s their fate.
 
I guess the natural moment for the suit would be in 2042 when owners who didn’t sign a quit claim have their points removed from the DVC system.
that is really playing the long game and maybe Disney is banking on those original owners not even having those contracts anymore.
The 2042 OKW owners & the rest of us will get updated. The way the UY points are currently listed in membership is current UY plus next 3. In the 2039 UY, 2042 will be posted. If contract shows “0”. That’s their fate.
You are right, it will become apparent in 2039, so they have time to mount a legal case prior to the expiration. Of course, wouldn't it actually have to be arbitration? I know in my direct contract I had to sign an agreement for arbitration instead of litigation.
 
The 2042 OKW owners & the rest of us will get updated. The way the UY points are currently listed in membership is current UY plus next 3. In the 2039 UY, 2042 will be posted. If contract shows “0”. That’s their fate.

If you read the multi site POS, it already makes clear what DVDs positon is on this matter.

Owners who did not extend contracts end 2042.

So, at least at this point, it seems one will have to fight
 
I guess the natural moment for the suit would be in 2042 when owners who didn’t sign a quit claim have their points removed from the DVC system.

The owner then contacts DVC and says “please restore my account to the current expiration, what you just did was unlawful.”
Disney says no we disagree, and then suit is filed by the 2042 expired owner and their attorney files for class certification and off we go.

Like so many consumer class actions, it probably ends with everyone getting an AT&T calling card in the mail as part of the settlement and the attorney collects a ridiculous legal fee lol.

It also assumes that there will be original owners who actually want the extra 15 years worth of use and dues.

Unless owners start well before, this would need to make it through the courts and it could take years for owners to have accounts reinstated if DVD sticks with the positon that owners aren’t entitled to the extra years if they didn’t pay.

So, even if it’s a win, how many of those actual years will they get.
 








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom