Tell me about Mama Melrose...Good choice??

Been once and enjoyed it our table had two steaks a flatbread and chicken pippetta and it was all good! Went in not knowing what to expect but we were happy with it and are going back in Sept!
 
I have never had a bad meal here and always have had good service. It is definitely my place of choice in the studios outside of the Hollywood Brown Derby.
 
DH and I enjoy Mama Melrose. We've actually been numerous times, for dinner (both with the F! package and without). I've seen lots of terrible reviews, but we've always had good food and good service. I would say in our experience, the food has been better than the service but nothing to really complain about.

Give it a try and form your own opinion! If it helps, DH and I are both Italian and while it's not the best Italian food, it's certainly not the worst (and we actually think it's pretty good).

We have an ADR there for dinner for our upcoming September trip! It's really the only place we'll eat TS at HS. We've tried the Brown Derby, but it wasn't worth 2 DDP credits in our opinions.

Good luck!
 

I really enjoyed it the one time I ate there. We had lunch in June last year. It was good. My son is sort of picky and he liked it. I liked the atmosphere there. And even in June it was not that crowded for lunch.
 
MM = Carabbas (a notch above)
Tony's = Olive Garden

IMHO and I am happy with all 4 choices.
 
We enjoy it every time. Everthing we have had has been good,the atmosphere, and the service as well as the food.
 
We didn't like it and we got sick after eating there but I will say that was quite a few years ago, we just haven't had the desire to go back. We have far better Italian food locally.

We much prefer Prime Time for dinner while in HS.
 
ill throw my two cents in here....
...this was my least favorite meal last trip. I wouldnt book it again, UNLESS i could get it for the fantasmic package ( the reason we ate there last time). This year i opted for h&v buffet (which also gets mixed reviews)

The food wasn't bad, it just wasn't good. The atmosphere isn't anything to write home about either. I wouldn't tell people not to go here though, as some people enjoy it very much. It just wasn't for us
 
This is my Dhs favorite restaurant. He usually gets the spicy sausage or the steak. I don't really like it here but go because DH loves it. I like the tomato and mozzerella as an appie and the desserts are good, loved the crema limon. But I have had the cheese flat bread (blah) Then I've had the eggplant 2x one of the times was better than the other but still not great. From looking at the menu on the disney world site the eggplant isn't available anymore. So, this year I might try the tuna. Other than that there is nothing appetizing to me on the menu.
 





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom